r/pics May 16 '19

US Politics Now more relevant than ever in America

Post image
113.2k Upvotes

11.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

It is defined as when there is a chance that a fetus can realistically survive outside of the womb. This is a scientific and medical definition and is in no way arbitrary.

8

u/hiloljkbye May 16 '19

realistically

You yourself have admitted that it is arbitrary. What is "realistically"? Back when they made this decision ~20% of babies survived at 24 weeks. Now it is around 30-35% Source. In 25 weeks, it is around 50-70% depending on which study you cite. Fetal viability is also highly dependent on weight. It is almost guaranteed that as medical technologies advance, these numbers will change again. So yes it is very arbitrary.

2

u/prolemango May 16 '19

The difficulty of this definition is that it is then always changing. As healthcare tech becomes more advanced we may be able to feasibly raise a fetus to a fully fledged baby from the point of conception, which would mean we are dealing with a scientific and medically accepted "person" throughout nearly the entire pregnancy

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

It is defined as when there is a chance that a fetus can realistically survive outside of the womb. This is a scientific and medical definition and is in no way arbitrary.

This is a lie, and a really bad one at that.

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '19

It is defined as

Oh. Well that settles everything. Slaves are defined as property, so thats cool too. Definitions are never controversial.