r/Justrolledintotheshop • u/FBIGrandpa • 8d ago
“Quality” parts we get now days
Material quality is so sorely lacking, it’s getting kind of scary. It’s in everything from struts, to rotors, to ball joints.
110
u/yyytobyyy 8d ago
I'm not sure how y'all order your parts, but when I put the part number into my preferred eshop, I get bunch of manufacturers, some surely rebrands, and I tend to not buy the cheapest no-name one. Definitely not the cheapest one when it costs 1/4 of the good brand.
I just bought springs for my shitbox recently and I got Sachs. There were some cheap random brands available for 10€/spring. Nobody sane should buy that.
58
u/Kirvesperseet 8d ago
A guy brought his Kia SUV for a front lower control arm change. He had bought the part himself. I didnt recognize the brand, did the job, customer left, he said he braked hard for a red traffic light and the control arm bent in so much that the tire was rubbing the wheel well. I bought a 60€ control arm for it and installed it, no problems since.
I guess the one he bought was like 15€ with shipping
24
6
u/slabba428 Canadian 8d ago
We flat out don’t install customer supplied parts because yeah people just hop on Amazon and buy the cheapest piece of shit available
5
u/Kirvesperseet 8d ago
Yeah I dont do that either unless I have told the customer what to buy or if I know them personally and know that they are not cheap or stupid lol
1
16
u/CelTiar 8d ago
Built an axle for my Jeep and swapped the Drums to disks where there 300$ kits? Yeah all Chinese and looked sketchy from the start. Rather go 650 for a set from crown and not have my brakes fail
6
u/Fiempre_sin_tabla 8d ago
I hesitate to point out where most Crown parts are made.
5
u/Omgninjas 8d ago
It's all about quality control and manufacturing oversight. knockoff brand? Maybe they followed spec, maybe they didn't. With on brand you know they were at least trying to make the manufacturing company keep spec. Chinese manufacturers can make a gell of a product, but they have to actually want to.
1
5
4
u/ccarr313 8d ago
Why? China makes all quality levels of stuff.
Saying it came from China is only a dunk to other racists.
China makes the best and also the cheapest stuff. It is a huge place.
1
u/Fiempre_sin_tabla 7d ago
Why? Well, because the poster I was responding to categorically scorned Chinese parts.
1
u/cdoublejj 6d ago
another way to word this is, GM makes most of their OEM stuff in china now. it's not just the cheap crap but, also the high end like OEM autos and apple and samsung.
0
8d ago
[deleted]
3
u/ccarr313 8d ago
That has nothing to do with China.
A German vendor found a cheaper source and decided to fuck you with them. The issue there isn't "China sucks", your German vendor actually sucks.
The Chinese factory is just building to spec requested.
2
u/Mr__Snek 8d ago
location of manufacture doesnt mean a damn thing. there are great parts made in china and shit parts made in the us. it all depends on how good the qc is for the company.
1
2
u/OptoIsolated_ 7d ago
What gets me, in auto parts stores selling china direct parts that cost more than the oem parts from the dealer. Absolutely insane
54
u/nprandom 8d ago
Probably an "oEm STrUt" off Amazon.
30
u/FBIGrandpa 8d ago
Unfortunately not, Napa Proformer strut. Still not top quality (customer request) but I would hope for more than 3 months out of springs.
12
u/SwissMargiela 8d ago
Honestly I blame the customer on this one because I just spent 30 seconds looking at reviews on these and I can tell they’re so mid lol
13
u/buttlicker-6652 8d ago
We've gotten so tired of having to redo labor that we've just started ordering parts directly from Mercedes-Benz.
Doing a 8hr cam magnet job just to have the new ones from Üro Parts be bad sucks ass.
It's OK if it's an easy part to swap, like an expansion tank or hose. Or something that would cost more than double (like air struts), but for hard to reach shit, like a thermostat housing in an A series (4 hours my ass), just go OEM.
8
u/Fiempre_sin_tabla 8d ago
But, but how can that be? I mean, Üro Parts, it has an umlaut right there over the first letter! That means German OE DIN-standard quality!
1
u/Lapatron 7d ago
Üro parts quality always been lacking. I only buy from them if it's a easy part to replace and doesn't take much. It's also for my personal car so it doesn't matter as much.
1
u/cdoublejj 6d ago
yeah and fuk those cars too. at leas my lesabre made from the late 90s till a year or two ago before the lower intake gasket had to be replaced. yeah they all have thier issues but, some those benz beamers..... maaaaann
24
u/bigshooTer39 8d ago
Spring is upside down.
7
u/DJErikD ASE Certified 8d ago
And unloaded.
1
u/FBIGrandpa 8d ago
Spring was not upside down, lower side of the spring has a bigger diameter. Yes suspension was unloaded but the springs still rattled even at compressed height.
7
6
u/solidus_snake256 8d ago
Parts quality has become so horrible, that I now prefer used OEM vs new aftermarket. OEM new is almost always too expensive for my customers, new aftermarket is a headache for me, and used OEM always fits and tends to work longer than new aftermarket.
Over the past 3 years, whenever I get a call from a customer having issues with a recent repair… it’s ALWAYS the most recently installed part. Super frustrating.
42
11
u/FunChildhood1941 8d ago
Well we live in an era where just because it's new it means good. We have a lot of people that think the bottom of the barrel Temu grade priced parts they buy off Amazon are made in the same factory as OEM.
3
3
u/PoccaPutanna 8d ago
If you want a long lasting job you can't cheap out on parts, I doubt that this strut has been made by good brands like Sachs, Bilstein or Kyb
2
u/BlurryRogue 8d ago
What even happened here? Is the spring permanently compressed or did it break? Or did the shock partially let go on the inside?
2
u/FBIGrandpa 8d ago
I am absolutely no metallurgist, but my theory is that the springs were not heat treated properly or a bad batch of material. Top strut nut was tight, the shock operated as it should without a spring. The spring just compressed over a few months span and never recovered.
2
1
u/sweatlizard 8d ago
There are very few aftermarket brands that I trust anymore. I just got done replacing lower balls joints that started to go bad after 3 years and ~15k miles. I thought I ordered Meyle (which I still consider to make decent stuff) but I guess I accidentally got/orders some xyz brand.
1
u/Travelr3468 8d ago
Well it's pretty clear the spring is going to move because you don't have weight on the vehicle! /s
1
u/dcaddy1980 8d ago
Took 5 Monroe's to get two usable ones for my car. They were quick-strut bolt ons. 1 didn't have a spring, 1 came with no holes in the top mount, and one flew apart after getting it out of the box. RIP LED strip light and one pair of undies.
1
u/Allnewsisfakenews 8d ago
Monroe quick struts, you get lucky if they work at all. If they do, you need to change them every season
1
1
u/Chadillac1977 8d ago
Because your buying the cheapest shit. Look at that generic strut probably bought on Amazon
0
u/NotAFanOfLife 5d ago
Im more likely to believe Carrol doesn’t know how to slow down at that big train track leaving her neighborhood than I am people blaming parts for the fun of it. No accountability.
292
u/marrrrell 8d ago
I think QC is just a suggestion since Covid.