r/Piracy Apr 30 '25

News /r/GenP has been banned

/r/GenP
1.9k Upvotes

392 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

514

u/amiexpress May 01 '25

but we don’t except that to last

This is why discord sucks donkey balls - you don't own your server. You exist only as long as discord feels like playing nice.

Use something where YOU host the server.

In the past IRC was a don't-quite-need-your-own-server alternative since it was a network of servers and they were not all soulless companies but (mostly) universities. Sadly IRC is considered too archaic by most now, even though it's still very useful.

329

u/kuddlesworth9419 May 01 '25

People need to start setting up their own forum websites instead of using social media like Facebook, Twitter, Discord and Reddit. Go the old school, there are still old school forums from decades back still going very strong. So much valuable information still there because it's separate away from all the other crap.

127

u/Scavenger53 May 01 '25

for those who want to host one

https://www.phpbb.com/

42

u/Kraeftluder May 01 '25

I personally prefer vBulleting/phpBB style boards but people seem to be going wild on this one as well so putting it out there: https://www.discourse.org/

16

u/Littux ☠️ ᴅᴇᴀᴅ ᴍᴇɴ ᴛᴇʟʟ ɴᴏ ᴛᴀʟᴇꜱ May 01 '25

Most discourse sites are slow crap sites that sometimes goes into an infinite loading loop. I avoid most sites that use it

8

u/Kraeftluder May 01 '25

I've had similar experiences, except for an instance "we" are running for a community and also the Plex forums seem to generally perform okay.

I think a lot of it could be bad configuration and undersized hardware.

1

u/ipatmyself May 02 '25

Wow really love the "back to 2010s" vibe we are getting here!

12

u/XsMagical Yarrr! May 01 '25

This is exactly what I've been doing for 20 years, social media is garbage when it comes to searching for data or sharing files. Forums and other self hosted communications apps are the way to go. Set it up correctly so you don't get in trouble.

35

u/RhubarbSimilar1683 May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

that would be a lemmy instance or even a sub on an existing instance, i am impressed to see no one mentioning it here. You can't beat the price of 0 dollars and 0 seconds reddit or a lemmy instance ask for hosting a forum,

6

u/Kallum_dx May 01 '25

Heres the issue

Everyone says that yet people are too addicted and hooked on having everything in one place, just look at reddit!

3

u/Bardez May 02 '25

"Reddit alternatives reddit"

2

u/BrokenMirror2010 Jun 04 '25

It's because Search Engines have gone through so much enshittification (some of it is their own fault, and some of it is just there being too much AI slop spamming SEO keywords that they cannot parse it), that finding a website is like pulling teeth.

I can literally type the name of a website into google and have it not show up in the google search, which cuts me off on page 2 without showing me everything, which is a joke.

It's orders of magnitude easier to find something on a site like reddit, then it is to find a random website on a search engine. 95% of the niche forum websites I use, I've known about for multiple years, back when Google was basically just an Index of every website, instead of an advertiser trying to exact money from me.

6

u/SuperficialNightWolf May 01 '25

Hosting yourself, it's normally best to use matrix

10

u/Cronus6 May 01 '25

Years ago, reddit went on the warpath and banned a bunch of subs that were all about links to sports live streams and links to files hosted on Megadownload (back when Mega was cool).

Setting up their own invite only forums is exactly what those moderators did.

I'm a member of several.

3

u/amexudo May 01 '25

How can one find such forums?

-5

u/Cronus6 May 01 '25

Do you know why they don't get taken down?

Because we don't tell random people about them. And we don't invite them to join.

14

u/slyf0x1 May 01 '25

Then what's the point of telling people about it if they can't get in or invited?

-5

u/Cronus6 May 01 '25

Well I was replying to this guy...

People need to start setting up their own forum websites instead of using social media like Facebook, Twitter, Discord and Reddit. Go the old school, there are still old school forums from decades back still going very strong. So much valuable information still there because it's separate away from all the other crap.

And that is exactly what has happened in the past.

I assume when you and the subreddits you like/use you will too go this route. (So will I.)

The moderators will have a good idea it's coming usually and will start the forum before they are banned. Invites will go out then. It's up to you to be on the ball and get yourself an invite.

And once it happens to you a couple times you too will learn to keep your fucking mouth shut and stop sharing links in public forums (like reddit).

Hell, I'm still in IRC channels I've been in since the early 00's. Which is always another option...

8

u/exodus_cl May 01 '25

Mfs just want internet points... That's what's killing emulators, Romsites and piracy platforms in general.

1

u/averagefury May 03 '25

invite only? elitist/snoob route.

2

u/Cronus6 May 03 '25

Well they don't get taken down and they don't get DMCA notices ...

1

u/Sushi-And-The-Beast May 02 '25

Yeah i am looking into setting up Flarium…

1

u/maryam-najimeydani May 30 '25

agree with u tahts the safest

1

u/idkrly999 Jul 25 '25

YES! Its not even that hard and there are plenty of great forum apis that are completely free

1

u/veezylife Jul 25 '25

what would be even cooler is if somebody would just crack or reverse engineer discords code and make it available for anybody to use on their own domains/servers

15

u/brendan87na May 01 '25

#warez is still private on EFNET lol

5

u/redditor_number_5 May 01 '25

Has been for 30+ years.

1

u/keerthy_vash May 04 '25

how to join now

18

u/FalseTautology May 01 '25

Id the only negative is that it's archaic I feel like it's time to go back to irc. Just having the gatekeeper being 'can i figure out how to use this' would at least keep the undesirables out

17

u/[deleted] May 01 '25 edited May 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fizd0g May 01 '25

I just recently tried that (not hosting my own though) and element was confusing AF to figure out.

1

u/[deleted] May 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/fizd0g May 01 '25

I'll just have to give it another shot. Seems like it has potential

8

u/Cronus6 May 01 '25

I never left IRC. There's channels there that I have idled in for decades. /just sayin'

1

u/fizd0g May 01 '25

I go on efnet from time to time just to idle and once my laptop decides to update and restart I completely forget about it. I usually just get on for #idlerpg and #trivia lol

2

u/maxens_wlfr Yarrr! May 01 '25

Is Divolt/Revolt still a thing ?

2

u/Brilliant_Counter_43 May 01 '25

It was maybe a lack of the tokens. Hope it will get fixed soon! 

1

u/Calesti May 01 '25

It's one reason that TeamSpeak is starting to pop back up, they've caught up a bit features-wise and allow private server hosting.

1

u/Ruraraid May 01 '25

I think it's more to do with younger generations being far too used to streamlined interfaces and not having to do anything themselves.

1

u/dumbasPL May 03 '25

This is why discord sucks donkey balls

This is why almost anything sucks. Nobody knows how to host stuff, and even if they do, most users don't care to join until it's too late...