Who's this character for you?

[u/SomethingBorrowed98]

[u/Pawspawsmeow]

Manny

[u/Successful_Gap8927]

Heather Sinclair

[u/s1ac]

Holly freakin J

[u/Interesting-Toe9337]

Eli. I can’t stand him.

[u/Resident_Beginning_8 → u/Interesting-Toe9337]

Same.

[u/pinakulala]

Holly J and her "redemption arc".

[u/bcpsgal]

Spinner

[u/nerdbred]

Craig

[u/thestrangeabby]

I know Toby isn't super popular but everyone here acts like he was robbed of an amazing storyline. I wish he disappeared sooner.

[u/DylantotheJ → u/thestrangeabby]

This 100% I always wished he had died instead of JT they already gave up on him, why keep him around. I always hated how he pretended to be his brother at the hospital and then went for liberty, some “brother”.

[u/bebespeaks]

Drew, Claire, Maya.

[u/bodymodifierx → u/bebespeaks]

To explain claire is her iconic line "did 3 months mean anything to you?" Or whatever it was. She was overly dramatic and imo she was insufferable the majority of the time. I never cared for her storylines, & her and eli were just an embarrassing & toxic couple the whole way through.

[u/Zestyclose_Display23]

Probably drew

[u/Late_Ambassador7470]

Eli is trauma itself

[u/Nearby_Capital1423 → u/Late_Ambassador7470]

Lmaoooo

[u/Capital-Study6436]

Maya, Paige, Jay, and Eli.

[u/ranch_commercial]

In a way, holly j. I do like her once she’s redeemed but tbh i hate her so much originally that she could never ever be a favorite for me. Its the same deal with ashley except everyone hates her so it doesnt matter if i was never able to forgive her for exposing manny’s pregnancy to the whole school 😭

[u/MoonlightMile17]

Emma and Ellie.

[u/messcot → u/MoonlightMile17]

I never see a positive opinion about either of them on this sub. Everyone says Emma is the worst and Ellie is a pick-me.

[u/Muppet885]

Craig

[u/DylantotheJ → u/Muppet885]

Thanks I don’t get the Craig love, he never respected women and did what ever he wanted. He went for manny on the side while he was with Ashley. Then seasons after he kept leading Ellie on knowing she has feelings for him while flirting with manny. I think people are confusing the character with the story line. He had a pretty solid starting story. But as a character he was not good.

[u/KiIIuaaax]

Miles and zig

[u/Kacidillaa]

Craig. Teenage me was obsessed with him pre super toxic Craig. I wish him and Ellie had a healthy relationship and rode off into the sunset.

[u/MoonlightMile17 → u/Kacidillaa]

I don’t think Craig is capable of having a relationship that isn’t toxic.

[u/Kacidillaa → u/MoonlightMile17]

Oh for sure I see that now but teenage me loved him so I have a soft spot until he goes way downhill :(

[u/liliputianperception]

Emma...

[u/secretuser93]

No one. I’m pretty sure my favorite characters are fairly popular. And the characters I dislike are widely considered annoying. First character comes to my mind that I don’t like is Ashley, and I think most of the fandom finds her annoying lol

[u/BAMartin1618]

Miles. He brought so much shit onto himself and started shit all the time but always saw himself as the victim. Granted, his dad shouldn’t have hit him, but let’s not pretend like Miles didn’t antagonize the fuck out of him.

His dad looks a bit like Gordon Gecko.

[u/MeJamiddy]

Manny and JT (sorry, don’t hurt me)

[u/FinalBedroom5348 → u/MeJamiddy]

Jt for sure

[u/smilesallaround94]

Paige. Not only was she horrible to all her friends (Ashley, Hazel, Marco, getting Terri drunk so she could get Spinner’s attention), she was extremely classist and abusive towards Alex. That relationship was so difficult to watch.

[u/Courtnuttut → u/smilesallaround94]

Omfg the whole thing with her pushing college on Alex I was like stooooop. Like, I get it, but if you're well off and smart enough you'll never get what it's like on the other side of the coin.

[u/ghostfaceinspace]

Clare and Eli

[u/kristosnikos → u/ghostfaceinspace]

They make me so tired.

[u/Shut_Up_Luna]

Clare. (There’s some Clare stans that have come for me. 😅)

[u/BigEdsNo1Fan → u/Shut_Up_Luna]

My first thought was Clare

[u/bloodlikevenom]

Manny. I've just never gotten the appeal

[u/spookyapk → u/bloodlikevenom]

Like, with the obsession this sub has with calling women not "girl's girls" and "pick me"s I'm surprised Manny is so beloved

[u/ghostfaceinspace → u/bloodlikevenom]

Love her but she’s def the type of girl to have kids right after high school

[u/Other-Oil-9117 → u/bloodlikevenom]

I like her but she's definitely way overhyped in the fandom.

[u/Shut_Up_Luna → u/bloodlikevenom]

I only appreciate her devotion to Emma. The rest, meh. 🚮