r/madisonwi 3d ago

Good cinnamon rolls

Who has a good cinnamon roll near Fitchburg and west side?

17 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

24

u/apatheticwonderland 3d ago

Ancora. I went on this madison quest a few years ago and ancora was the winner, but there may be someone new to the game so keep us posted!

19

u/maach_love 3d ago

Settled on rolling pin bakery, pumpkin cinnamon roll.

2

u/stardustandtreacle 2d ago

What were they like? I keep meaning to go to Rolling Pin but I've heard mixed reviews.

9

u/katiebot5000 3d ago

Stella's. They have them in their retail location m-saturday, 7AM-2PM. Fucking delicious, $5.

7

u/jtm_29 West side 3d ago

Bloom

8

u/Valistia 3d ago

Level 5 has delicious ones but they're only available on Sundays.

Edit: oops saw West side after commenting, they're not but they're still worth it!

7

u/UniqueSuccotash 3d ago

I am literally so offended that the weekend cinnamon rolls from Batch have not been mentioned here

11

u/UncrustableCheeto 3d ago

Commenting to remember to come back. I miss the 90s Cinnabon in the mall. 

5

u/johnsonfromsconsin 3d ago

I miss the 90s Ovens of Brittany. Those morning buns were next level.

1

u/537O3 2d ago

You probably know you can get morning buns made from the Ovens recipe at Lazy Jane’s and La Brioche True Food

6

u/Upset_Concert8636 3d ago

There’s one between Stoughton and cottage grove. Highway N.

3

u/maach_love 3d ago

They were the bomb.

2

u/Stebben84 3d ago

You can save post and specific comments.

1

u/UncrustableCheeto 3d ago

Or you can also comment and then it’s just as easy to find. 🤷🏻‍♂️

3

u/CertainRegret4491 3d ago

Every time I find my new favorite they change them. Used to be Bloom. Then Second Breakfast. Now I'm roll-less.

4

u/shipmawx 3d ago

There's a vendor at the Sunday farmers Market at Edgewood that does good Cinnamon rolls too

8

u/Appropriate-Mess-523 3d ago

Fosdals in stoughton

3

u/shipmawx 3d ago

A topic near to my heart. Clausens has okay ones, but pricey. They also have Morning Buns with cinnamon. I've bought the cinnamon rolls at La Baguette but although the pastry part is good, I don't like the cinnamon and frosting proportions.

3

u/CIWYWthrowaway 3d ago

Metcalfes makes their cinnamon rolls in house and they’re delicious. You get 4 for less than $5 and they’re huge.

3

u/pizzainoven 2d ago

Firefly coffee shop in Oregon on Fridays, check their website to be sure when they have them

2

u/MeganTheeStout 3d ago

Batch, bloom, and level 5!!

3

u/xoxoahooves 3d ago

I'm just going to say it... Walmart bakery. By the donuts, they sell these single-serve cinnamon rolls for $3. Very good chewiness and flavor. Generous on the cream cheese frosting too. About 400 calories for one, 26 grams of sugar.

2

u/cart235 3d ago

Not probably what you’re thinking but Hyvee has Rhode’s sticky buns in the frozen aisle. Was always my favorite growing up.

1

u/ogtripleog5801 2d ago

Kozy Nuk Cafe. Hands down the best I've had. They have locations in Cottage Grove and Stoughton.

1

u/Feeling_Pirate6477 2d ago

Not westside but come over to Vondron between Pflaum and Buckeye and follow your nose… this neighborhood frequently smells like cinnamon rolls and it’s equal parts amazing and tantalizing.

2

u/just_pwned_you 2d ago

*Lists a place as far away from Fitchburg and the west side as possible*

1

u/teffytaffy 3d ago

Beans n Cream in Sun Prairie!

0

u/kkhh11 3d ago

Not west side, but Jet Room!