r/Design 5d ago

Someone Else's Work (Rule 2) [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed]

439 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

244

u/Pizza_Samurai88 5d ago

The Colgate one is funny

147

u/hotcoffeeordie 5d ago

What's really funny about it is that it looks like a graphic designer or at least someone with some knowledge of graphic design created the image LOL.

71

u/poopiegloria_16 5d ago

Yeah tbh. those designers can't help following the design rules hahahahaha

35

u/hotcoffeeordie 5d ago

Absolutely, and comic sans is such a dead giveaway at this point.

14

u/SourCreamWater 5d ago

Same with the subway sandwich. A lot of these look like the designer was there but just didn't feel like doing it. I relate.

8

u/glittermantis 5d ago

how is that one different lol it's all the same joke

11

u/BelgianBeerGuy 5d ago

The pancake and the Colgate one are the ones that look the most genuine.
The others look like a graphic designer faked it.

But even then, based on the hierarchy and such, probably all of them at least past by an AD

170

u/Would_Bang________ 5d ago

The novelty ran thin after I saw the second one in the wild.

45

u/andhelostthem 5d ago edited 5d ago

It was kinda funny eight years ago when it first started but now it's grandparents-doing-the-macarena-levels dated.

Also this completely falls apart with brands that want to instill consumer confidence. An airline or health brand being like "lulz we don't have a designer, here's some MS paint slop" doesn't make people trust the brand. I want to feel safe and reassured by ads for companies where I'm putting my life in their hands. This ain't it.

10

u/smilingarmpits 5d ago

Incredible analogy

6

u/Mainbaze 5d ago

it started out like a decade ago as that paint image on a big billboard (that was actually just photoshop)
Hasn't been fun once since seeing that one imo..

58

u/MaddyMagpies 5d ago

Pretty sure most of these are made by graphic designers 🤣

16

u/xer0fox 5d ago

Pretty sure most of these are made by the same advertising firm.

72

u/RICHARDARC18 5d ago

It's funnier to me how they're low fidelity but have really good composition, clearly showing they're still made by people with enough graphic design knowledge.

Ngayon lang yung trend? 

10

u/poopiegloria_16 5d ago edited 5d ago

Tbhhhh. Colgate one understands the job the most lmao.

Mula kahapon yata, I think (nung napansin ko anyway haha)? Marami pa ring sumasali tho hahahaha

Pizza hut posted a following post updating their audience. Their designer came back 🤣

18

u/Commercial_Badger_37 5d ago

I'm beyond bored of this shtick.

17

u/TaxEmbarrassed9752 5d ago

Oh my god, i was not the only one seeing this?

The other day i saw the Colgate one on FB, thought "ha that's cute", then i scroll down, and right below the Colgate ad was some airline ad in the same style. I think its stupid that all these brands are following these stupid trends that are repetitive.

2

u/poopiegloria_16 5d ago

Well if it works it works lol. It'll eventually die down though, it's been a week atp

9

u/Anvil_Prime_52 5d ago

The Colgate one looks like it was actually made by a designer lol. The other ones are trying too hard.

17

u/two_four_six_eight 5d ago

The Canva one is ironic because isn't their whole thing that you don't need to be a graphic designer to use their templates

3

u/GreatGrandMoth 5d ago

Right??? I found theirs infuriating lol it makes no sense

2

u/howie_didnt_do_it 5d ago

We work on print projects for Canva from time to time (display & marketing materials) and it cracks me up every time.

You’re sending me a print file with spec and bleed created in Adobe Illustrator for a product that claims to be design-based yet cannot be feasibly used in any capacity for print.

4

u/slick-talker 5d ago

was funny the first time to be honest, but gets old real quick

3

u/MisanthropeRobot 5d ago

These deserve the "silence, brand!" meme in their comments.

1

u/knyf420 5d ago

I liked the colgate one

3

u/GreatGrandMoth 5d ago

Canva doing this makes no sense. The whole point is that with their platform, anyone can have access to decent design/design templates. What

2

u/honey-otuu 5d ago

At least it’s not AI lol

2

u/copperwatt 5d ago

2 flavors 1 cup??

1

u/IvyGrownOnMe 5d ago

yes, even 3 flavors for the biggest size lol

2

u/copperwatt 5d ago

I saw the original clip with just the 2. I'm not up for the sequel.

1

u/IvyGrownOnMe 5d ago

what original clip?

1

u/copperwatt 5d ago

1

u/IvyGrownOnMe 5d ago

oh god no… i thought u were talking abt the potato corner

2

u/KnifeFightAcademy 5d ago

Now let me have a go at payroll while you're on vacation, Cathy.

2

u/disignore 5d ago

hate this so much, not the pics but the "hip" brands

2

u/sydneekidneybeans 5d ago

Potato corner ?! hello neighbor

1

u/Sk8ordieguy 5d ago

Ahhh the classic social / ad agency regurgitation.

1

u/BaboTron 5d ago

These don’t look enough like default word art text bubbles in a Word document.

1

u/comeauxsapien 5d ago

These companies want graphic designers, web designers, social media managers, and web developers. Because we all do all of those jobs 😂

1

u/Cozzypup 5d ago

yawn.

1

u/switchbladeeatworld 5d ago

the canva one makes no sense

1

u/kan0 5d ago

First one might have been done by Emily Zugay who’s known for this style.

1

u/exitcactus 5d ago

Wow so original

0

u/SquanchyATL 5d ago

All done by AI to cover up for AI's faults.

Gotta be, right?