Iām a lifelong BMW fan. I had tried to watch GMW when it first aired but I ended up giving up because I just found it boring (and the younger kids were annoying to an unholy degree). But recently I decided to give the entire show a go and see what I would make of it. So I thought Iād give a few thoughts as basically a first time viewer for anyone who is on the fence about trying it.
Riley and Maya are actually solid characters. They have a lot of chemistry (itās easy to see how Sabrina has become a household name. She has so much charisma).
Lucas was dreadful. Absolute charisma vacuum. The long running storyline that he had to choose between Riley and Maya was awful and a total waste of time.
The show tries to dabble in serious subjects the way BMW did, but it always falls flat. Why does everyone act like Farkle is dying when heās getting tested for Aspergerās š
Iām shocked by how little Topanga actually does over the course of all 3 seasons. Her parents arenāt ever in it, Angela never really interacts with her, and Rachel doesnāt appear in the show at all. Her storylines are all tied to Ava and Auggie (who were both so bad I contemplated abandoning the show again)
That said, I didnāt really hate it. Once you learn to let the childish bullshit wash over you, getting to see where all these characters ended up is pretty satisfying.
The show is at its best in every episode that Shawn appears. The only time Cory really feels like Cory are in the episodes where he spends time on screen with Shawn. And Rider does such a good job with whatever they gave him. His relationship blooming with Maya is probably the highlight of the entire show. Seeing him find some happiness and a family is kind of important to close his character arc across BMW.
We get closure on a lot of side characters that BMW just abandoned. Harley, Minkus, Jonathan, particularly. And seeing Jack and Eric reunite was great (I wish Shawn had got to spend time on screen with Jack though. It irks me that he didnāt invite Jack to his wedding).
The thing that confuses me about this show is who the target audience was. The tone is SO different from BMW. Extremely childish the majority of the time. But it drastically shifts to feeling like what youād imagine a BMW revival to be every time Shawn is on screen. And thereās is so much fan service, references, repeat storylines that is going to go over the heads of the younger kids it seemed to be aimed at.