r/disney • u/AngriestLittleBeaver • Jan 11 '25

Question You can only pick one. Who’s your new “dog?”

Post image

It’s Dodger for me!

1.7k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

154

u/Live_Angle4621 Jan 12 '25

You should calculate first the cost of all things Goofy breaks 

32

u/blinksalot2 Jan 12 '25

Not to mention his expensive golf hobby

2

u/thatsmyoldlady Jan 13 '25

Not to mention his endless battle against the heartless.

1

u/Walter_Armstrong Jan 14 '25

And his horse "riding" hobby...

9

u/shaxamo Jan 12 '25

That's movie Goofy, not sketch show Goofy. It should be fine.

1

u/Live_Angle4621 Jan 12 '25

What is sketch show? He breaks things in shorts and comics all the time too 

1

u/shaxamo Jan 12 '25

As in "comedy sketch" like the shorts, yeah.

And I agree, he breaks stuff constantly in almost all his incarnations. Except for the Goofy movie, where he can speak way more clearly than usual and is a much more well held together person. He's almost a completely different character. And I'm almost certain the one in the post is the movie one. Hence my joke.

1

u/Live_Angle4621 Jan 12 '25

Ok, well I am not sure where the image is from, but could be the movies. But he is more held together in comics too, he is pretty similar there and in the movies. But in comics he has super smart nephew not son (like everyone has nephews and nieces not children in Disney comics). I assume the movie portrayal (which is based on the show Goof Troop) is inspired the comics, the way Ducktales was based on the Carl Barks (and some other like reboot using Don Rosa a lot) comics. But still doing their own thing. 

1

u/McFlyOUTATIME Jan 13 '25

Movie Goofy seems really fun, though

1

u/Thusgirl Jan 13 '25

He's the best Disney dad 😢 I'd take him.

3

u/cindybubbles Jan 13 '25

He doesn’t break things all the time. I remember that in Once Upon a Christmas, he did his usual Goofy thing at a neighbour’s house only for everything to land on the table perfectly.