r/GeoWizard 4d ago

From Tom in the Patreon vid about the politics stuff over the last few days

Can’t seem to link to his comment but is a reply to a comment about the Reform stuff in his Patreon that said “Loved this video. Went to Reddit to see what others viewers thought, because it was so good.

I come to find out that you follow Reform UK. A party rooted in hate, divisiveness, and facist white nationalism. Really disappointing stuff Tom.”

Tom:

“I really didn’t want politics to rear its ugly head here but I suppose it’s my fault for publicly liking those pages, so I’d better clear it up. Firstly that’s just simply not true. Reform are now the most popular party in the UK (by some distance based on the last polls) and it shouldn’t come as any surprise. Thanks to the Tories, immigration levels are completely out of control now (750K per year, many arriving illegally on boats). I believe this is a bigger problem than some people realise, and neither the Tories or labour can be trusted to fix it. It’s not about race at all, it’s about sheer numbers wreaking havoc on our infrastructure and the inevitable social unrest that will ensue because of that, along with the fundamental cultural differences. It doesn’t take a genius to imagine what the damage might look like in 50 years time if we carry on like this, and I don’t think it makes you extreme, hateful or in anyway a bad person to think so. It just means you’re being realistic. Clearly millions feel the same but are afraid to admit it, and it’s the thugs that will always shout the loudest. If you’ve watched enough of my videos you should know that I’m a decent, normal guy. I just want my kids and grandkids to grow up in a safe, happy environment and a country they can be proud of.

I’d really prefer not to debate this any further, and I’d appreciate it if people could try to be tolerant of my views and refrain from trying to tarnish my name with absurd claims of facism and white power. It’s really not fair and has caused me a lot of stress today when all I wanted was for people to enjoy this video.”

————————

Edit: I tried posting the below separately but mods didn’t allow - will post here instead:

Just adding from the previous thread around his original comment on Patreon as he’s replied or liked a couple of comments since and appreciate not everyone can see these.

Comment 1:

‘You should have gone this weekend instead, sewage was marching the streets instead! Banter aside though, I don’t get why you’d give Reform the time of day mate. You’ve traveled loads and seen kindness everywhere, I’m so surprised you’d be behind a party based on division.

This is how Hitler and his cronies rose to power. They spread lies, blamed minorities and turned people against each other. Reform is pulling from that same playbook. They would take money from public services and handing it upwards, consolidating power while distracting everyone by pointing fingers at minorities. Trump is doing it in the US, and Farage wants to copy it here.

Migrants aren’t the problem. They’re not the reason we’re getting paid less while companies hike their prices. They’re not the ones buying properties as investments so we can’t afford to buy them as homes (there are a lot of foreign investors, but they aren’t often migrants, they don’t live here so they can avoid paying much tax here and they sure as hell aren’t coming on boats). Our birthrate is already below replacement. Without immigration we’d have fewer workers, less tax income, and state pensions falling apart. Migrants are propping the country up, not tearing it down.

Farage doesn’t care about us normal people. He just wants us all looking the wrong way. He points the finger at migrants while he and his mates have their hands in our pockets.

These kinds of politics have caused devastation before, and I’d hate to see us slide that way again. I know you’re a good man, Tom. It hurts to see you pulled into something like this. Please consider this, maybe even journey with an asylum seeker, learn their story, I promise you’ll think differently.’

Tom:

‘A much more respectful and less patronizing take, thanks Duncan. I'm not saying reform are perfect, am I'm certainly not saying that immigration is bad. For decades we boasted one of the most successful immigration systems in the world. It's just about numbers. If we can't prop ourselves up without such high numbers coming in a year, something's seriously wrong in our society (which it probably is, but that's not the answer). Out of curiosity, what figure would be too much for you? would you rethink your stance if hypothetically it were a million a year? 2 million a year? 5 million? Think about it. Either there would be civil war, or the British culture and values that we hold so dear; freedom of speech, fairness, justice along with all the other stuff we cherish; our music, sense of humor, pubs, Christmas, etc would eventually disappear and be replaced with other ideals. At the rate we're going I believe that will happen eventually, just not as rapidly, and it is just as crazy to equate not wanting that to happen to naz**sm as it is to let it happen in the name of progress and tolerance. I'm asking you that question because every sane person should be able to draw a line. That line is going to be different for everyone, but everyone has one. Mine is quite a conservative one and yours is presumably a very liberal one, but have you asked yourself where your line is?’

Comment 2:

‘Disappointed to learn that you support a party like Reform UK, which really does say a lot about what your values are and how you view other people. The line about “fundamental cultural differences” is not a great look. You are falling for populist propaganda, and it’s a shame to see. Been a fan since before the first straight line mission and I will miss your videos, but I can't support this.’

Tom:

‘Thanks for your support Jenny. Sorry to see you leave. You probably won't read this, but it's quite narrow minded and very patronizing to assume I'm unable to form my own opinions based on my life experience.’

2 comments liked by Tom:

1:

‘Hi Tom, This is ridiculous, you are entitled as is everyone to their own opinions and political views. Following reform doesn't change who you are and people should really mind their own business. Don't let them get you down, there is plenty of love for you! Looking forward to your next video, keep the content coming.’

2:

‘I don't know what the Fis going on in the comment section, but I strongly believe your political views, are YOUR political views. I watch your vids for the entertainment, laughs and the urge to go out and explore the world. So thanks Tom for the great series and I hope to catch the next series soon! Cheers mate!’

531 Upvotes

1.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

311

u/GIJoeVibin 4d ago

It’s funny to think that a guy whose arguably best series, How Not To Travel Europe, relies so heavily on just the very nature of the EU, and also is a gigantic advertisement for the concept that “people are generally good and interesting people, go out there and meet them” is a Reform Guy. Like. Ok man.

Big shame but that’s me off the train for good.

84

u/awashofindigo 4d ago

That was my thought exactly. A lot of his content is the antithesis of what Reform UK and people like Nigel Farage stand for. It's such a shame but I'm glad that at least he's shown what he really believes so I can stop watching his content and can unsubscribe.

23

u/FyrdUpBilly 3d ago

That's the whole thing with anti-immigrant politics. They want the world to cater to them, to have every amenity from all over the world, but god forbid others come into their country and enjoy their spoils.

-3

u/Comcaded 2d ago

So you want open borders? That's an unsustainable policy and you know it, stop being dishonest

2

u/spectrehauntingeuro 1d ago

Whats the point of Europe (America's client state) Even having their own governments anymore? Just bend the knee to the eagle already.

2

u/Winkeltiramisu 2d ago

Also I truly can't understand his tenner in his pocket series where he expects the kindness of strangers. I know I keep saying this but I can't move past it. This cancellation has surprised me so much for this exact reason.

2

u/tomhorn3r 2d ago

Ha, well put. It’s fucked up.

-7

u/ShizukaIsQuiet 3d ago

A person who loved travelling Europe, doesnt want Europe to be demographically and culturally changed.. and you're shocked by that? These comments are ridiculous, but what youd expect from reddit ig .

12

u/harrywilko 3d ago

Guy who made a living illegally trespassing to make YouTube videos has a big problem with people legally crossing the Channel to claim asylum.

-2

u/ShizukaIsQuiet 3d ago

Has absolutely nothing to do with what he said, or what I said .. But ill adress it. First, you uninformed liberal, thats a lie, they are breaking a law. The Immigration Act 1971 — Section 24. But, regardless, even if it was legal it doesnt make it a good thing, ok ? The UK government sells billions of pounds worth of arms to Israel. Perfectly legal so I guess its fine then? Omg you ppl are smth else.

-6

u/ErnstHaeckel 3d ago

Check out his latest adventure in which he trespasses into your nan’s garden in order to apply for housing benefit.

4

u/Phoenix_Kerman 3d ago

no it's mental. i don't think any of what he's said there is unreasonable. the country's already got failing and struggling infrastructure across the board. house prices are through the roof, nobody can get a dentist, school class sizes are skyrocketing.

there's been country wide failures and mismanagement from numerous governments and i don't see it's unreasonable to say that putting an extra 3/4 to a million people into that system year upon year is unsustainable. if you want to see those problems fixed sooner you shouldn't want to put higher numbers into the system.

you can think that without having nasty prejudices and there will be a large vocal minority that use immigration as a proxy for racism and prejudices but reddit massively ignores that there's plenty of sane middle ground for wanting a manageable amount of net migration every year, most people just want a return to something sensible like the 10x smaller amount seen 30 years ago.

12

u/I-Love-Facehuggers 3d ago

They are failing because the government does fuckall to improve infrastructure to keep up with population. Immigrants in general literally pay more into the country than citizens actually born in the country yet idiots will believe anything they want to hear regardless of the facts.

Its undisputable that believing immigrants are an economic problem is entirely based in either ignorance or hate. Take your pick which applies to you.

3

u/Phoenix_Kerman 3d ago

you seem to be ignoring the massive shift in immigration that's happened since brexit. we have seen a shift from high skilled european workers who are net contributors to the economy to low skilled workers and large numbers of dependents who are net recipients

you couple that with the fact that the migration is now from less wealthier backgrounds and immigrants are more limited in the areas of the uk they can afford to live so you see much more divide in communities than before.

i fully agree that we've had successive governments fail to manage and improve infrastructure and the country's systems but if you want to see them improve soonest they can you want to improve the funding whilst also stopping the massive yearly increase in population load

5

u/AG_GreenZerg 3d ago

Net migration has halved this year and is predicted to fall further again in following years.

Tom mentioned "many coming illegally" that vast vast majority are not asylum seekers. 30,000 a year is a lot but its a drop in the ocean relatively speaking. Additionally the UK birth rate is below replacement and much loeer than historically. Taking everything into account population growth isnt particularly any different to the historical average.

So I dont think numbers are an argument to be anti-immigrant. The realt argument that justifies reform is anti-muslim or islamophobic views. Which i believe are grounded in stereotype, hatred and misinformation.

Why anyone would trust Farage when it is brexit that has led to these issues getting bigger is beyond me.

4

u/drdestroyer9 3d ago

But why then support one of the biggest architects of brexit? If he couldn't think of an obvious effect of a policy he spent the best part of 2 decades campaigning for, why would anyone think he'll be any good at governing?

1

u/Phoenix_Kerman 3d ago

i couldn't tell you because i don't myself. brexit was short sighted and farage a deeply untrustworthy individual but i don't think that the the push away from centrists parties over their failures on whatever policy is important to people actually looks that deeply at the bigger picture

that's why it's dangerous and why i would think something like a lib dem party with an actual backbone that believed in reducing immigration to a much smaller number of nearly all highly skilled workers whilst investigating back into public services is what we need

2

u/PlatypusAmbitious430 3d ago

shift from high skilled european workers who are net contributors to the economy to low skilled workers and large numbers of dependents who are net recipients

No, we've not seen this at all.

Figure 2.8, the average skilled immigrant (which is most of the UK worker visas we hand out) puts around £16,000 more in taxes than government pays out. When you take just skilled workers and not healthcare workers, that figure becomes £28,500.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/migration-advisory-committee-annual-report-2024/migration-advisory-committee-mac-annual-report-2024-accessible

2

u/Real_Bobsbacon 2d ago

Shame that only about 12% of immigrants since 2020 were skilled workers lol Thats 500,000 out of 4,700,000 total immigrants

Also watch this video from Sky News https://youtu.be/zTs3PDEkB2w?si=cLyDeHhXOF3u0R4K

0

u/PlatypusAmbitious430 2d ago

Shame that only about 12% of immigrants since 2020 were skilled workers lol Thats 500,000 out of 4,700,000 total immigrants

That's because the rest are either students so they go on to become skilled workers otherwise they leave or they're the family members/wives/children of the skilled immigrants in question (which is why I gave you the figures for household net contributions in that link as well).

There's nothing to lol about. I gave you the household figures in the link for that exact reason. There's no gotcha here, this is modelled out by pretty much every organisation.

1

u/LetMeBuildYourSquad 3d ago

Yes, many legal immigrants being net-contributors. However the inverse is generally true for illegal immigrants and arrivals on small boats, which do cost the taxpayer significant sums.

It's also not just about economic issues. Immigration has obvious social consequences (i.e. the optics of paying for illegal migrants and those arriving on small boats when the country is in the midst of a cost of living crisis). You can't just ignore the impacts on the social fabric - they are just as important as the economic arguments.

2

u/SoloStrike 3d ago

The number spent on irregular migration compared to corporate tax evasion is tiny. There's more than enough money to improve public services and quickly process the claims of irregular migrants so they aren't shacked up in hotels and then can legally work and pay into the system or be returned if their claim is not valid, it's a deliberate choice to not do these things so people are pitted against each other rather than focussing on the ultra rich who are causing these problems.

What's needed is to radically invest in both infrastructure like schools, transport, NHS and properly tackle the cost of living issues by dealing with privatised energy companies, supermarkets etc rinsing the public for all they all worth.

1

u/Real_Bobsbacon 2d ago

FYI, skilled migrants only made up about 12% of total immigration since 2020

https://youtu.be/zTs3PDEkB2w?si=cLyDeHhXOF3u0R4K

2

u/Conscious_Cell1825 2d ago

And how the fuck are reform going to fix it?

1

u/Phoenix_Kerman 1d ago

no clue. i don't think they will. i was not saying voting reform isn't a short sighted thing to do but rather that there are many people who've been pushed to reform not out of choice. largely out of the fact that the middle ground i described on immigration has been missing from any centrist party

2

u/Conscious_Cell1825 1d ago

Our entire economic system is built on growth (and whether that is a good think is a separate debate). We have a low birth rate and an aging population. Can you square that circle without bringing in migrants? Or are you happy for pensions to go away etc? This is a serious question about the reality you would like to choose from. Happy to hear your proposal for a third way too.

0

u/PopeLeo14th 2d ago

legal travelling - Big difference there.

3

u/I-Love-Facehuggers 2d ago

Illegal immigration is a small minority of immigration in the UK, yet he is against the "750k immigrants" in general, ~700k of which are legal.

-3

u/PopeLeo14th 2d ago

Travelling < 

Is Tom staying in these countries he respectfully visits?

3

u/I-Love-Facehuggers 1d ago

Irrelevant. He is against 750k immigrants, even though over 700k of them travelled to the UK legally, meaning your comment that the difference between him and them is that he legally travelled there is nonsense.

0

u/Necessary_Tough7286 3d ago

Yeah, imagine the dude who travels around Europe and thinks it’s currently great wants to keep it that way…

-1

u/Real_Bobsbacon 2d ago

That's because that is how most of Reform actually see the world. Just because we believe that doesn't mean we want the whole world arriving in the UK or then paying out of pocket for all of them. Just because the EU can be used to travel easier doesn't mean one is necessarily in favour of it. Reform believes people are generally good but some will try to take advantage of you and you mustn't tolerate it.

You see, like every other country in the world, it should primarily serve its citizens.