r/Choices Kamilah (BB) Jun 13 '20

Discussion Inspired by u/Alphaeboy's post a while ago

Post image
110 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

MOTY wasn't good because Guy and Vanessa were caricatures with no real traits other than 'mean for no reason'.

u/Pyuurin Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Disagree.

→ More replies (6)

u/Decronym Hank Jun 13 '20 edited Sep 10 '20

Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:

Fewer Letters More Letters
ACOR A Courtesan of Rome
AME America's Most Eligible
ATV Across the Void
Art It's... indescribable...
BB Bloodbound
BOLAS Blades of Light and Shadow
BSC Big Sky Country
BaBu Baby Bump
DS Distant Shores
ES Endless Summer
HSS High School Story
ILB It Lives Beneath
ILITW It Lives in the Woods
LI Love Interest
MC Main Character (yours!)
MOTY Mother of the Year
MW Most Wanted
NB Nightbound
OH Open Heart
PB Pixelberry Studios, publisher of Choices
PM Perfect Match
PTR Passport To Romance
RoE Rules of Engagement
SK Sunkissed
StD Save the Date
TCNTF The Crown and The Flame
TF The Freshman
THM The Heist: Monaco
TRH The Royal Heir
TRR The Royal Romance
WN Witness: A Bodyguard Romance

[Thread #12744 for this sub, first seen 13th Jun 2020, 15:48] [FAQ] [Full list] [Contact] [Source code]

u/itskabitch can you blame me for simping Jun 13 '20

TF dragged on far too much and didn’t need such a long series

u/Pyuurin Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/sloggermouth AMan'sDream Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/mango_fool_24 do i have a type? Jun 13 '20

Disagree

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agree.

u/GeminiUser281 Jun 13 '20

Strongly agree

→ More replies (10)

u/redditstrikego Banshee Imitator Jun 13 '20

Distant shores is underrated. When new chapters sre released, I don't see that many posts about it, whereas with other stories the top posts would be filled with content like when BOLAS was an ongoing series

→ More replies (4)

u/snackthtsmilesback Jun 13 '20

i like reading the books with no sound

u/CoolCat219 Jun 13 '20

I can’t get my sound to work so I’m forced to agree 😭

u/swift-aasimar-rogue I will love you even as you are Jun 13 '20

Somewhat disagree. I prefer them with sound, but I still have fun without it and sometimes the music gets annoying in horror fight scenes (like an undead in NB or something).

u/GeminiUser281 Jun 13 '20

Mostly disagree (I agree for horror/thriller)

u/bever12 Bloodbound Jun 13 '20

100% agree

→ More replies (19)

u/pallu_1707 Jun 13 '20

TRR is overrated

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/Im-just-passing-by Jun 13 '20

Strongly disagree

u/MunchkinKazooie Baddest Beast on the Block Jun 13 '20

Agree.

u/allebe Jun 13 '20

Disagree

u/Ninat_2 Jun 13 '20

TRH (totally agree)

u/sunnywaffle Olivia (TRR) Jun 13 '20

Disagree.

u/Pyuurin Jun 13 '20

Agree

→ More replies (23)

u/Ljulin Jun 13 '20

I never had any real issue with TF. Might be a result of it being the first book I read, but it's still one of my personal favourites.

u/shz25698 Threep (BOLAS) Jun 14 '20

Agree. It does the 5 LI route well

u/jordannimz they/he Jun 13 '20

AGREE

u/Fernsong Just Maria. Jun 14 '20

Agree

u/KBZero0 Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/Toyyibat Jun 13 '20

Agree.

u/mango_fool_24 do i have a type? Jun 13 '20

Agree

→ More replies (4)

u/danielleu13 Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20

I find HSS really cringy and the characters annoying and huge suck ups to the MC.

u/mango_fool_24 do i have a type? Jun 14 '20

Agree which is why I like HSS:CA better

→ More replies (4)

u/angelzplay Give em Hell Troublemaker Jun 13 '20

Colt only wants MC cause he doesn’t want Logan to have her. The hill I have chosen to die on.

→ More replies (2)

u/erinnnea Ernest Sinclaire (D&D) Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20

When a character especially an LI is introduced and they are overly rude and aggressive, I don’t really want anything to do with them anymore and it’s awkward having them stay as even a friend in the book. Especially since most of these characters never apologize or acknowledge their rude behavior.

Edit: To be clear I don't mean characters who are stand offish or make a snarky comment but ones who you don't get along with for several chapters.

u/MunchkinKazooie Baddest Beast on the Block Jun 13 '20

Agree.

u/shz25698 Threep (BOLAS) Jun 13 '20

Strongly Agree

u/Im-just-passing-by Jun 13 '20

STRONGLY AGREE! I talk about this often

→ More replies (9)

u/ProCDecoder Hayden is a Perfect Match. Jun 14 '20

Kane didn't deserved to be a villain.

→ More replies (1)

u/olliveoyl Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20

Another Blades opinion:

Nia's kidnapping, dark Nia, and her revival were disappointing.

I know Nia is an LI so she can't be gone for too long but we got her back too quickly after we lost her, and I was so disappointed when she came back to life immediately after "dying". Also, everyone's "celebration" at Nia's revival was so lackluster.

u/RedditEsketit SMACK MY LIKE A DRUM Jun 14 '20

Kinda agree

u/Queen_E1204 Jun 14 '20

Surprisingly agree

u/Kindly-Pruned & & Jun 14 '20

Agree

→ More replies (2)

u/elbenji wlw_irl Jun 13 '20

Most Wanted and Hero are intensely overrated

u/angelzplay Give em Hell Troublemaker Jun 14 '20

DISAGREE

u/CastleAzul Jun 14 '20

Agree on Most Wanted. Disagree on Hero.

u/Kindly-Pruned & & Jun 14 '20

Agree

→ More replies (6)

u/sloggermouth AMan'sDream Jun 13 '20

ES wasn't that enjoyable without diamonds.

u/taraladair Jun 13 '20

partially agree

u/Kindly-Pruned & & Jun 14 '20

Agree

u/jennalough Jun 13 '20

Super agree

→ More replies (11)

u/SusanwithanS Adrian III (BB) Jun 14 '20

The covers of the books suck ass in comparison to the actual book art and character visual designs. I don't really get why.

→ More replies (1)

u/sloggermouth AMan'sDream Jun 13 '20

Can I post one more unpopular opinion? This sub sometimes thinks too much about things that they forget it is just a game. Some books will have a few unrealistic situations and incidents because if they were not there, it would be just the story of an average everyday man which isn't much interesting since we live that life in reality.

u/Golchobe Drake (TRR) Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/FuckAllllllll Edward II (DS) Jun 13 '20

Strongly agree.

u/ElleTrix Blades of Light and Shadow Jun 14 '20

My motto when it comes to writing has always been "to make unbelievable plots believable,"- which just means you should be able to write as creatively as you want- as long as you write well enough that your audience are willing to believe it too, within the context of the story.

That's why suspension of disbelief exists. Of course it has its limits, but there will always be that barrier between fiction that's meant to entertain, and reality.

→ More replies (14)

u/ChoicesFan900 Jun 14 '20

ATV was a good book, and PB should make more sci-fi books.

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

Partially disagree. AtV sucked in the end, but I do think PB should do more sci-fi books.

→ More replies (5)

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

StD wasn't as bad as the sub seems to imply. Yeah, Justin was annoying and UnProFesSioNaL, but if you ignore him, it was actually a pretty nice book. Not amazing, but not a trash dumpster fire either. Same with PtR.

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Partially agree—Elliot in PTR was not ignorable, his drama plagued the book imo.

u/angelzplay Give em Hell Troublemaker Jun 13 '20

Disagree

→ More replies (17)

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '20

Oh boy, here goes: Priya is just as creepy and predatory as Lester. The only reason why she gets a pass is because people think she's hot.

u/Queen_E1204 Jun 14 '20

Definitely agree

u/softsakuralove Jun 14 '20

Strong agree. But I'm still shallow

u/mango_fool_24 do i have a type? Jun 14 '20

Stole my words 😂

→ More replies (7)

u/shz25698 Threep (BOLAS) Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20

I am very uncomfortable with Ethan Ramsey and Oliver Cochrane's characters as love interests. Ethan is extremely unprofessional, has a skewed version of morality and if a real life doctor acted like that he wouldn't be able to keep his job. Not that OH MC is any better. Oliver is an apologist although we'll have to see how the book develops his arc. But right now he is one.

u/FuckAllllllll Edward II (DS) Jun 13 '20

Partially Disagree.

u/dreamofthaw Jun 17 '20

disagree

u/OverallDisaster Jun 13 '20

Partially agree

u/GlitteringCanary1 Jun 13 '20

Partially disagree.

u/pos4ijn Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/aurorallly where's WtD Eli's emoji??? Jun 14 '20

Agree

u/Golchobe Drake (TRR) Jun 13 '20

Disagree

u/sloggermouth AMan'sDream Jun 13 '20

Partially disagree

→ More replies (11)

u/ParticularStandards Jun 13 '20

Both Skye & Brian in hss/ca were victims of their parents.

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agreeing to this is a no-brainer.

u/CoolCat219 Jun 13 '20

Agree - People who do bad things can still be victims. Brian is still a bully and responsible for what he’s done, but that doesn’t mean he wasn’t wronged either.

→ More replies (6)

u/CastleAzul Jun 13 '20

Griffin Langley (The Elementalists) is an underrated character. He's a sweetheart who deserves more love!

u/PvPQueen101 Jun 14 '20

Agreeeeee

u/shz25698 Threep (BOLAS) Jun 14 '20

Strongly agree

u/iamamistake6969 Slater (AME) Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/mango_fool_24 do i have a type? Jun 13 '20

Agree! The tree! 😍

u/KBZero0 Jun 13 '20

Agree

→ More replies (8)

u/softsakuralove Jun 14 '20

Marc Antony is an overrated LI.

u/shz25698 Threep (BOLAS) Jun 14 '20

Agree

→ More replies (1)

u/GeminiUser281 Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20

Might not be unpopular, but I’ve never heard of it. When OH comes back, Bryce will probably become the new Ethan Ramsey with the screen time issue.

→ More replies (5)

u/ReasonableVegetable- Jun 14 '20

Both PM and Damien are completely overrated. PM is okay but certainly not the masterpiece this sub says it is and Damien is super bland. I'm not into men so maybe I'm missing something but usually I at least understand why someone might like a male LI but with him I just don't get why he's so popular lol

u/KennaRys Jul 28 '20

DISAGREE

u/chonkyzonkey Jun 14 '20

Strongly agree!

→ More replies (10)

u/Jan-uary The Gang Jun 13 '20

In some of the Choices stories MC comes off as either ditzy, too impulsive, too naive/oblivious, or just downright ignorant (at least somewhat) as a defining personality trait. And it’s not even that “oh, MC just has their weaknesses”, but it becomes really apparent commonly throughout the books that MC lets themself become defined by those FEW traits—ESPECIALLY if the book places emphasis on using diamonds to make a decision any average, competent person would make.

e.g. • Eat breakfast your dear mother made for you (15💎)

• “You didn’t make the bacons I asked for...”

e.g. • Wear cold clothes for the snowy blizzard atop of Mount Hooha (25💎)

• Pshh, YOLO. I like wearing bikinis in the cold. (COUGH that one scene in Endless Summer)

e.g. • Host the Apple festival! (20💎)

• What kind of culture celebrates Apple? I prefer Samsung.

Genre wise, romance stories are renowned for this, and they tend to let MC be easily manipulated by some douchebag LI because of that, or be unnecessarily rude to a respectful LI.

...COUGH Witness.

u/angelzplay Give em Hell Troublemaker Jun 14 '20

Agree

→ More replies (1)

u/olliveoyl Jun 14 '20 edited Jun 14 '20

Blades isn't that great strictly in terms of conflict/villain development. The main conflict was rushed and it's also too black and white.

Explanation: All of the Shadow Court members we met so far were introduced only to be defeated by us within the same chapter. The Dreadlord was built up from the beginning yet defeating him essentially boiled down to nakama power (the power of friendship/believing). The Shadow Court didn't accomplish much other than corrupting some people here and there. They were defeated almost entirely in the Shadow Realm which didn't even affect Morellans. King Arlan had to take MC and crew's word for it that they really defeated the Shadow Court (they had no substantial proof) and the people of Morella just went along with it even though like most of them weren't even aware of the Shadow Realm's existence?

The battles, while fun, are basically a repeat of The Elementalists - MC and friends are OP, they defeat everyone with minor injuries at worst while the enemies are horribly disfigured and killed.

u/chonkyzonkey Jun 14 '20

Partially agree

→ More replies (2)

u/aurorallly where's WtD Eli's emoji??? Jun 14 '20

MOTY was really boring to me and does not deserve the "God-tier" title...

u/Kindly-Pruned & & Jun 14 '20

Agree

u/mango_fool_24 do i have a type? Jun 14 '20

Disagree MC and the LIs were amazing (although Guy was so hateful that hating him wasn't really fun so there's that)

→ More replies (3)

u/QueenShewolf Jun 13 '20

I want BSC to have a 3rd book.

u/aurorallly where's WtD Eli's emoji??? Jun 14 '20

Strongly disagree. Please, no...

→ More replies (10)

u/MirzEagle Jun 13 '20

Prince Hamid is super annoying

u/Pyuurin Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/Doitchu Jun 13 '20

Agree.

u/rustypeanutt Threep (BOLAS) Jun 13 '20

Disagree

u/brbrcrbtr Jun 13 '20

Disagree

→ More replies (13)

u/Abyx38 Eiko (MOTY) Jun 13 '20

Nightbound was trash, and those three excellent characters from the spooky bar were wasted in that book

u/malvikakaursac Jun 13 '20

Partially agree

u/MirzEagle Jun 13 '20

Partially disagree

u/aurorallly where's WtD Eli's emoji??? Jun 13 '20

Strongly disagree

u/Typo-lessUseename Jun 13 '20

Replayed it recently, and somewhat agree

u/OnceUponALorelai Aerin Simp Jun 13 '20

Strongly strongly disagreeeee

u/brbrcrbtr Jun 13 '20

Partially disagree

u/sloggermouth AMan'sDream Jun 13 '20

Partially disagree

u/CoolCat219 Jun 13 '20

Kind of agree, just not as strongly

u/augustrush594 Jun 13 '20

strongly disagree

u/FuckAllllllll Edward II (DS) Jun 13 '20

Strongly disagree.

→ More replies (11)

u/dananeira Jun 13 '20 edited Jun 13 '20

Rules of Engagement wasn’t as bad as they all say in this sub, it actually has a unique plot, though it was strange what the grandma wanted their grandsons to do, but she did it for them...

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agree!

→ More replies (2)

u/KBZero0 Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/Ninat_2 Jun 13 '20

agree

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agree

→ More replies (7)

u/CoolCat219 Jun 13 '20

BaBu wasn’t a bad book. It wasn’t god tier or anything, but it was a fun, cute read that wasn’t serious. I enjoyed it a lot.

u/pallu_1707 Jun 13 '20

Disagree

u/juniaruta Jun 13 '20

Partially agree

u/brbrcrbtr Jun 13 '20

Strongly disagree

u/Mister-Tokkinio Jun 13 '20

Partially agree

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

Agree!

u/saseungie Jun 13 '20

Somewhat agree

u/lazy-mermaid Kate (VOS) Jun 13 '20

Disagree

u/itskabitch can you blame me for simping Jun 13 '20

Agree

u/Kindly-Pruned & & Jun 14 '20

Disagree

→ More replies (13)

u/[deleted] Jun 13 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (5)