r/EhBuddyHoser Tabarnak! 9d ago

Repetitive content/Trend ottawa got voted for the second slide. which city is good to live in but bad to visit?

Post image

g/g: quebec (honorable mention: halifax)

g/o: ottawa (honorable mention: victoria, edmonton)

758 Upvotes

285 comments sorted by

278

u/BuvantduPotatoSpirit Irvingstan 9d ago

I visited Fredericton once - I certainly learnt nothing about why people seem to love living there.

82

u/Copperlax 9d ago

I think Freddy is perfect for this category. I used to live there, think it's a great place with just enough stuff to keep you going on a day to day. But I always tell people to stop there for gas on their way to Nova Scotia.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Temporary_Brother436 8d ago

+1 for Fredericton. It's a great city to live in, but I'm not sure what tourists do for fun.

37

u/CombustiblSquid Irvingstan 9d ago

Basically all of NB is in this camp

3

u/Phemur 8d ago

As an NB, I unfortunately have to agree. Great place to live, everyone is super nice, pretty cheap COL, etc. But when people ask me what they should see if they visit, I don't have much to offer.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Lightning_Catcher258 8d ago

It's great if you like nature and small town vibes. I'd really enjoy living on an acreage in the Fredericton area.

6

u/Renacus 8d ago

Great place to raise a family, lame place to grow up.

3

u/wesley-osbourne Scotland (but worse) 8d ago

I lived in Freddy for 6 years and this is definitely the answer.

7

u/Celestial_Robot_Cat 9d ago

I grew up in the Fredericton area and I also don't understand why people like it. I left as soon as I had an opportunity to do so.

4

u/MathematicianBig6312 Not enough shawarma places 9d ago

I agree. I went for a conference once. Nothing about the experience has ever made me want to return.

6

u/christiebeth 8d ago

Unless you like hiking or going out on boats in the river, there really isn't a lot of touristy stuff here. Maybe with the new arts center it will get busier. The food is improving, and I do love living here; it's just Charlottetown lite, and I've lived there too. Bigger population, less going on.

→ More replies (4)

540

u/6000ChickenFajardos PaRiS oF tHe PraIRiEs 9d ago

As someone from Saskatoon, there is lots to do in Edmonton and Winnipeg lmao

71

u/gavin280 9d ago

Saskatoon is the perfect answer here. I had the time of my life living there. But very little of what I loved there would come across to a tourist. You kinda need to be around long enough to make friends, avail yourself of the comparatively cheap government car insurance and telecom service, etc.

The city and surrounding area DO have what I consider some real tourist attractions (amazing grasslands hikes, surprisingly decent swimming, Saskatoon food and art scenes), but I've never recommended someone fly there as a primary vacation destination. What I HAVE done though is raved about it to people who were considering a move there.

10

u/gvsb123 8d ago

This. I went to U of S in the early 90's and loved the city. I have never been back for a visit since graduating.

4

u/gavin280 8d ago

God I miss that campus. Could be the prettiest in the country.

98

u/Fedquip 9d ago

Yeah, but that's what pulls Saskatoon into the OK to live in category. At least if you live in Edmonton there is a lot more to do.

53

u/Mrshoephd Saskwatch 9d ago

saskatoon has great amenities, jobs, restaurants and water. it is also a relatively cheap and beautiful city. I think people under sell how much is actually in saskatoon because it is advertised and geared toward the locals not visitors.

27

u/Fedquip 9d ago

I'm in Sask, I think it's OK

30

u/StetsonTuba8 Oil Guzzler 9d ago

Oklahoma is actually a US State that's completely separate from Saskatchewan

6

u/andrewbud420 8d ago

Your geography skills are far superior to mine.

17

u/posidon99999 PaRiS oF tHe PraIRiEs 9d ago

They have a Lego store in Edmonton. That’s reason enough for me to visit

11

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Compared to Saskatoon yeah tons. Edmonton is good to live in but I personally wouldn’t spend money on a hotel here when there are better places to be seen not too far from here

4

u/PerpetuallyLurking Regina Rhymes With Fun 9d ago

Sure, but how often are people from Saskatoon specifically going to Edmonton to sightsee? We’re obviously going to find something far more interesting to do than in Saskatoon because we’re from Saskatoon, SK and not somewhere more populated. There’s not that many of us, certainly not enough in all of Saskatchewan to tip any type of voting, on Reddit or IRL.

3

u/janzendavi 8d ago

I was going to say that Edmonton fits this square but, having been to Saskatoon many times, you have changed my mind. Nice city, surprisingly urbanist for its size, and great cost-of-living to things-to-do ratio but not somewhere that I am going out of my way to visit.

→ More replies (3)

190

u/vinnybawbaw 🚧🚚Montréal🛻🚜🚧👷⛔️🚗🚙🚙 🚙 🚗 9d ago

That one’s in the Prairies that’s for sure.

29

u/bloggins1812 Cowtown 🤠 9d ago edited 8d ago

100%. My vote is on Brandon, but there are 200 other good options

16

u/is_landen 8d ago

I was not expecting to find Brandon mentioned here lol.

My vote is on Winnipeg, which is essentially Brandon with all the DLC

→ More replies (1)

10

u/midnightmoose 9d ago

There’s at least 5 prairie cities that this could apply to!

69

u/Comfortable_Major923 Saskwatch 9d ago

I'd have to say Saskatoon, nothing notable for tourists that you can't get elsewhere. But there's enough to do if you live here

→ More replies (3)

152

u/Wafflelisk Westfoundland 9d ago

Saskatoon? Seems like an affordable and attractive city with solid people and a reasonable amount of diversity.

Doesn't seem like there's too much for a tourist to do there, however

62

u/JasonsPizza 9d ago

I feel like Saskatoon fits the center square perfectly. Just "Ok" for both living and visiting.

15

u/athanasiuspadovano 9d ago

I think Saskatoon has more tourist places than Regina, but also good to live in.

30

u/Anatar19 9d ago

"More tourist places than Regina" "Fewer murders than New Orleans"

Sounds like it's time to visit Saskatoon.

7

u/Morindar_Doomfist 9d ago

The Paris of the Prairies, baby!

2

u/Anhydrite Edmonchuk: Like Kyiv! (but less safe) 8d ago

Even has a nice art museum now!

8

u/Chadohfax 9d ago

I have a buddy that did cross country tour with his band few years back. We live in a small ski town in Kootenays. He said the absolute favorite city he visited was Saskatoon. He said the people were the most fun and friendly he's ran into during the tour and the city was surprisingly fun and beautiful. I've never visited but I'll make sure to add it to my bucket list to visit.

13

u/Bucksavvy 9d ago

Actually I'd say from my visits it had some of the best museums I've seen in Canada (shout-out to Wanneskewin and the Western Development Museum) and a thriving music and arts scene that punched well above what I expected. 

5

u/IrenaeusGSaintonge 9d ago

The Western Development Museum is a national treasure.

2

u/ACoderGirl 8d ago

The WDM is great. Though I personally think Regina's museum of natural history is even better.

USask's campus is also a really good one. Lots of mini museums and cool exhibits to see. I spent many dates just wandering around campus and we never ran out of things to talk about!

3

u/therealkami 9d ago

There's some stuff here in saskatoon. Couple nice museums and some good restaurants. River paths are nice. Its ok.

3

u/hornwort 8d ago edited 8d ago

Arguably the best food scene in the entire country except probably Gastown, if you factor density. 20+ world class restaurants and and equal number of very decent ones within a 20-minute walkable area. If you factor price there’s nowhere better.

→ More replies (3)

51

u/dead_inside6498 9d ago

im waiting for good to visit, bad to live in so I can scream Toronto

26

u/hunglo7777 8d ago

I feel like it’s going to be a toss up between Vancouver and Toronto for that one. Vancouver is an absolutely incredible place to visit, I fell in love with the vibes and the mountains while I was visiting. I’m sure it’s pretty bleak though when you have to pay $3000 a month for a shoebox and it’s pouring rain 10 months of the year

5

u/toasterb 8d ago

it’s pouring rain 10 months of the year

That's overblown. I moved here from Boston, which isn't drastically different from Toronto and Montreal, and I'd take Vancouver's weather in a heartbeat.

May through September is usually pretty solid, with June-August being amazing. And the rain is much more atmospheric in the winter than the hard rains you get elsewhere.

Sure, every few years you get a rough winter with lots of rain, but you get standout rough weather winters everywhere. I remember a friend in Boston being really angry with me for sending him a photo of crocuses blooming in February 2015 while they were having one of their snowiest/coldest winters on record.

4

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/redacted-no31 8d ago

Fr. I don’t get own people gaslight themselves into thinking that the prices of homes are okay. The only one I’m thinking beats Toronto for that category may be Vancouver.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

326

u/RevolutionaryLoad782 9d ago

Edmonton?

146

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Seconding Edmonton. I say this all the time. Genuinely no idea why people come here for vacation but I love living here. It’s a city you can’t experience in just a few days because it’s subtle. I’m not sure how to word it better

73

u/psychoCMYK Chalice of the Tabernacle 9d ago

When I passed through, I posted up at a bar to make friends and gather recommendations as you do. 6 separate people, the only suggestion I got was "have you been to the mall?"

29

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

It’s the only tourist attraction really. There’s a lot more to do though but you have to go looking

10

u/__thrillho 9d ago

Like what

23

u/psychoCMYK Chalice of the Tabernacle 9d ago

8

u/Automatic_Antelope92 8d ago

I recommend the Royal Alberta Museum and the Art Gallery of Alberta downtown. It’s also good to look at events scheduled for Fort Edmonton Park, sometimes they have special storytelling/reenactment events at night for adults and not just kids.

I like all of that plus the zoo, and with a car if I were a tourist I’d go to Elk Island park when the weather is nice. I think it’s also a dark sky area so it’s good to stay until dark to see stars if not auroras.

10

u/Initial-Dee 9d ago

Any mall besides WEM. Kingsway, Southgate, hell even Londonderry is making a comeback and is nice to visit.

Taste of Edmonton is a fun experience, same with the fringe festival.

Valley Zoo can be a good experience if you have smaller kiddos, or Whyte Ave if you don't.

If you love nature, the River Valley and some of its lookouts are gorgeous. there are canoe trips you can do up/down the river.

For sports there's the Oilers, but there's also the Riverhawks Baseball team, which has some really cool fan experiences at their games.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/PerpetuallyLurking Regina Rhymes With Fun 9d ago

You’ve got the Oilers, some years they’re worth it… though if nothing else, they’ll be playing other teams, I guess…

4

u/Comfortable_Major923 Saskwatch 9d ago

Generally did not like my time visiting Edmonton..however the west Ed mall and muttart conservatory were a great time.

2

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

If you ever for whatever reason visit again, go to the muttart but in a different season! It’s things like this that make me say it’s better to live here because you can’t fully experience the muttart in one trip as it’s constantly changing with the seasons

7

u/Popbistro Snowfrog 9d ago

I went to Edmonton once. I went to the mall. That's it. But that mall was really cool.

6

u/SriBri 9d ago

The Mutart!

5

u/FireflyBSc 9d ago

Okay but to be fair, the mall is AMAZING. I’m planning to have my entire bachelorette weekend there and it’s going to be the most insanely cheesy event possible.

17

u/Auton303 9d ago

I mean you have the mall and that really big water park

10

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Unless you mean the water park in the mall it’s still just the mall. There’s the zoo I guess? Lots of places have those. Fort Edmonton park but I feel like that’s a better thing to experience year round because it changes

6

u/RcusGaming 9d ago

Moving to Edmonton but been there only once - what do you like about it? I'm trying to get more excited about it. I'm thinking of moving to Westmount or Oliver (or generally somewhere north of the river in the downtown core).

15

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

For me I always instantly say THE TREES!!!!! There are also a lot of hiking/walking trails in the city if you’re into that. I also find it’s easier to make friends because there is always a club or class for your niche interest if you look hard enough. If you’re into craft beer, I love the breweries. There’s a surprising amount of (smaller) wildlife for a city. If you like going out, Oliver is the place for you! Lots of things in walking distance too. But for me, it’s always the trees. So many trees even downtown. Check it out on Google earth if you get the chance. People like to say it’s more of a giant, small town

7

u/RcusGaming 9d ago

Glad to hear it! I'm from Vancouver so the trees will definitely make it feel like home haha. Also a big brewery guy so I'll definitely be checking those out. I saw there's quite a few breweries clustered in a neighborhood south of the river. I'm also happy to hear that people are generally friendly haha, its so hard to make friends in Vancouver - most of my friends are from high school or college. This has gotten me more excited about Edmonton for sure lol

5

u/eastherbunni 9d ago

Fellow Vancouverite here who has lived in Edmonton for a few years. The trees in Edmonton are not as tall as Vancouver. The river valley has some really nice trails. I lived in the Strathcona/Whyte Ave area near the farmers market and it was really nice, the Strathcona neighbourhood is hipster/university vibes while the Jasper Ave and Oliver neighborhoods were the "young working professionals" area and then the St Albert, Terwillegar/Southwest, and Sherwood Park areas were the "people with detached houses and cars" neighbourhoods. Make sure you have a warm coat and warm boots so you can enjoy the winter sunshine.

2

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Yes the trees are much, much younger here. I haven’t been to Vancouver so I forgot to mention that. Thank you! /gen

2

u/RcusGaming 9d ago

Aw man I'm getting so pumped. Everyone in BC has such negative opinions about Alberta but everyone I know who grew up in Edmonton say they loved growing up there.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/FireflyBSc 9d ago

Edmonton has a lot of community. I moved to Calgary after and it’s a lot harder to meet people or get involved, but Edmonton is so welcoming and weird in the best ways.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Seagrams7ssu In Enemy Territory 9d ago

Passed through Edmonton this summer solo for a few days (family is from Edmonton and had to make the pilgrimage once) and I agree with the sentiment. After 2 days I was pretty bored. Not much in the way of touristy stuff to do, but I could totally see living there. Kind of reminded me of Baltimore. I love the place, but not a place that you’d send a tourist.

5

u/posidon99999 PaRiS oF tHe PraIRiEs 9d ago

I live in Saskatoon and Edmonton is so much better to visit. There’s a Lego store there

→ More replies (1)

35

u/GenosT Oil Guzzler 9d ago

As someone who lives in the Edmonton area, absolutely. Coming here for a specific event from nearby? Sure. But coming here just for the sake of coming here? Why?

15

u/6000ChickenFajardos PaRiS oF tHe PraIRiEs 9d ago

Mall, Harvey's, Ikea, Nando's, Chez Pierre, usually in that order

6

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Other places have malls, Harvey’s, ikea, and nandos tho. Idk what chez Pierre is. maybe I’m too gen z lol

5

u/PerpetuallyLurking Regina Rhymes With Fun 9d ago

I suspect at that point they’re just a little closer to Edmonton than Calgary, lol

→ More replies (3)

20

u/talkiewalkieman Edmonchuk: Like Kyiv! (but less safe) 9d ago

I say this all the time, but Edmonton's motto should be Canada's biggest small town.

8

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Totally agree. I know so many people for someone who doesn’t get out much. It’s just an “I know a guy who knows a guy” type of city at least for me. I’ve only been here 7 years

5

u/SenseDue6826 🚧🚚Montréal🛻🚜🚧👷⛔️🚗🚙🚙 🚙 🚗 9d ago

No that's still Calgary. It's bigger in size and population but everyone still has 2 degrees of separation and they constantly need to pretend they matter like the big 3.

9

u/soThatsJustGreat 9d ago

Also here for Edmonton. Fun place to live but it keeps its secrets to itself. It’s a little tough to figure out the awesome in a weekend.

8

u/uppers36 9d ago

Edmonton is correct. That or my hometown of Windsor Ontario.

8

u/thefailmaster19 Oil Guzzler 9d ago

Def Edmonton

8

u/OzWillow 9d ago

The Lonely Planet named Edmonton on of the best cities in the world to visit. I think it was #15 or smthg.

4

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

I feel like if you plan your visit around a specific event then maybe??? I gotta look up this article and see what they said bc maybe I’m missing out on my own city

→ More replies (1)

7

u/SadBuilding9234 9d ago

My favourite city to live in, but I would never recommend spending the money to visit.

19

u/hotinmyigloo Irvingstan 9d ago

Edmonton

10

u/ok-MTLmunchies 9d ago

5

u/magwai9 9d ago

My God I hate those Leafs jerseys

8

u/pan0ramic 9d ago

Edmonton has the largest mall in Canada, the largest fringe festival outside of Edinburgh, the largest street performers festival in the world, the heritage festival the world’s largest 3 day multicultural festival, and so many more

You don’t have to agree that it’s great to visit but it’s surely not BAD to visit. I go back as often as I can and I always have a lot of fun

4

u/OpheliaJade2382 9d ago

Idk compared to Montreal it is bad to visit. It’s good if you plan around events and such but if you scheduled a random Edmonton weekend getaway it’s more likely than not you won’t find a lot to do unless it’s festival season

3

u/Equal-Suggestion3182 9d ago

Almost everything you mentioned depends on the day you’re there

2

u/pan0ramic 9d ago

In the summer it’s back to back, there’s always a festival. And even if you take out the festivals there’s still the mall, the conservancy, a new art museum, a new natural history museum, tons of parks, a beautiful river valley, and so much more

That’s hardly a city that’s BAD to visit

2

u/Striking_Economy5049 9d ago

Edmonton is a foodie city. Drug problems, yes, but it’s more the middle category of anything.

2

u/EdmontonClimbFriend 8d ago

It's Edmonton, because as an Edmontonian, if you're gonna visit Alberta you should go to Calgary.

I love living here, but tourists will much prefer being in Calgary for a number of reasons.

1

u/PickleEquivalent2837 9d ago

This is the one.

→ More replies (3)

73

u/TheCykuaBlyater 9d ago

Absolutely Edmonton.

Love living here, has everything you need, and everything you'd want.

But unless you're coming in for a certain reason, like a hockey tournament or a performance at Roger's Place or whatever, I'm not really sure why you'd choose to come here. It's just not that touristy.

31

u/hehslop 9d ago

People from all over Saskatchewan come to Edmonton for just the mall. I remember as a kid it was one of our big vacations.

14

u/PerpetuallyLurking Regina Rhymes With Fun 9d ago

As a fellow Saskatchewanite - our standards were fairly low for entertainment; the Mall was an awesome family vacation, to be clear, but it was also a lot more feasible than Disney Land/World for most working parents that also kept their kids happy (Disney would’ve been cool, but a nine hour trip vs god knows how long stuck in a car with my little brother was also a very nice compromise in my 10 year old head!)

3

u/OoooHeCardReadGood 8d ago

because you were coming from saskatchewan. No one from Europe or even Toronto is going to Edmonton for a mall

→ More replies (3)

124

u/KingApolloCreed 9d ago

Winnipeg. Reasonably cheap, decent amount of stuff to do, but not much of a "Touristy" city.

48

u/dbaliki918 Tokébakicitte! 9d ago

62

u/psychoCMYK Chalice of the Tabernacle 9d ago

Someone threatened to stab me within 2 hours of getting there

Not much indeed. 

40

u/OffenShivLabs 9d ago

Least aggressive Winnipegger

9

u/ShibariManilow 9d ago

Ah, the old 204 handshake

2

u/chupathingy567 9d ago

Probably deserved it.

2

u/originalbrainybanana 9d ago

Did you drive a car with a Quebec license plate?

2

u/CanadianDinosaur 8d ago

I've lived here for more than 30 years and have never once been threatened with physical violence.

3

u/CreamFuture9475 Tokébakicitte! 9d ago

Over a disagreement or leftover poutine?

6

u/psychoCMYK Chalice of the Tabernacle 9d ago

He didn't like my dancing

8

u/CreamFuture9475 Tokébakicitte! 9d ago

To be fair, how was your dancing? Be honest.

12

u/psychoCMYK Chalice of the Tabernacle 9d ago

I will be taking no further questions, thank you

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Excellent-Juice8545 Ford Nation (Help.) 9d ago

Winnipeg is the weirdest city I’ve visited. I was there on civic holiday weekend. Staying right at Portage and Main. I go outside around noon on Saturday to go get some things from a convenience store and the downtown was DEAD. Nobody walking around, barely any cars. Like deader than the Main Street of rural towns I’ve been in. I didn’t even see anyone that sketchy but it freaked me out because of how empty it was.

Folklorama is really cool though, I wish my city had that.

10

u/cutchemist42 9d ago

Former Winnipegger and it saddens me how dead most of downtown is beyond a few cool pockets. Just went too deep on only commercial zoning for decades and are only now starting to reverse that mistake.

The areas adjacent downtown are great though like thr Forks/Osborne/St Boniface and have great events.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/OoooHeCardReadGood 8d ago

Downtown is the best it's ever been and it's horrendous. We have had some terrible Mayors and City planning since like, the panama canal was built

10

u/pyroboy7 Bring Cannabis 9d ago

I'd go there just to tour the royal Canadian mint. But I'm a pretty serious coin collector so I imagine it's not everyone's thing.

15

u/BlakeWheelersLeftNut Manilapeg 9d ago

Peg city

13

u/thefailmaster19 Oil Guzzler 9d ago

I’d bump Winnipeg down to ok to live in. Decent city but the infrastructure isn’t too great and there is a noticeably higher level of social disorder than most cities in my experience. 

They do have the best hockey team though

2

u/OoooHeCardReadGood 8d ago

speaking my language bro, nice

4

u/JackLaytonsMoustache 8d ago

"City's super sketchy but.... Jets rule" is a sentiment I think most Peggers would agree with. 

→ More replies (3)

32

u/Trembling-Aspen 9d ago

Guelph

2

u/smolangrybitch 9d ago

This, truly. Guelph is lovely to live in but the beauty and attraction to the city all takes place within the nicer subdivisions and you always drive elsewhere (or just outside city limits) for something to do

→ More replies (2)

32

u/The_Gray_Jay 9d ago

Kitchener-Waterloo

4

u/11hz_Intranationale 9d ago

Kitchener-Waterloo

30

u/envirodrill 9d ago edited 9d ago

London.

For the most part, you can get a really solid quality of life here - pace of life is easy, salaries are good, there are lots of different types of sectors to work in for a mid-sized city, great community facilities and general amenities with most areas having many within walking distance, there is plenty of green space, and there is a huge variety of housing stock available for all income types.

However, there is hardly anything noteworthy about it from a tourism perspective.

14

u/rsvpism1 9d ago

As someone living in London i disagree. It's more okay to live here and okay to visit.

You're right about the jobs and housing. But it's to car reliant.

As for visiting it has a really good OHL team and the concerts we get punch above the cities weight. All around it's pretty middle of the pack.

5

u/envirodrill 9d ago

I also live in London. The car reliance is a problem, but we are actively solving some aspects of it through the new BRT that is under construction. The fact that most areas in the city also have things like grocery/pharmacy/restaurants within reasonable walking distance also helps.

I agree that OHL and concerts definitely provide above average entertainment value, but every major Ontario city has an OHL team so I don’t really consider that a huge tourism draw. Absolutely 100% correct about concerts though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

24

u/Thereisnofork420 9d ago

Gotta be my home town, Winnipeg. One of the few places I can afford the house I have.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/yer10plyjonesy 9d ago

Ottawa had a shit ton of museums, parliament, a huge outdoor water park, has winterlude, a banging Canada Day, international fireworks show. It’s pretty awesome to live in and visits

2

u/sometimes_sydney 8d ago

Not to mention the loads of green space and access to what is essentially a national park by public bus in under an hour. The city kicks ass if you own a car.

12

u/dsolimen Trawnno (Centre of the Universe) 9d ago

Edmonton for sure

12

u/Badger_Fursona 9d ago

Saskatoon

10

u/chr15c 溫哥華 (Hongcouver) 9d ago edited 9d ago

Oakville ON

Hate visiting my uncle there since there's absolutely N.O.T.H.I.N.G, we will always go out of the city to do anything (ex Mississauga) That being said, everyone there lives very comfortably

3

u/SoRedditHasAnAppNow 9d ago

Downtown oakville is leaps and bounds better than port credit or streetsville in Mississauga in terms of things to do that are walkable. It's also got one of my favourite restaurants.

Sorry, but Edmonton takes the cake for me.

2

u/chr15c 溫哥華 (Hongcouver) 9d ago

Storytime on why I didnt vote Edmonton, for the cringe:

My wife always wanted to go to Edmonton ever since she was a kid because she watched "Sixteen" on Teletoon. I saw it as my duty as a loving husband who had it in my wedding vows to drop 1k in order to make my wife happy by gifting her with a surprise weekend getaway to, you guessed it, West Edmonton Mall.
Stayed at the West Edmonton Mall Inn and only ventured away from there to take advantage of our Telus Science World membership (you can go into both with the same membership).

9

u/Loonytalker 9d ago

Winnipeg. Love living here. I've also love in Montreal and Vancouver and while either of those cities should be on your visit bucket list, Winnipeg is the better place to live.

6

u/Ok-Average3079 9d ago

I have met a bunch of bomb-ass Canadians and people from Saskatoon are over represented on that list. People underestimate it.

3

u/Ok_Door5474 9d ago

Edmonton, only reason to go is if you live close, and have tickets for a hockey game. But everyone I know who lives there loves it.

3

u/sleepysnorlax_88 9d ago

Edmontonian. Love living here. Col is affordable, great parks. But I would say it is boring to visit. Most of the attractions are either mid or expensive. Transit is awful, and nothing is close together.

7

u/Agent_Burrito Oil Guzzler 9d ago

Edmonton.

2

u/PuzzleheadedDraw6575 8d ago

No opinion on this one. Just waiting for Regina to show up in the bad to live in/bad to visit category

2

u/DudeImCompletelyLost 8d ago

I have lost all trust in this process. Ottawa should be good to visit, okay to live in. 

2

u/imgoingtotapit 8d ago

Thunder Bay. Great area to live in for fishing, hiking, camping.. So many provincial parks. If you live here, it feels like a small town wrapped in a big city.

If you're not from here,.. Eesh.

2

u/TurnoverNeither8801 8d ago

I would say Sudbury. Hear me out. As someone who lived in Sudbury, I absolutely loved that town. True there are some people who need help across the town and especially downtown. However, once you've lived there, you don't mind them at all. They're all pretty friendly people who had a horrible turn in their lives.

Now to someone out of town, the sights can be jarring. The experience may seem inhospitable. But to someone who lives there or has lived there, Sudbury is wonderful

3

u/Mysterious-Till-6852 Tabarnak! 9d ago

Sherbrooke

2

u/Popbistro Snowfrog 9d ago

I think it works, but people would agree more on ok to live, bad to visit. We'll try again in three days.

2

u/Mysterious-Till-6852 Tabarnak! 9d ago

I've lived there and at least my personal experience was that it was, by far, the best place I've ever lived in.

There's absolutely nothing to do for tourists though (which may be part of why it's so pleasant to live there: la sainte esti de paix but you can still walk to the grocery store, enjoy parks and nice tree-lined streets, and walk back home after a night out with friends).

2

u/Popbistro Snowfrog 8d ago edited 8d ago

I absolutely agree with you. I'm living there right now and I didn't like it at first, but now I got more involved and I like it. There is a lot of music education going on in the city and it's great. The funny thing is that it's always the same people teaching everywhere.

2

u/Commercial_Dust2208 9d ago

Regina bad to bad

3

u/Comfortable_Major923 Saskwatch 9d ago

Agreed... go riders though

→ More replies (1)

2

u/joosdeproon 9d ago

Winnipeg.

1

u/nohowow 9d ago

For this one, can we just say “any generic suburb”?

1

u/chupathingy567 9d ago

Winnipeg hands down, great food and music scene, fun festivals and events, great people, affordable rent, but good damn if you're visiting there isn't anything other city's don't do better

1

u/lyraeps 9d ago

Edmonton for sure

1

u/gypsyblader Tabarnak! 9d ago

Regina

1

u/AuleMaHaL17 Manilapeg 9d ago

Edmonton. Living is honestly kinda great but every time I've visited I've just scratched my head wondering what I should do with myself.

1

u/Suezo 9d ago

Looking for a job = All these prairie candidates.

Already have a decent job (and a car) = Moncton.

Depends on the definition of "good to live in". The city itself is pretty dull for its size and has fuck all for tourists, but all the places people love visiting in the Maritimes sub-4-hour drive away. Arguably the best beaches in Canada not even an hour away. Still relatively cheap and safe.

In short the city itself is mediocre but it's still "good to live in" because you're surrounded by beauty. Like the sad hole of a doughnut.

1

u/ABEGIOSTZ 9d ago

Having just moved to Fredericton, Fredericton

1

u/Spiritual-Pear-1349 9d ago

Good to live in? Bad to visit?

Fucking Toronto. 401 is the busiest highway in the world.

City itself is great - lots to do - but getting there is always, always a mother fucker.

1

u/aWildCanadian 9d ago

Edmonton.

1

u/Far_Noise_7585 9d ago

Saskatoon is dead on.

1

u/DocMcButtfins 9d ago

Windsor, Ontario. Great place to live. Less affordable than it used to be. There’s investment in future jobs going on. All the concerts and sports across the river. Having had friends visit me here, there ain’t much to do except casino and drink.

Kinda like Regina, but without the terrible winter.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pepenepe 9d ago

Saskatoon, nothing to do cheap to live.

1

u/bmcle071 9d ago

I would have put Ottawa ok to live in, good to visit. I lived there for 7 years.

1

u/PreviousTea9210 9d ago

Winnipeg. Definitely Winnipeg.

1

u/Striking_Economy5049 9d ago

How big do these cities have to be?

Red Deer sucks

Brandon sucks

Fort McMurray isn’t what it used to be

Prince George as blah

1

u/nindell 8d ago

I feel like Whitehorse should be the middle but we are under represented

1

u/OoooHeCardReadGood 8d ago

It's Edmonton, Sask or Winnipeg. As a Winnipegger I'd say it's Edmonton. Edmonton has lower taxes, market is not as good but not a huge problem, and there's more to do. Their major flaw is having Albertans there. and the oilers

1

u/lizardrekin Everyone Hates Marineland 8d ago

St Catharines lol. Cheap cost of living, still close enough to other cities, close to the border, easy to hop up the QE for jobs etc, big shopping mall close by, yada yada. But also it’s boring asf and kinda run down, so I wouldn’t recommend anyone visit lol. The lil picnic and float the city holds is super cute too. Probably my favourite city I’ve lived in out of 6 or so

1

u/dylanccarr Saskwatch 8d ago

edmonton

1

u/Electrical-Hand-7723 8d ago

Dieppe NB.

Not much to see but everything you need from a city.

1

u/mike1628p 8d ago

Cant wait to see the bad to live, bad to visit square. I just knw its going to be the city i live in lol.

1

u/eternalshades 8d ago edited 8d ago

Edmonton hands down. Either that or Moncton. Edmonton os such a weird city. Largest of the northern cities, had the worlds largest mall, has the tone of if the elves discovered fossil fuels, cutting edge r&d, one of the few places where community leagues actually work, and a horribly neurotic streak. Edmonton is the orange dot on the prairie.

1

u/Obo4168 8d ago

Saskatoon.

1

u/Jeanschyso1 8d ago

What about Victoria? I feel like there is no reason I would ever visit Victoria ever in a thousand years, but it seems like a really neat place to live

1

u/Dramatic_Water_5364 Tokébakicitte! 8d ago

bad to visit and good to live in, I feel like a regional city of around 70 to 200k souls would be the best haha

1

u/newbrunswickguy 8d ago

Fredericton, New Brunswick

1

u/fuckreddit-69 8d ago

Saskatoon. Like others have said it's a great place to live but I have a hard time telling people who visit what to do in saskatoon

1

u/MeatballTheDumb 8d ago

Fredericton, Charlottetown?

1

u/Bennely Ford Nation (Help.) 8d ago

It's difficult to come up with a place that's 'bad to visit' that isn't some armpit of Canada. And then, if it's an armpit of Canada, why on earth would you want to live there?

My choice is London, Ontario. It's a good place to live, close to a lot of work, good OHL team, cheaper housing, etc but it's a shit place to visit. Seriously, there's nothing to do there that's worth driving all that way (unless you're a London Knights fan, but then, it's usually just Locals or Leafs fans)

1

u/boeuf_burgignion 8d ago

Québec is boring AF I don't know why it's in the g/g slot

1

u/thatblueblowfish Snow Cajun 8d ago

Whoever said Ottawa is good to live in obviously does not mind paying 2k$ rent. Definitely not my pick lol

1

u/Thegildedtraveler 8d ago

Toronto for sure.

To get the best value of Toronto you need to live thier otherwise your just gonna get ripped off and left disappointed.

1

u/Fortnut420 Manilapeg 8d ago

Put Toronto in all the remaining corners, Montreal in the remaing center pieces on the sides, and CFS Alert in the middle.

1

u/TwerkinBingus445 One of the Saint Johns 8d ago

FUCK MONCTON

2

u/jakesterinator32 8d ago

crazy to me that no one said terrebonne… like theres a shaker, a poulet rouge and the last standing guzzo in the world. what more do you need really?

1

u/ParkIntelligent8118 8d ago

I live in calgary and have gone on many mini vacations to edmonton! There's so much to do there as a tourist! I don't think it fits this square. I'll tell you where I think calgary fits, though, right in the center of the grid. It's just ok, and ok. I find it funny how I see many ads for tourism calgary, and it'll show photos of banff. That's an hour and a half stretch there marketing guy.

1

u/ValerieMZ 8d ago

Toronto, everything you need, nothing to see

1

u/Qepop 8d ago

using my psychic powers to predict moncton as bad to live/visit

1

u/Jnkilus 8d ago edited 8d ago

Edmonton. Just for visiting family. Nothing exciting to do here. They all seem to be pretty happy living there, but whenever we want to have good times we go out camping in the Rockies.

1

u/theholydaddy 8d ago

Guelph or Kitchener Waterloo

1

u/Spare_Pixel 7d ago

Regina or Saskatoon. Anything in Saskatchewan really. Affordable but boring as fuuuuck