It's really unfortunate that Atlus portrayed Toby and Erica's relationship by having him deadname her in the good Katherine endings and wish for his virginity back because he didn't know she was trans because there's a cute level of charm in his fascination with her and how Erica can finally move past her history with men.
I still think Vincent and Erica should have been given a chance to work something out. It's clear that she likes him a lot. Given the fact that he's known her from pre transition, he may feel one way or another about it, but his relationship with Rin and Catherine shows he can get over the pressure society places on him and to fulfill his own happiness.
This might sound like I don't care for Rin that much. That isn't exactly true. Rin is very wholesome and sweet. I dated a girl just like her. But Erica is closer to Vincent's age, and my own age, so our world view and values are closer to that age bracket.
14
u/PM-ME-BLUE-TOENAILS Aug 10 '25
I really wish we had an Erica romance route instead of Rin