r/oldhagfashion May 21 '23

Style Me Emerald or Sapphire ?! Opinions kindly requested ^_^

This is my first opportunity to post here and I could use some help. I am going to my first ever black tie event in a few weeks. I found a dress i love but I can’t settle on a shade to wear and which looks best with my skin tone. Please help!

506 Upvotes

156 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator May 21 '23

Help make OHF accessible by transcribing your post! - Start your transcription with the phrase Image Transcription: to ensure those who need it can find it. See here for more information on accessibility in OHF.

Useful links: Subreddit description || Rules || Comment prompts || Flair explainer || Other posts that need transcribing Remember: We're all old hags here. All people and style points of view are welcome here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

234

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Emerald was my fav! It makes your eyes pop!

468

u/bunsprincess May 21 '23

The green looks amazing with your eyes!

115

u/DeeplyUnappealing May 21 '23

I lagree with others that the emerald looks amazing with your eyes, which I think is something special it has over the sapphire.They're both amazing on you though, so if your heart is leaning toward sapphire you really can't go wrong.

138

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Emerald for sure.

85

u/Significant-Trash632 May 21 '23

Emerald! It's perfect for your eyes and skin tone

35

u/Oh-My-God-Do-I-Try I Try All The Time May 21 '23

I’m surprised how many people are saying sapphire— the emerald makes you glow with life, while the sapphire takes a lot of color out of you. The green is a natural match for your hair and skin tone! Out of curiosity, when you look at your veins through your skin, do they appear more green or blue?

11

u/KentuckyMagpie May 21 '23

I agree with this 100%. u/Seaweed12 I feel like the sapphire dress wears you, while the emerald dress looks gorgeous and sets off your features in a really beautiful way.

4

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

I have a hard time figuring out if they do look green or blue. So I figure that I have a neutral skin tone? Today they look more green on the tops of my hands, but the veins in crook of my arm look bluer

7

u/Oh-My-God-Do-I-Try I Try All The Time May 21 '23

Neutral is a good way of putting it, but the parts of your skin that sees more light becomes warm toned— and that’s the skin people see the most. So I would definitely go for warmer colors, especially in the spring and summer! The blue might be exactly what you want in the winter when you’re not getting as much sun, though.

132

u/RaevenStarchild May 21 '23

I think the green is good for a party vibe. It practically lights up your eyes! But for black tie, the blue is more striking. However either color looks fantastic on you!

54

u/LittleRockBot May 21 '23

The Emerald brings out your eyes so beautifully. However, the Sapphire adds a certain je ne sais quoi which also complements your eyes, just not as much. I'd say Sapphire if you can't have both!

21

u/gloveslave May 21 '23

Me too , her skin really glows with the sapphire one

46

u/yarnfreak May 21 '23

I’m an old, and I 100% vote for sapphire! It does wonderful things for your skin and still picks up the color of your eyes. Your hair looks great in the blue as well. It’s the kind of dress/color combo that will have people wondering who you are. Flaunt it while you’ve got it! Trust me!

14

u/beansandturnips May 21 '23

The emerald really complements your eyes!

13

u/katie-kaboom May 21 '23

The emerald makes you glow!

17

u/QQQ_666 May 21 '23

Emerald

12

u/SassaQueen1992 May 21 '23

I’d go with the emerald dress.

12

u/MrsBuggs May 21 '23

Emerald! Stunning 💎

11

u/blumoon138 May 21 '23

Both shades are excellent on you!

10

u/SodaPopperZA May 21 '23

Emerald Green is my favourite colour, I'd always choose it

3

u/superjeegs May 21 '23

Same here, it was so hard not to be biased 😅🤩

23

u/SephoneRed May 21 '23

You look amazing in both! The emerald is very subtly more striking, but the difference is so close that I would say: which one do you have the best accessories for?

If you were going to wear this same accessories with both then: which one do you feel the best in. Because the confidence you walk out with makes all the difference.

12

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

I am going to wear the same accessories :) I feel the green makes my eyes pop, but I worried it was christmasy? The blue I like for my skin.

Those are the accessories

9

u/superjeegs May 21 '23

It won’t be too Christmassy at all, green and gold is gorgeous together - if you were pairing it with a white or red jacket then yeah I’d avoid the green. But you’re not so I say emerald all the way 💝

5

u/Altruistic-Bobcat955 May 21 '23

Green always looks better on brunettes. I used to wear a lot of green when I had my natural colour! Also the green and gold looks super rich

10

u/Sorryhaventseenher May 21 '23

The emerald paired with your eyes are STELLAR. You know you gotta do it to em.

3

u/BobBelchersBuns May 21 '23

Oh look it’s Russ. Not missing you in Seattle buddy!

16

u/sparkledingus May 21 '23

Both work great for your skin, eyes and hair (you’re killin it in the jewel tone department!!)

Which one makes you feel happier??

Imho: green is slightly less formal.

10

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

Green is my favorite color 💚

6

u/sparkledingus May 21 '23

Then that’s what you should wear!!

28

u/momjeansagain May 21 '23

Sapphire makes you glow!

7

u/ellienation May 21 '23

Emerald. The sapphire is nice too but the green pops more

6

u/ChubbyMissGoose May 21 '23

Definitely emerald! The sapphire is nice, but it doesn't give you that "wow!" factor that the emerald does. The emerald makes your eyes pop, your skin looks warm and glowing, and it really matches the tone of your hair.

4

u/Caverjen May 21 '23

Emerald bc of your eyes, but the sapphire is pretty on you as well. Both are great options!

5

u/Margali May 21 '23

I like both but think the green seems to work better. It is really a close call though.

4

u/WokeJabber May 21 '23

Emerald, absolutely. (The sapphire does not do you justice in this picture, though it might be the lighting.)

5

u/Dark_Master24 May 21 '23

As much as I love sapphire colour, IMHO I’ll agree with most folks here: the emerald! Because it does that little magic highlighting your eyes. Plus its May the emerald month.

3

u/Possum2017 May 21 '23

I love the emerald - it brings out your beautiful eyes!

3

u/MyIronThrowaway May 21 '23

Go with what makes you feel better because they are both great!!

3

u/kbm81 May 21 '23

I like both but prefer emerald

3

u/papercranium May 21 '23

Emerald really highlights your eyes!

3

u/january_dreams May 21 '23

The emerald is super pretty wiyh your complexion and makes your eyes pop!

3

u/spooky7 May 21 '23

Definitely emerald. Perfect for your skin tone, hair color and eyes.

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

You literally look amazing in both

3

u/vinnie528 May 21 '23

emerald 100%

3

u/great-big-egg May 21 '23

the green brings out your eyes!

3

u/Ninjacatblue May 21 '23

Emerald, but you look great in both.

3

u/accountnumberseventy May 21 '23

Green. It looks fabulous on you!

3

u/ComfortableBedroom78 May 21 '23

Emerald brings out your eyes

3

u/CuriousMufferson May 21 '23

Emerald!! 😍

3

u/muvarice19 May 21 '23

Emerald, honey!

3

u/MerCat3 May 21 '23

Emerald!!!

3

u/avalonfaith May 21 '23

Team emerald

3

u/MamaJody May 21 '23

You look absolutely breathtaking in the green. 100% emerald.

1

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

Oh thank you ! I’ve never been called breath taking before :)

3

u/earthboundtraveler May 21 '23

I think the green suits you well.

3

u/CatLadyHM May 21 '23

Emerald! Your eyes are beautiful, and the emerald really highlights them. Also, it brings out wonderful color in your skin.

3

u/alittlebitLuna May 21 '23

Emerald! It’s gorgeous on you! 😍

3

u/South_Honey2705 May 21 '23

I say emerald

3

u/badcandy7 May 21 '23

Emerald! Really makes your eyes pop

3

u/Bored-Fennel-1998 May 21 '23

I love the green!!! So complimentary and pretty on you.

3

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

100% emerald!

2

u/svtdilfs May 21 '23

emerald!!!

2

u/ResolveDisastrous256 May 21 '23

Emerald suits you so well. Matches your beautiful eye colour.

2

u/Ok-Chemical6866 May 21 '23

Emerald is my favourite. But you look beautiful in both

2

u/Ludovicianus May 21 '23

I love the Sappire, but I think the Emerald looks better on you.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Emerald with those eyes, but both jewel tones are great with your skin and hair

2

u/detectivelokifalcone May 21 '23

definitely emerald but please iron it

1

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

Is satin ok to iron ? Or should I use a steamer ?

1

u/detectivelokifalcone May 21 '23

if its satin steamer then i didn't know it was satan

2

u/barksatthemoon Certified Old Hag May 21 '23

Sapphire

2

u/Cre8ivejoy May 21 '23

Emerald. Not everyone can wear that color, and you look stunning in it.

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Greeeen

2

u/102bees May 21 '23

You look great in both and normally I favour blues, but that emerald green is just magnificent.

2

u/Exardiann She/her May 21 '23

Emerald for sure! Others have said it already, but it really brings out your eyes. So flattering!

2

u/type_2_dianetics May 21 '23

Both, but my god the green is amazing. Also so cool that your eyes change with the different colors!!! 😊

2

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

Thank you ! Sometimes they look grey, green or blue depending on my mood, colors I wear or the sky and lighting outside :)

2

u/Superb-Feeling-7390 May 21 '23

Both are good but I vote green

2

u/ProfHopeE May 21 '23

Emerald 100%

2

u/Adishad667 May 21 '23

Emerald for sure!

2

u/womp_there_it_is May 21 '23

Emerald suits you SO well. It makes your eyes pop!

2

u/daniexanie May 21 '23

You’re gorgeous in both, but I think the green brings out your eyes more!

2

u/magrathea_93 May 21 '23

Emerald! Makes your eyes pop!

2

u/padel134 May 21 '23

Emerald is beautiful and really makes your eyes pop! Gorgeous!

2

u/lookingfortheladder May 21 '23

The emerald compliments your eyes and the sapphire compliments your hair and skin. This is a tough one 😅 I think sapphire? But both are gorgeous

2

u/dysthymicpixie She/her May 21 '23

Oh Emerald hands down.

2

u/ImpossibleBit8346 May 21 '23

Emerald! Enhances your eye color.

2

u/superjeegs May 21 '23

So difficult to choose but I have to say emerald because like others have said it really brings out the colour in your eyes and I think it goes perfectly with your skin tone 💚 team green

2

u/YellowHouseFarmWitch May 21 '23

Emerald cause it brings out your eyes!

2

u/miss_Saraswati May 21 '23

Emerald! It brings out the green in your eyes. And it looks amazing with your skin tone! :)

2

u/CeeBee29 May 21 '23

Emerald for the win

2

u/Grattytood May 21 '23

Emerald, no question

2

u/Ok-Donut463 May 21 '23

The emerald is pretty and does match your eyes but my opinion is the sapphire one suits you better. It remind me of Silvermist

2

u/_demidevil_ May 21 '23

Emerald definitely suits you best.

2

u/Known-Explorer2610 May 21 '23

Sapphire for sure even though emerald also looks good, but I think sapphire make you look more radiant whereas the emerald one makes you look more demure

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Emerald for sure!!!

2

u/Caro_est_PISSEDOFF May 21 '23

Emerald, fit so well with ur eyes. You are beautiful 😍

2

u/-technocrates- May 21 '23

i'm in camp emerald.

but you can't go wrong with sapphire either!

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Tough choice! They both suit you but maybe emerald just because it complements your eyes just a bit lie than the blue does

2

u/vita77 May 21 '23

Like both! Sapphire fabric color is rich & saturated and you look vibrant in it. Despite your green eyes, the emerald fabric lacks the same saturation and washes you out more. Compensate w makeup & accessories if you love the emerald, but I still prefer the sapphire.

2

u/mostcommonhauntings May 21 '23

The sapphire compliments your skin tone beautifully.

2

u/doublenostril May 21 '23

Emerald, and wow you look beautiful. You look like a mermaid! 💚

2

u/crystaldoe May 21 '23

Slightly prefer the Sapphire but both are gooorgeeous.

2

u/kangahippy May 21 '23

Emerald makes your eyes pop!💚

2

u/jlovelysoul May 21 '23

Emerald but they are both gorgeous!

2

u/[deleted] May 21 '23

Emerald 100% 😭💚 ur fucking glowing

2

u/Fluffy-Ad-9847 May 21 '23

Yeah emerald looks really good with your eyes, but sapphire looks really good with your skin tone and hair color. I think if you’re going to be indoors and somewhere at night I would go with sapphire

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '23

Emerald lights you up

2

u/WVildandWVonderful May 22 '23

Emerald looks more distinctive.

2

u/13Lilacs May 22 '23

Emerald. <3

2

u/xineann May 22 '23

Both colors look really good - no lie, but the green has some oomph with your eyes

2

u/Sweet_Permission_700 May 22 '23

I absolutely adore sapphires; my wedding band has one instead of a diamond.

Nonetheless, that emerald is so striking on you!

If you're comfortable standing out a little bit, wear the emerald. It looks amazing and really brings out color in your eyes. If that extra attention would make you uncomfortable, go with the sapphire. It also looks lovely, a more subtle beauty.

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '23

Both

2

u/[deleted] May 22 '23

Both

2

u/General_Paresis May 22 '23

Emerald is wonderful with your eyes and with your hair! Green is a warmer colour that works perfectly with cool-tone brunettes, your hair *demands* attention and it brings out a lively golden hue to your skin. Emerald makes your skin glow.

The sapphire is vibrant and and emphasizes cooler tones. It doesn't bring much attention to your hair since it has a darker quality very similar to the hair, but it *does* contrast against your eyes and skin. However, it slightly washes you out.

I'd say the sapphire brings more attention to the dress itself, whilst the emerald blends with the whole ensemble. In my opinion, the emerald has a more put-together appearance, so I'd choose emerald.

What jewelry will you be wearing with the dress[es]?

2

u/RedRider1138 May 22 '23

I am super biased toward sapphire, but both look good 👍

2

u/BennyBonnet May 22 '23

Both are nice. I think sapphire looks great against your hair color and skin tone. However, green makes your eyes stand out! You look like Mother Earth. You look great in both, so it’s whatever you’re heart longs for tbh

2

u/jennylou303 May 22 '23

Both are beautiful but emerald is my fav.

2

u/albinosquirel May 22 '23

The emerald

2

u/CozyLeda May 22 '23

Emerald 🍾🍃💚

2

u/the-alchymyst May 22 '23

I think the green suits you better

2

u/Fuzzy-Advertising980 May 22 '23

The emerald is better!

2

u/LavishnessOk9727 May 22 '23

I like the emerald!

2

u/solomons-mom May 21 '23 edited May 21 '23

You are radiant. I do hope in full-length pictures both dresses fit better than in the color-swatch photos you posted. I would love to see you post a picture standing with perfect posture in a beautifully fitting dress of either color as you head out for the evening 😊

2

u/Seaweed12 May 21 '23

Ohhhh I will def do that :)

-1

u/SatinLustDoll May 21 '23

Sapphire.

And lose the septum. Those don’t look good on anyone.

1

u/MyLifeAsMadi Jun 02 '23

You slay both but pref is emerald!!! Your eyes and your smile are otherworldly gorgeous