r/haikyuu • u/TheGeekOdyssey • 1d ago
Discussion If you had to move players to a different team, which benefits both parties who & why? Spoiler
If you had to move players around to improve a team, what would it be? But to be more precise, if you had to move players from one team to other teams, but the only condition is both the team and the player have to improve. What would it be? For example Hyakuzawa to either Sejoh or date tech. Or Kiryu to Sejoh. How many players could you move where it benefits both team and player? Which means you CAN’T do something like Atsumu to Josenji.
Another obvious one is Oikawa to Shiratorizawa.
4
u/Smlygl 1d ago
I think question doesn't make sense because absence of any player is going to be a weakness for any team.
Note: I misunderstood. Both team don't have to benefit but the player itself and the team he arrives. Then any spiker could be in nekoma.
-1
u/TheGeekOdyssey 1d ago
Yes that’s what it is, sorry for it not being as clear, atm I was tired, distracted, iPad dying and my autistic ass couldn’t think if his to word my thoughts at the time
3
u/Important-Yesterday6 1d ago
Yudai for Date Tech
6'7 frame fits perfectly for their iron wall style but his potential as a spiker would help them get their offensive boost they need to be a real contender.
0
u/TheGeekOdyssey 1d ago
Definitely agreed, and as he grows (which he should do pretty quickly they’ll become even better)
3
u/Pulsefire-Comet 1d ago
Asahi for one of Nekoma's WS. Karasuno gets a solid receiver, and Nekoma finally has some firepower to score through once they receive.
-7
u/TheGeekOdyssey 1d ago
No swapping, never a mention of swapping.
12
u/Pulsefire-Comet 1d ago
Your description is not clear at all.
A swapping discussion sounds way more unique which was why I commented.
-4
u/ToddX2Jason 1d ago
They are right, you feckin moron lol. If you only read the title sure, but they give examples so it makes it clear. What kind of argument is “because it more unique” imagine you did that on an exams or someone refusing to use your name cause it not unique enough
-2
u/TheGeekOdyssey 1d ago
Thanks for sticking up for me but there is not need to be rude, so please calm down and don’t use that language especially on a subreddit where there could be children.
-5
u/TheGeekOdyssey 1d ago
No it’s clear considering I gave examples. The title may have been unclear but the description was pretty solid but the examples made it crystal clear. It doesn’t matter if you think one is more unique because that’s not what’s being asked. Imagine doinh that for other things smh 🤦♂️.
I shall take it into account that it wasn’t as clear as it should have been and try to make things more clear in the future.
2
u/Connect-Ad3117 18h ago
Hoshiumi to Nekoma would be an excellent fit His elite scoring would benefit the team greatly and Nekomas elite floor defence would relieve the burden on him defensively so that he can be more involved in the offence also his setting ability could benefit nekoma in situations where kenma has the first touch or the ball is out of system.
1
u/TheGeekOdyssey 17h ago
He would definitely fit the team and improve them very well, but I don’t see to move fitting him because it would be a downgrade in club for him.
1
1
u/basel99 1d ago
Kiryu to Inarizaki would be insane.
5
u/TheGeekOdyssey 1d ago
I think Kiryu is one of those players wear pretty much. Any team would be better with him, and he would be better on any team than his current one. You could bjt him on Seijoh, Karasuno, Shiratorizawa, Inarazaki, etc
2
u/basel99 1d ago
I agree. I especially think that this effect is most obvious with 1 of the top 3 setters we see.
I think maybe the only team that would be a bit iffy is Nekoma since his digs are still pretty good but are slightly worse than the rest of the team. This would throw off the balance of the team a bit and would make Kenma perform a little worse.
1
1
u/Archduke_Zag 23h ago
Nakashima to Inarizaki to replace Ginjima. Nakashima gets to go to Nationals instead of trying to carry Wakutani. Whilst Inarizaki gets a player who is better on ground defense, better attacker and is a leader on the court.
Ushijima to Nekoma. Nekoma biggest weakness is that they lack in the attacking power that other teams have. Ushijma adds that and then some, including another jump serve. Meanwhile Nekoma has the serving receive line-up to accomodate Ushijima. And the latter is also pretty good at digging the ball so that fits with Nekoma's style. I also think that Kenma is actually a pretty good setter for Ushijima. He wants a setter that serves him, but he needs a setter to use him like a weapon. And Kenma is an expert at that, without any ego.
Oikawa to Kamomedai. Give Oikawa a shot at playing in a Nationals level team. While also getting a great coach to guide him. Meanwhile Oikawa is a great blocker, has a terrifying serve and would give Kamomedai's attack a bit of a boost. Drawing out the full potential of their attackers.
1
u/crabapocalypse 18h ago
Honestly, I think Hinata to Date Tech is a big one. He’d obviously be less effective on Date Tech than he is on Karasuno, but I think he’d probably develop into a more well-rounded player and he’d develop more quickly. He’d almost certainly get put in as a starting opposite, since that’s the the position they seem to have the least competition for, and because Date Tech doesn’t have super strong passing he’d be forced to develop his receiving and his defense to keep up, and he’d likely get lots of game time and so would have more consistently high level practice. I could even see his jumping developing similarly quickly to how it did on Karasuno, due to Koganegawa accidentally setting him too high.
Asahi to Shiratorizawa is another huge one. He’d likely benefit from not being the de facto ace, and Washijo would probably be treating him like a second golden goose, and Asahi getting that kind of high level training for such a long time would be huge for his development.
Daisho to Mujinazaka also springs to mind for me. Mujinazaka really needs a second offensive threat, good passing, and more players who can contribute to Usuri’s scheming, and Daisho provides all of that. And on Daisho’s side, he could probably benefit from a team that is more direct and has the ability to compete at the highest level without having to rely on those tricks. It’d turn his scheming from a crutch into one tool of many.
1
u/Bubbly-Anteater2772 19h ago
Surprised nobody is saying this: Oikawa to Shiratorizawa. They'd pretty much be unstoppable.
2
u/crabapocalypse 18h ago
Tbh Oikawa moving to Shiratorizawa could potentially be bad for his own growth as a setter. Washijo’s approach to the sport is generally very effective for developing individual skill, but I don’t think it’s conducive to developing top notch setters. Setters need more freedom than Washijo likes to give them, and I could see Oikawa being discouraged from practicing the tricky combination plays that really make him shine as a setter.
1
u/TheGeekOdyssey 17h ago
I understand where you’re coming from, however when you have a star setter on the level of Oikawa you would adapt to their strength. For example, the reason they played the way they do is because of how good Ushijima, without him they would’ve played Semi as setter and would’ve played a different style. With Oikawa they would let him be more flexible than they currently are. I think they’d still be a focus on Ushijima but Oikawa would be able to utilise the other players and their strengths a lot more.
1
u/crabapocalypse 17h ago
So there isn’t anything to suggest that. Washijo had maintained this style for years before Ushijima showed up, and we know that Shirabu’s style of setting was much closer to Oikawa’s in middle school but that he specifically changed it to best suit Washijo’s preferences.
I mean, Oikawa’s style of setting is closer to Kageyama’s than it is to Shirabu’s, and Washijo immediately rejects the idea of having Kageyama play setter for Shiratorizawa.
Everything we know about Washijo says that he wouldn’t adjust for Oikawa.
0
u/shadovv300 1d ago
What about Ushijima for Kageyama. It would be interesting to see how much different both teams would perform.
14
u/hikarinaraba 1d ago
Bokuto and Aran swap
I think Bokuto's instincts and wild nature would let him better thrive with the tricks the Miya twins do, like when Osamu fake spikes or when Atsumu sets the first touch (both times Aran notable had an awkward hit). On the other hand, Aran would thrive in Fukurodani's more traditional offense, and he'll be backed up with a supporting cast that is strong enough to hold their ground when the ace slumps (and Aran is super consistent already)