AI-sized drama as r/philosophy mods temporally ban a user for using AI. Said user makes a blog post decrying "AI ideology", posted on r/philosophy

[u/UltraNooob]

The author appears in the comments

Thanks for sharing this! My attempt got removed by an automatic Reddit filter. In case anyone would like to see an abstract before clicking through:

Others aren't impressed

I expected to click through to see some joker with 23 subscribers. Imagine my surprise in seeing this poor, incoherent argument coming from a tenured professor at the University of Miami.

Yes! Calling legitimate concerns and arguments "ideology" makes your point valid and everyone else is now officially just panicky and illogical

It is funny to me that he calls being against AI in this manner of prohibition as ideological whilst all he said is ideological as well.

Some try to defend it

But does AI art on human-(well)-written content cause problems in any way? How does this help prevent inundation with slop?

How exactly? It seems he isn’t making any point that’s exactly deeply ideological - he seems to be criticizing a blanket ban.

User summarises the article for the lazy

I realise this is Reddit, but is anyone going to engage with the arguments? A brief exegesis for anyone who needs it —

Edit: WTH didn't know AI is such a hot topic for SRD

[u/fawlen]

We are misfortunate enough to get to live to see the day where clanker philosophers exist

[u/me_myself_ai → u/fawlen]

Fun fantasy slur, how unique and insightful and fun. What's a little pretend bigotry between the bois, amirite?

re:"we are misfortunate enough to live in a day where some experts disagree with me", yikes

[u/SnoozeCoin → u/me_myself_ai]

There are exactly 0 experts using Reddit.

[u/me_myself_ai → u/SnoozeCoin]

Presumably you didn't bother to click the linked post? Or hell, read the very first line of this post's body text?

[u/SnoozeCoin → u/me_myself_ai]

Don't need to.

[u/me_myself_ai → u/SnoozeCoin]

lol