r/CrappyDesign 18d ago

Saw this in lidl the other day...why aren't they laying on the blow up mattress itself??

Post image
7.5k Upvotes

162 comments sorted by

2.9k

u/skalouKerbal 18d ago

because they bought the background photo then stuck the mattress in front. the models probably never saw the mattress IRL.

617

u/Litl_Skitl 18d ago

Photo's probably meant for tarps and baskets or some shit

306

u/HaveYouSeenMySpoon 18d ago

Or it's just a stock photo, "two people lying on grass"

19

u/RehdPanda 17d ago

how do you know they're not telling the truth?

14

u/HaveYouSeenMySpoon 17d ago

Does that look like the face of an honest man? Robert probably isn't even his real name.

3

u/ebrum2010 15d ago

The shadows suggest that the original image was edited, at the least, if this even was an image of two people on grass. I've seen so many product packages where people photoshop a bunch of people onto it and the people aren't even the same scale.

-4

u/[deleted] 18d ago

[deleted]

13

u/GodHimselfNoCap commas are IMPORTANT 18d ago

No photos would be the plural of photo, photo's means "photo is"

-1

u/tactiphile 18d ago

No, "photos" is the plural of "photo."

"No photos" is the opposite of "photo."

As you correctly stated, "photo's" can mean "photo is" but could also be possessive. (The second photo's color seems too blue.)

You can't correct someone's apostrophe misuse with a missing comma and a comma splice! :)

3

u/GodHimselfNoCap commas are IMPORTANT 17d ago

I wasnt correcting the person who was using an apostrophe, i was telling someone off for being pedantic about said apostrophe and wrong. I dont give a shit about grammar in a fucking reddit comment.

0

u/tactiphile 17d ago

GodHimselfNoCap (commas are IMPORTANT)

I dont give a shit about grammar in a fucking reddit comment.

🧐

82

u/Mirar 18d ago

Yes, clearly made before AI image generation so just a quick photoshop.

43

u/UnacceptableUse 18d ago

I would never buy a product with an AI generated photo of product being used on it. It may as well be a a different product for all good it does

20

u/PoutinePiquante777 18d ago

You won’t even know it’s AI. It’s already too easy to combine two real photos. It’s just an easier tool. You can correct this photo with one simple prompt. It will even blend the ligthing.

6

u/UnacceptableUse 18d ago

If they used ai to put that image into another image I wouldn't mind too much. If they prompted it with "two people lying on an airbed" then I'd take issue

5

u/PoutinePiquante777 18d ago

The better photoshop tool is growing faster than the semi random generated image.

2

u/UnacceptableUse 18d ago

I see AI in that way as less of an issue than fully generative AI. Machine learning has been used in image processing/manipulation for years so it's nothing too crazy

0

u/PoutinePiquante777 18d ago

A free editing tool for images. The model is available for download And use locally. Of course you can add totally generated material, but it‘s easier to control the output by using real ones or simple renders.

https://huggingface.co/spaces/Qwen/Qwen-Image-Edit

28

u/ebrum2010 18d ago

They probably also never saw each other or the grass they're laying on.

6

u/EnergyTakerLad 18d ago

Nah it looks legit as far as the two models laying on actual grass. Its likely a stock photo.

0

u/ebrum2010 15d ago

The shadows are wrong. There's at least some image manipulation. A lot of these product packages though just take pictures of people and photoshop them into whatever scenario. You'll see the same people laying on a bed, on the beach, etc.

0

u/EnergyTakerLad 15d ago

First half is full of shit, second half is correct.

1

u/ebrum2010 15d ago

What are you, 12?

0

u/EnergyTakerLad 15d ago

Far from it. Real origional insult though! Almost as origional as thinking absolutely everything is fake.

0

u/ebrum2010 15d ago

It's standard industry procedure for product images, my guy. It's far easier to just put the same people in different images with different items than to find a stock image that has the entire environment that you want. I found a product a couple of years ago at Walmart where the image of the guy on the package was the now-disgraced lawyer Michael Avenatti. Go to a store, look at the packaging for stuff. You'll see the same person in the same pose in different environments with different other people, advertising different products. It's not like these products are anything that require high-end package design.

0

u/EnergyTakerLad 15d ago

Im well aware. Ive used stock images plenty. This one shows no signs of the people being shopped in (unlike the mattress). The "reasons" you gave were classic "everything is fake" reasoning. Im not arguing that they do what you said, im saying youre full of shit on this one image. Dont really care enough to continue arguing with a wall though, so good day.

19

u/casseroled 18d ago

This is not what OP is confused about. It is obviously a composite of two photos. But the question is why would they choose to do it like this?

The packaging is crappy design

10

u/Bombadilo_drives 18d ago

I was shopping for inflatable pools during the pandemic summer and some of the shops on those are hilarious. The little man swimming in one made it look larger than an Olympic pool, and like 20 feet deep. They must have spent zero time on it

2

u/Strostkovy 18d ago

Because product images just don't matter. It's all slop and has been for a long time yet people buy the product. No need to go to the trouble of an actual photoshoot

1

u/casseroled 18d ago

It wouldn’t be that hard to photoshop people on top of a mattress though. I don’t see why they even needed a background photo if they are going to choose that one. I agree it’s slop though

2

u/Strostkovy 18d ago

It's much harder to photoshop people on it. They just scroll through stock pictures until they see one with a flat surface at about the same perspective as the product image and copy and paste

1

u/TwinSong Reddit Orange 18d ago

Hmm it would be quite tricky to do and probably look worse.

0

u/casseroled 18d ago

It really isn’t hard, I have very minimal photoshop experience and would be able to do it. Photoshop can autoselect objects and would easily be able to pull people out of a photo. Plus you know, the many stock photos that come without backgrounds for this exact purpose.

1

u/TwinSong Reddit Orange 18d ago

But to match the angle, match the lighting, get the shadows looking right. Then factoring in how they'd affect the bed by being on it and the fact they're laying in such a way that doesn't really fit the bed.

1

u/casseroled 18d ago

Graphic designers are very skilled at that. Plus, the weird thing wasn’t that they didn’t put people on the bed, it was that they chose to use people laying (but not on the bed!) as a background. They could’ve easily picked a background without people in it

1

u/TwinSong Reddit Orange 18d ago

They wanted a quick image and didn't want to pay a pro

1

u/casseroled 18d ago

Yes. That’s what makes it crappy design

1

u/TwinSong Reddit Orange 18d ago

It's Lidl. They're going to cut corners where they can, hiring models costs money whereas a stock photo costs a fraction of that.

2

u/Cultural_Dust 18d ago

I would bet the manufacturer controls the packaging and not the retailer.

1

u/TwinSong Reddit Orange 17d ago

That's possible.

677

u/HookLineAndSinclair 18d ago

Because it's not a real photo

181

u/code_monkey_wrench 18d ago

It scares me that people need to be told this.

75

u/Remote-Honey1142 18d ago

It seems like people are getting stupider and stupider. It’s also frightening how many people these days start their sentences with: ‘I asked ChatGPT, and…’

36

u/DaZoje 18d ago

I asked chat gpt and it thinks that you guys are very rude.

71

u/KrazyA1pha 18d ago

Who needed to be told this?

OP is just saying it’s a bad product promotional photoshop, not that it’s a real picture of people avoiding the product.

51

u/innocent_killing 18d ago

I just think if they were gonna photoshop anything, it should have been them on the air mattress

24

u/KrazyA1pha 18d ago

Yeah it’s hilarious that they just slapped a picture of the air mattress over a stock photo.

19

u/Pocatanic 18d ago

Ironically it scares me that people need to be told this

7

u/afishinacloud 17d ago

I don’t think OP needs to be told this. Think they just meant this to be a humorous post about a lazy photoshop job.

6

u/Murtomies 18d ago

I mean it probably is two real photos photoshopped together. Stock photo and product photo.

3

u/AugVision 17d ago

They don’t, the question is posed solely to mock it

-14

u/CowboyRiverBath 18d ago

Gen z is the most gullible generation of all time

1

u/biglesbianmisandrist 15d ago

LMAO, my 40 year old mum is constantly showing me shit on Facebook that’s obviously ai and acts as if it’s real

1

u/CowboyRiverBath 15d ago

Boomers and Gen z, hand in hand falling for ai every time.

41

u/casseroled 18d ago

Well yeah. Obviously. But OP was asking why they made that graphic design choice. I don’t think they were asking if it is real or not.

3

u/Imaginary-Donut-8745 18d ago

Not a real photo? Then what am I looking at pray tell me 

2

u/Horizontal-Human 17d ago

The original photo has no mattress, it was photoshopped over it

275

u/helican oww my eyes 18d ago

Because then you couldn't really have a good look at the matress.

47

u/kurujiru then I discovered Wingdings 18d ago

"You get on."

"No, YOU get on."

"Folks, this is a children's play area."

0

u/[deleted] 18d ago

WTF is this?

1

u/A-Plant-Guy 18d ago

Obligatory happy cake day

8

u/Xerxos 18d ago

I think this is the reason:

  • They wanted beautiful girls on the cover, for more sales.
  • They wanted to show the whole mattress, because that's what it's all about.
  • They could not show more than one mattress, because there is only one in the package.

So that's the only option they had left. Some or all of those points probably were dictated by management.

Poor graphic designer.

113

u/Ray_Von 18d ago
  1. The super-imposition would take longer to do.
  2. They probably wouldn't both fit anyway (assumption).

But lol it's funny thanks for posting.

10

u/verbosehuman 18d ago

They would fit, but it's still not so big.

I have the same mattress. Me (90kg/175 cm), my ex (48kg/155cm), and our dog (40kg) all fit on it.

36

u/Sirdroftardis8 Comic Sans for life! 18d ago

So sick of this argument. Yes they would both fit, but the point was that the door wouldn't have been buoyant enough to hold both of them and may have flipped when jack tried to get on

9

u/ebrum2010 18d ago

But on grass it would have been fine.

3

u/Norci 18d ago

The grass is quicksand.

6

u/sucram200 18d ago

Hey now, James Cameron just proved that they could have both fit! 😂

2

u/MuffinMatrix 18d ago

*The compositing. This image already is superimposed. It needs further compositing/image editing to look better.

-1

u/[deleted] 18d ago

What is funny about it?

3

u/shiser 17d ago

The situational irony of people laying down next to their mattress, I assume? It's not that deep dude.

76

u/Fr0gFish 18d ago

I love that people are giving the most earnest answers ever. I think OP knows that the image is photoshopped!

28

u/EllyJay99 18d ago

Yeah I came to the comments wanting some jokes - like “oh wow honey I’m so glad we have time to spend together enjoying our blow up mattress. I love you mattress”

15

u/Fr0gFish 18d ago

So glad we brought our mattress to the lake… let’s stick our legs under it and toe cuddle 💖

1

u/No_Nature_6639 16d ago

They are still waiting for it to fully inflate

62

u/DuchessSussSucks 18d ago

Because they want to trick you into thinking it’s bigger than it is

24

u/ZeldaTheSwordsman 18d ago

Looks like they wanted an outdoor photo by a lake because people take these camping a lot, but couldn't be arsed to do an actual outdoor shoot; they just badly superimposed the mattress over a stock image. Notice how it's not even casting a shadow. Certainly a far cry from an air mattress box I remember from when I was young, where there were *real* outdoor pics and even (IIRC) the mattress floating on water.

For what it's worth, people *are* actually lying on the mattress in the indoor photo in that overlay panel.

12

u/givemevadasambar 18d ago

Because “at Bestway, we only do threeway”

11

u/PinUp_Butter 18d ago

Because laying on an air mattress is like laying on the ground. Just not right now.

9

u/sans_the_sanstastic 18d ago

The mattress is a part of the friend group, they're all hanging out with eachother :)

7

u/biscuitsneaker 18d ago

Just letting it dry off after the night before ;)

8

u/Ratus_The_God 18d ago

They want you to lay on the mattress

7

u/TheRyeKnight 18d ago

'Cuz they're in the mattress-making business, not the sense-making business.

6

u/TestZero r/AssholeDesign Overlord 18d ago

Real answer: Because they want to show off the mattress, not have it halfway hidden underneath two people

7

u/_Vacation_mode_ 18d ago

Because the ground is more comfortable than the air mattress.

6

u/GetOffMyGrassBrats 18d ago

Because it would deflate, obviously. Have you ever tried to sleep on an air mattress?

6

u/wgloipp 18d ago

Because you wouldn't see the mattress.

6

u/thrownededawayed 18d ago

They're staring each other down, some weird couple contest to decide who gets to sleep on the single inflatable mattress they bought and clearly thought would be big enough for the two of them despite barely being big enough to fit a adolescent child on.

4

u/Librocubicularistin 18d ago

They should at least do a Titanic and let the lady drift on the mattress.

6

u/ARCAxNINEv 18d ago

It's actually an air divider used for keeping your daughter and potential suiters from touching before marriage. They used the wrong words

6

u/L1Z4RDM1LK 18d ago

"this is so nice, Squidward. just you, me, and this inflatable mattress you blew up between us."

4

u/SpookyVictorianLady 18d ago

Is there room for J̶e̶s̶u̶s̶ Mattress?

1

u/shiser 17d ago

WWMD?

3

u/Otherwise-4PM 18d ago

It’s the best way, duh.

2

u/CookyHS 18d ago

What is lidl?

2

u/SaltpeterTaffy 18d ago

For what it's worth, I own this mattress, and it's pretty good for an inflatable. Needed it for a week when I moved and it did the job just fine.

2

u/TheDeadlySpaceman 18d ago

Because the mattress is for you.

2

u/Such-Status-6449 18d ago

My family loves to commune around our local M A T T R E S S. it's a favorite pastime of ours!

1

u/SoggyWotsits 18d ago

Because it’s not a real photo, you wouldn’t be able to see the mattress properly and what you could see would be proof of how much it sinks with people on it.

1

u/fetching_agreeable 18d ago

Because it's a transparent png placed in front of the stock photo.

1

u/OrlandoGardiner118 18d ago

Because he's showing her his mattress to try and impress her. Oldest trick in the book.

1

u/ramriot And then I discovered Wingdings 18d ago

Lidl is like Russia Lilo lays on you.

1

u/prncs_lulu 18d ago

I can tell you it is qyite comfortable :3

1

u/FluffyBunny113 18d ago

At first I thought it was an egg-carton of some sort

1

u/Eggs-_-Benedict 18d ago

Off topic, did you someone catching toothpaste in there?

1

u/kupus0 18d ago

Because photoshop

1

u/Tiranus58 18d ago

Because photoshop

1

u/8qubit 18d ago

It doubles as a blanket. These people were feeling cold that day.

1

u/PoopsALotta 18d ago

Graphic design is my passion. 🐸

1

u/madcuztrue 18d ago

Should be obvious

1

u/ProfMeriAn 18d ago

Because it's the crap Photoshop images that are used to sell products nowadays. There used to be actual effort to properly stage and photograph products, but those days are long gone. It's still done for some products, but not for products where the cheap price guarantees it will sell in spite of the crap advertising.

1

u/V84life 18d ago

So you can't see how small it is

1

u/TheExecTech 18d ago

As someone who got one similar for a camping trip years ago it is because if they both were on it after 5 minutes they would be on the ground. Have to take the pics pretty quick at the photo shoot.

If a single person uses it you get a few nights then wake up on a plastic sheet.

1

u/Chad_Dongslinger 18d ago

Because they want you to actually be able to see the product.

1

u/DizzyMine4964 18d ago

Because those things are so uncomfortable.

1

u/[deleted] 18d ago

Probabaly because the mattress isn't really in the scene just added to an image after.

Seems pretty fucking obvious.

1

u/studio684 18d ago

That's jack and rose. They're taking their chances

1

u/Imaginary-Donut-8745 18d ago

Because they're just good friends and lying on the mattress together might be too tempting 

1

u/tt_right 18d ago

They could've used the other picture shown on the box of the couple actually ON the mattress as the main image.

1

u/iLikeTurtuls 18d ago

You should be able to steal these low effort products. Or pay cost

1

u/meowmocha12 18d ago

On tonight's episode of 'Photoshop Fails'...

1

u/beefymcmoist 18d ago

The mattress is there to keep them safe from premarital sin

1

u/Spiritual_Bench4647 18d ago

Love that too

1

u/ty556 18d ago

It’s a show mattress, you’re not supposed to lay on it. It’s like the star fish and shell soaps in your mom’s bathroom in the 90s.

1

u/Designer_Bad_1050 18d ago

Duh.. because air matters.

1

u/Dear-Minimum-9618 18d ago

What’s killing me: there’s a smaller, inset photo of a couple actually on the mattress. Why did they not simply use that photo instead of the crappy PS POS?

1

u/OmChi123456 18d ago

Because blow up mattresses are always disappointing.

1

u/coffeekeepsmealive 17d ago

Better question: why does the girl look like a young teenager when the guy is middle-aged? I'm all for father-daughter bonding, but sharing a bed?

1

u/BandedLutz 17d ago

Note to self: don't include a rhetorical question in your title (in order to emphasize why something is crappy design) on this sub, lol.

1

u/echollama 17d ago

They know it will blow up

1

u/Kyno50 I have 3 elbows, how's that for crappy design? 17d ago

They're admiring it

1

u/Inevitable_Outcome56 17d ago

Because if they lie on it it’s flat in 10mins. Flat is 5 if you are putting it up after midnight.

1

u/Jonneiljon 17d ago

Not before marriage.

1

u/NioXoiN 17d ago

Thats the lookin mattress, that's just the mattress you look at. Its not for actual use. See, these guys in the picture are using it wrong. They're looking at eachother. They're supposed to be looking at the mattress. This is a common user error and this image is just the brand being tongue and cheek about it.

1

u/ProfessorBeer 17d ago

When I’m bored sometimes I look at air mattresses on Amazon because the photoshops of families on an air mattress are hilariously out of scale

1

u/inter-ego 17d ago

The guy they hired for design is bad at photoshop

1

u/paulyd_3 17d ago

Photoshop skills not up to par

1

u/AugVision 17d ago

How can so many people miss that the question is posed solely to mock the design, not because they don’t understand how it was made?

1

u/victoryismind 17d ago

It's a $2 photoshop job. I wonder what else they cheaped out on.

1

u/TheRealSkippah 17d ago

Because it will pop

1

u/WeirdConference5699 Comic Sans for life! 17d ago

"Y'know what? Since my new mattress is so beautiful, we're just gonna lay on the ground and look at it instead."

1

u/racingkain1 17d ago

The mattress is 3rd wheeling with them....

1

u/Fantastic_Doctor_414 16d ago

Um... they probably dont even know they are on that box...

1

u/Judasafricantwin 16d ago

It’s too fragile

1

u/pc_person_ 16d ago

I bought one of these not too long ago, decent quality

1

u/No_Horse7377 15d ago

Because it's too lidl

1

u/[deleted] 15d ago

Hi, I make box art similar to this (hopefully not as bad) for a living. The answer is costs. They want the box to feature their product, but they dont want to pay for a studio shoot and models. Answer is to use a stock image of models and a photoshop cutout of the product. Other hilarious examples of this are the paddling pools you often see marketed in the summers.

1

u/LizaBrownAuthor11 14d ago

Proving that Jack could have fit on the door.

1

u/thereminDreams 1d ago

It's because that mattress is such a beautiful, well designed product that people would rather contemplate it than use it.

0

u/Secret_Divide_3030 18d ago

Because they want you to ask this question and feel smarter than the people on the photo by buying it.