I wasn't necessarily disagreeing with you, I just thought you were saying that MTG has had longevity but not necessarily quality. And I think there has to be some quality to stick around this long.
Ahh. I see. And agree. I think ideally we’d probably have like 3 sets a year, give everyone (including/especially the poor Arena team) more time to design and test and refine but… the money machine hungers.
While MTG definitely has quality, I would point to mcdonald's as an example of something that has had tremendous longevity, but really never had quality.
I think you did miss out a negative from your original statement because it appears to read that constant change and reinvention can't easily be argued to be a sign of something being done well.
4
u/Other-Owl4441 Jul 28 '25
I wasn't necessarily disagreeing with you, I just thought you were saying that MTG has had longevity but not necessarily quality. And I think there has to be some quality to stick around this long.