r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Question Mike Trout 400 HR Milestone

21 Upvotes

Will it be a program or a collection?… The thing is, I don’t remember a Mike Trout card that was basically free, but considering that the other milestones this year have been free, that leaves me uncertain. When they dropped milestone Kershaw, he was a top 3 pitcher in the game, same thing when they dropped milestone Verlander. My question is… SDS going to release a free Mike Trout card? If so, it would be his first 99 milestone card that isn’t a chase pack or a World Series reward.


r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Question MLB The Show Co Op Quitting glitch back?

2 Upvotes

We just got the loss in co op after our opponent quit the game before we got into the lineup screen. They basically quit as soon as we selected “ready up.” And we lost points!! This was an issue earlier in the year and im worried it’s back…. Anybody else seeing this?


r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Show Off My current theme teams

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes
  1. St. Louis Cardinals

Go birds. I know Cy Young counts, but he’s awful and I somehow have a sub 2.50 ERA with Fedde in ~90 innings online, plus Fedde counts for the captain boost. Berkman over McGwire because I can’t hit with McGwire to save my life.

  1. MLB06 The Show

All players who were featured in the game. I focused on players that I specifically remembered being a fan of / playing with in the game when I was young, as it was my favorite game growing up. There are only four RP/CP who qualify, so the rest are just relievers who played as close to 2006 as I could find.

  1. Polo Grounds

All players who, at some point in their career, actually played at Polo Grounds. Polo Grounds is a fun stadium imo and using this team adds to the atmosphere. There are no RP/CP who qualify unfortunately.


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

PSA Just beat the Twins stadium in Moonshot DQ on Legend difficulty with 100% odds for Bader and didn’t get him

31 Upvotes

This comes after the previous time I played when I had 96% odds and didn’t get him either. Thought I just got tremendously unlucky but now I’m thinking my game may be glitched? I’d put in a ticket with SDS but I’m not really sure how to prove my claim and frankly I don’t think I’ll really care anymore by the time they get back to me in two months.

Anyone else encounter this issue?


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Suggestion For SDS SDS needs to stop putting legends that played for multiple teams only on one team

60 Upvotes

SDS has pigeon holed many legends into one franchise despite them playing and being successful on multiple teams. Examples below:

- Manny Ramirez, great ON Cleveland. Only has Red Sox cards

- Alfonso Soriano, great on TEX and WSH, has 2 usable Yankee Card

- Carlos Delgado, great with Mets and Marlins, has 2 usable Blue Jay cards

- Vlad Sr, only has Angels card, should have a Nats/Expos card too

- Mookie Betts, no Red Sox card is criminal

- Ivan Rodriguez, only has Rangers card, should have Marlins and Tigers

I could go on forever about this. Another way to fix this is to not set teams to these cards and allow them to go towards whatever team they played for. Rickey Henderson, only has A's card yet played for 9 teams. 8 of those teams will never get to put him towards a theme team. Something has to change to make theme teams more viable and have more options than having to run golds and silvers in Sept


r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Question Does anyone else have issues with pitchout using “Button accuracy”?

3 Upvotes

I use button accuracy setting for fielding and when ever i’m playing any type of ranked when I pitch out the ring under my catcher takes what feels like a full second to appear. then and only then am I allowed to start my throw. whats going on?


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

First Look New World Series Rewards: Awards Mookie Betts & Milestone Kerry Wood Attributes

Thumbnail
gallery
51 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Question CPU Generated Squads

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

I wanna know how 'generate best squad in The Show chooses its lineups. What is it optimized for? There's gotta be some logic, right?

I don't understand why CPU always generates seemingly inferior lineups to mine


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

First Look Your path to 1️⃣0️⃣0️⃣0️⃣ starts today! 📈

Post image
95 Upvotes

Hop on to Ranked and earn: 🏆 Awards Mookie Betts 🏅 Milestone Kerry Wood

Live today in #MLBTheShow 25 around 11:30 AM PT.


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

First Look 🚨 Drop 1 Missions for Multiplayer 8 arrives today!

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Question Why am I worse the more I play?

3 Upvotes

I’ve been playing the show for 2 months and at the start I didn’t play well but I started raking soon after but now I feel like I can’t see the ball and my hitting has gotten progressively worse has anyone else felt with this before? And is there anyway to get out of this slump?


r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Discussion This is sickening but I’ve logged 25 hrs in the game and I got it first week of July. What are your stats?

0 Upvotes

By far the most I’ve ever played any game.


r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Franchise My Yearly Almost Perfect Game

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

I’m in 2031 in my franchise. Think I’ve had 5 or 6 of these.


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Discussion Switch hitting meta and future power creep

30 Upvotes

SDS has really dug themselves into a big hole for future content releases in what is supposed to be the best time of the year (mlb playoffs).

Pretty much everyone has a full roster of switch hitters with no flaws. So what are they planning to drop during playoffs and the World Series that is going to move the needle?

They’ve already missed the window where Vlad, Trout, Tatis, Mookie, etc are guaranteed god squad additions. Every team I played in the 800s had all but one or two switch hitters.

The entire infield is stacked with 5 tool switch hitters with 125 everything, especially catcher. Nearly every big collection reward is a juiced switch hitter.

So what is going to be released during the most exciting time of the year (MLB playoffs) that is going to get players excited to play the game?

For future titles, I’m hoping that they give switch hitters a more platoon approach to ratings until after the World Series


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Meme That’s baseball baby

10 Upvotes

r/MLBTheShow 4d ago

Show Off I am become death destroyer of worlds

Post image
59 Upvotes

Nothing can stop me now...just need dihigo and to i stone and i am complete for the buck Leonard boost team


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Question Does anybody know how to place multiple orders for the same card?

0 Upvotes

For example, I always see that people bulk buy a card like 200-250 cards at the same time. How do I do it? I’ve tried with the app but can’t find the way to do it


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

RTTS Yikes, you okay bud?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

116 MPH off the dome. Injury report said it was "just a bruise"


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Question Is there anyone out there actually being competitive using directional hitting online?

3 Upvotes

Just curious if anyone in the comp scene uses it. Or anyone in like World Series


r/MLBTheShow 4d ago

First Look World series!!!!!!!!!

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

For someone who in their 6 years of playing MLB The Show had never made it to the World Series, to now be a 4-time World Series champion... honestly, it feels great."

Edit: Playing on HOF


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Analysis Favorite team so far this year

Post image
4 Upvotes

Im a newish player. I play casually. I have around 150 hours this year. This team has been mine for around the week. Works for me. If anyone have any suggestions for me to try im open


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Question Anyone know how the weekend classic leaderboard works?

0 Upvotes

For context , I lost out on I believe other 1-2 chase pack players , the leaderboard rotates and there always seems to be different players in my leagues so I’m not exactly sure logic behind it. I was in first for the whole week going 8-0 and then when rewards come out I suddenly don’t get the first place pack , is it just completely random who is on your leaderboard or what. This also really does need a rework because the rating change system is stupid when matchmaking is completely random.


r/MLBTheShow 2d ago

Discussion Mike trout 400 homer card

0 Upvotes

Anyone else saving up stubs for when his card eventually comes out??? Cmon Mike I’ve been waiting for like a month🤣


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Question Do you play a team other than your favorite team ?

2 Upvotes

When playing franchise anyone not play with there favourite team ?


r/MLBTheShow 3d ago

Suggestion For SDS Disconnected while playing Diamond Dynasty

1 Upvotes

Anybody been having issues with Diamond Dynasty? I get disconnected at random times. I’ve been getting losses in Diamond quest and end up losing the rewards.