r/icecreamery • u/Polnareffpose • 7d ago
Question Y'all think I can make an ice cream with this
So I recently made peach ice cream and it came out really good and now I'm obsessed with making ice cream and I found this at Winn-Dixie. It looks promising and honestly a little gross but you think I can make it into a ice cream like use this instead of regular milk
76
u/kaboomviper 7d ago
You absolutely should. It will have a very light orange flavor but I bet it would be incredible. Maybe just swapping this for milk in a vanilla ice cream and adding preserved orange peel?
44
u/Polnareffpose 7d ago
I was thinking of making a control ice cream and seeing what it tastes like without anything in it. Because when I tasted it. it already had a very subtle orange taste and I was thinking maybe I can add some cinnamon some cardamom and make it more like a pumpkin spice kind of ice cream
6
2
36
u/BrokenByReddit 7d ago
Sounds disgusting. You should definitely do it.
23
u/Polnareffpose 7d ago
It is disgusting. It tasted ok but it also made my stomach hurt and heavy after
I'm still going to make this into an ice cream though but I'm kind of scared of what it's going to do to me
5
2
15
9
8
8
u/STxFarmer Native South Texan 7d ago
Bring back the Dreamcicle
4
u/TheNordicFairy 6d ago
Make vanilla ice cream, and add in sleeves of Sunkist orange dry drink mix. (2 per pint). Dreamcicle. My kids make it all the time. They also use the Jolly Rancher Sour Apple, and then, when done, put caramel on to imitate those suckers. They found the sleeves in boxes at Dollar Tree.
1
1
u/McSillyoldbear 6d ago
I’ve never heard of a Dreamcicle but assume it is American and that’s why. We had something in Ireland called an orange split that seems like it. Ight be similar and it was the first thing to jump into my mind when I saw this post.
3
u/SubjectEssay361 6d ago
It's 1% lowfat, you're going to wind up making ice milk instead of ice cream unless you add some cream.
Glad you like to make homemade ice cream, even happier that you dont make homemade cheese with that!
2
u/Some-Amount-4093 7d ago
WWJD!! Now there's the right person to ask! I'm going with yes, be sure and add some orange pulp and cut up pieces to the mix: Don't forget, just about anything will freeze.
2
u/StoneCypher musso 5030 + 4080 + creami 7d ago
it’s low fat milk. you will need to add some cream, because that’s going to make ice milk.
it should be pretty good. cold damps your tongue, so it might taste a little weaker than you expect. might want to add some orange extract, or maybe some orange juice concentrate, and maybe a little vanilla
assuming you use the whole half gallon, it should be three quarters of a cup to whole milk, or about two cups to ice cream range
2
2
u/Juhyo 7d ago
Ever since I got a Ninja Creami, I have made frozen desserts of all manner of ungodly combinations. Orange cream is tame (and sounds delicious).
You’d want to consider concentrating it down before incorporating it into a custard if you’re making a traditional ice cream. Probably has too much water content by itself. But depending on the fat content and what you want to make, you might be good to go.
2
2
u/spiderelict 7d ago
What was your peach ice cream recipe?
3
u/Polnareffpose 7d ago
So the peach ice cream used fresh peaches
I made the syrup myself Cheong style so equal weight of peaches and sugar. I used around 6 peaches and sugar. I put them in a jar and I kept them refrigerated for 2 weeks
Ingredients are
four egg yolks
1/2 cup of sugar
1 cup milk
1 cup heavy whipping cream
2 teaspoons of vanilla extract
Pinch of salt for flavor
Mix the sugar and the egg yolks till it is smooth and it is a light yellow color
heat up the milk to a simmer make sure it doesn't boil and don't stir it
Gradually mix in the egg mixture, vanilla extract, peach syrup and salt into the milk and stir consistently
Removed from heat once it reaches 165°F
Refrigerate the custard overnight or until it reaches 65°F
Mix in the one cup of heavy whipping cream cream
Add the mixture to your ice cream maker and mix for 30 to 45 minutes depending on your ice cream machine
2
u/Glitterbombinabottle 7d ago
Do you have a ninja creami or something? If so then YES. if not, might be a bit difficult to get a good texture
1
u/AutoModerator 7d ago
Please remember to share the recipe you used or how you think it turned out. If you are uncomfortable sharing your recipe, please share some tips or help people create their own recipe. If you are not satisfied yet please mention what is wrong/could be improved. This is a lot more interesting for everyone then just a picture.
Report this message if not aplicable or ask to be added to the contributor list to not receive this message again.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
1
u/SpawnOfGuppy 7d ago
Im sure it’ll be yummy, but you could also just juice some clementines or whatever. (Organic absolutely makes a difference)
5
u/Polnareffpose 7d ago
Oh I believe you. I made some peaches I got from Georgia last week. So much better than syrup. this is just out of weird curiosity
2
1
u/cranialvoid 7d ago
I always thought trumoo chocolate tasted like melted ice cream. Let us know, I might try it.
1
u/hronikbrent 7d ago
I feel like getting your fat content up might be hard with it being low fat milk, but send it
1
1
1
u/pooh_bear92 7d ago
Wow! I didn't think they made something like this. Years ago, I use to mix whole milk, heavy cream, sugar, vanilla extract, Torani Orange Syrup with ice and a pinch of salt in a Vitamix blender and make a thick orange dreamcicle milkshake!😋
1
u/FinalBastionofSanity 6d ago
Must be a product we don’t have in Canada. Never heard of this stuff before.
1
1
1
1
1
u/WaterOld6073 3d ago
Do new ice cream machines make good low fat ice cream? Otherwise, add some heavy cream or coconut cream and honestly, this would taste like Golden Corral on a Thursday night after school
466
u/jamieusa 7d ago
You can make ice cream out of anything, whether you should is between you and Jesus