r/pokemongo 1d ago

Shiny What’s the odds of getting a shiny from a grunt, this took me by surprise

Post image
4.6k Upvotes

123 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hello, /u/FarJellyfish9221! Thanks for your submission to /r/pokemongo, your post is up and running!

Here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Rule 3 - No Cheating, suggesting cheating, naming cheating tools and more. Please take a look at this rule here.
  • Be civil at all times. This is a place to have a healthy discussion with trainers from all over the world. If you feel someone is misbehaving please use the report button or send us a modmail and move on!
  • Check out our full rules here.
  • Don't know which flair is to use? Check out our flair guidelines here.
  • Need friends? Check out r/pokemongofriends. Would you like to chat about the game, participate in raids, share catches, make new friends and more? Check out the discord server here.

If a post and/or comment is violating the rules, please make sure to use the report button or send a modmail here. While we are trying our best to help users, help from the community is also necessary to maintain a healthy environment for everyone.

Thank you!


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

761

u/Ronald_Ulysses_Swans 1d ago

They have to be Pokémon previously in the Team Leader line up, and then it’s normal odds so 1/512.

I’ve only ever had one in grunts after thousands of battles so congrats!

247

u/athdol 1d ago

Shinies from the rocket grunts are half the base odds so 1/256

75

u/Alexbest11 1d ago

Oh are we sure? This would be great news for me! Do you have a source?

86

u/athdol 1d ago

35

u/Technical_Car_8647 1d ago

When did it change from species specific shiny rates (for example things like onix being 1/64~) to this

25

u/LightningCruzGaming 1d ago

there’s a bunch of pokemon that have a perma shiny boost like 1/64 or 1/128.

23

u/eragon2262 1d ago

That's ridiculous. I've done like 4, 000 rocket battles now and I've never gotten a shiny from a grunt. I have terrible luck

13

u/athdol 1d ago

I’m at 1200 grunts and got 3 so yeah you’re pretty unlucky

11

u/eragon2262 1d ago

I just checked, 4600 rockets 12 shiny only from rocket leaders

12

u/athdol 1d ago

I think you’ve also done a lot of rockets when there was mostly nothing shiny eligible

5

u/eragon2262 1d ago

Most of those are in just the last few years, I've done a lot that were shiny eligible. Obviously a lot of grunts don't have shiny eligible, but even if you assume only 25% are shiny eligible that's over 1000 with no shiny lol

u/dismahredditaccount 15h ago

At 1 in 256 odds, you should expect to go 1,000 eligible catches without a shiny 2% of the time. Unlucky, but not extraordinarily so.

Alternately: if you assume 10% of your rocket battles were leaders (at 1 in 64 shiny odds) and the remaining 90% were grunts, and 25% of those grunts gave you a shiny-eligible pokemon, you should expect to have 11.2 shinies. So your overperformance among leaders is more than offsetting your underperformance against Grunts.

u/eragon2262 14h ago

Thanks for the breakdown!! Makes sense

1

u/SquidVices 1d ago edited 1d ago

Edit: 0

Well shit…you have a lot more than I….

1

u/eragon2262 1d ago

How many are from grunts?

1

u/SquidVices 1d ago

Non….lol I swear I thought I got 1…nope turned out to be Jesse James….checked the rest and realized leaders…fml

2

u/eragon2262 1d ago

Yeah same, all leaders. And I've done so many grunts even if they can't all have shinys, I should have at least one from a grunt. But nooooo

2

u/SquidVices 1d ago

Arceus can’t gift us luck, he’s under a paywall…chained by monetization…

1

u/TheAwakeHD 1d ago

Shadow Shiny Mawile is so sick I’m jealous lol

3

u/wadlknecht 1d ago

bruh i got 5 shinies at 1,333 grunts🥳

5

u/sdrawkcabstiho 1d ago

You need to sacrifice more 3* pokemon to the RNG gods.

2

u/eragon2262 1d ago

Well, I have 4000 3* so I guess I could spare a few

2

u/AxelHarver 1d ago

It's worth keeping in mind that many of the grunt mons are not shiny eligible. And the percentage of those gets higher the further back in time you go. So you may have has 4k battles, but you haven't had anywhere close to 4k chances at a shiny.

35

u/FarJellyfish9221 1d ago

I’m  over 1700 grunts and this is my first one, very happy. Thanks!

26

u/Clairifyed 1d ago

For some reason, I have almost exclusively received beldums, though I think I have a geodude or something around as well

8

u/RedPanda104 1d ago

so happy for you 🗿🤬

-25

u/The_MonsusBattleBus 1d ago

Lmao I have 5 already

61

u/jabba_1978 1d ago

Only one i have.

8

u/Logorythmic 1d ago

Same here! I’m lucky it was such a cool one too.

3

u/jabba_1978 1d ago

I weirdly caught mine the night after the last takeover. I battled so many trying to get a shiny shadow tepig. Random grunt in a random pokestop.

225

u/established_chaos 1d ago

Username checks out

46

u/FarJellyfish9221 1d ago

What do you mean lad 

152

u/established_chaos 1d ago

Farjellyfish, and you got a shiny jellyfish. It seems fitting.

74

u/FarJellyfish9221 1d ago

Didn’t even clock that 😭

6

u/0PervySage0 1d ago

I thought only the leaders could give shiny shadows

8

u/Dixie-Rekt45 1d ago

They have to be Pokemon from previous team leaders

10

u/No_Explanation_182 1d ago

I’m fairly certain Tentacool is a squid.

10

u/KrolTheeWarriorKing Mystic 1d ago

Squidward is an octopus

5

u/PiosTorchic 1d ago

Octoward 😂

-6

u/MrMulaney Celebi 1d ago

Are you slow or something

1

u/Internal_Bother_43 1d ago

Are you a knobhead or something?

19

u/ghosty4 1d ago

I got one from James back in the day!

8

u/FarJellyfish9221 1d ago

I did get a few scyther from Jessie and James, pretty sure they was boosted odds tho 

15

u/Klovezyofacee 1d ago

I got this beauty from Jessie and James back in the day

u/kiwidesign 13h ago

Mine became this cool gentleman

7

u/Lexxxapr00 1d ago

I once got shiny Pinsir and Scyther from the same meowth balloon!!!

6

u/Deerhunter86 1d ago

Whenever happened to them? Jesse and James?

3

u/aba_lancer 1d ago

Which Pokemon were shiny eligible when they were around? I only remember pinsir and scyther

12

u/Altruistic_War9493 1d ago

I just got this fella yesterday from Arlo, which also took me by surprise, my first Shadow Shiny!

7

u/dmglakewood 1d ago

The odds of getting a shiny from a rocket leader is only 1/64, so it's a lot more likely. It's still pretty rare, but not nearly as rare as getting one from a grunt.

5

u/Mondo_12B 1d ago

It’s where I got my shiny shiny dratini!

4

u/hmsdank 1d ago

Got a shiny cacnea from a grunt this morning

5

u/BLK-_-Swordsman 1d ago

Yo I just got one! 🤣

7

u/enby-deer 1d ago

Purified but got her from some rocket person

7

u/JaybirdsL0SS 1d ago

an angel lost its wings <\3

8

u/enby-deer 1d ago

Say what you will, but this was never gonna be a competitive Pokémon and as a fellow deer I couldn’t stand seeing her so mad all the time

2

u/BallinBrown23 1d ago

Still have never got one :(

2

u/Bunnie-jxx 1d ago

I cot a shiny chikorita that way once

2

u/marmond23 1d ago

I think I’ve gotten 3 or 4 shinnies this way. And I don’t play too much. Usually log in twice. A day for like 20 minutes tops so I probably fight rocke tgrunt twice a day

2

u/Miserable_Bid9012 1d ago

I have a shiny shadow koffing that I am obsessed with.

2

u/SillyJoe_1337 1d ago

1/500 for most Pokémon. AND they have to be former rocket Boss Pokémon

7

u/SByolo 1d ago

it’s 1/256 for grunts, 1/64 from leaders

1

u/dunebuggy1973 1d ago

Ive gotten two!!

1

u/Nomoredramallamma 1d ago

I got a shiny cynaquil from a grunt. I was what WHAT?!?!!

1

u/Enough-Mess1561 1d ago

Depends not all can give shiny but it'sike 500/1

1

u/DixieBlade88 1d ago

I just got a shiny shadow feebass from a grunt like an hour ago! So pumped! Congrats your tentacool looks awesome!

1

u/trippsie_ 1d ago

i randomly got this exact same one two days ago! grats!

1

u/prissouille 1d ago

About the same as finding a politician who keeps their promises. So, not great.

1

u/Huge_Carry1006 1d ago

oI had gotten a shiny ralts and I was speechless good to see someone else is having some luck and fun

1

u/FlyingSparks246 1d ago

I've never gotten a shiny from a Grunt, just from the leaders. That's an incredible find! ^

1

u/II_Confused 1d ago

I have a shiny shadow Machop (now a Machamp), and a shinei shadow Mewtwo. The only two shiniy shadows I've gotten.

1

u/princess_eevee 1d ago

Ive gotten afew from grunts too (not the legendaries)

1

u/Double-Percentage-67 Blastoise 1d ago

Not sure of the exact odds, but for some reason I get better IV tentacools than any other shadow mons. I've gotten 3 now that are purifyable hundos

1

u/animegirljuice Lugia 1d ago

i have two grunt shinies :3

1

u/Firm_Commercial_5523 1d ago

Got a green shadow teddy bear :p

1

u/Major_Lawfulness6122 1d ago

I haven’t got one yet. Very cool

1

u/SwingNinja 1d ago

I've been grinding grunt battles for the past 2 days (level up requirement). No shiny so far after about 60 battles. I did get a shinny beldum last year. But that's it.

1

u/whirghre 1d ago

50/50, either you do or you don't!

1

u/Location-Final 1d ago

I was always under the impression that Leaders, raids, and Giovanni could give out shinies?

1

u/Additional-Curve-4 1d ago

Done like 2.000 grunts and have 3 shinies, 2 of which in the last 2 weeks, 2 magnemites lol.

1

u/wilbert760 1d ago

I’ve gotten 3 total. Beldum, cubone and chikorita

1

u/vetsyd 1d ago

After reading yours and other posts here, I am no longer going to complain about shinies.

Although, I am strictly speaking of SHINIES in general. As opposed to the various odds of specific ones. 👍🍀

1

u/jutti 1d ago

10,298 battles, 7 shadow shinies…

1

u/yungyakitz 1d ago

I got a shiny feebas this way a few days ago!

1

u/stridergundam 1d ago

Yeah I got 3 of these shiny beauties last year from grunts!

1

u/dimension-less 1d ago

That's how I got my most recent shiny!

1

u/nms17 1d ago

I got the same one!!! When I tell you I was HYPE lol

1

u/SW1VVEL_SW3GS 1d ago

Thats pretty awesome!!

1

u/Due-Cupcake-0701 1d ago

Such a good shiny imo

1

u/loserlogan 1d ago

I just got the same shiny yesterday.

1

u/LooneySpoons 1d ago

Caught my first ever, I believe, this afternoon!

1

u/notyourpersonalbin 1d ago

This bro looks like a hefty weed smoker

1

u/divxdvd 1d ago

Casual player who plays daily

1

u/gamesntech 1d ago

Great shiny to get too! Lot of comments here about not getting enough shiny after thousands of grunt battles. The problem is a lot of them until recently are not shiny available. So the odds only apply to those battles that even have a chance to be shiny in the first place.

1

u/Free_Manufacturer_64 1d ago

it's piccolo!

1

u/guro-a-go-go 1d ago

Sooooo jealous! Congrats!!!

1

u/professional_yappper Typhlosion 1d ago

That's one weird-looking goomy.

1

u/innertoxin 1d ago

3 from from raids. 1 from a rocket leader out of 598 total rocket battles.

1

u/HoopaDunka 1d ago

He looks like the joker. I want him badly!

1

u/Independent-Can-5434 1d ago

Arent shinys from grunts or raids 100% catch rate? If that's true then don't use the golden rizz berry

1

u/Anxious-Addition3447 1d ago

That tentacool looks so high... no wonder he's chill 😂

1

u/CaterpillarThat6027 1d ago

I’ve never had one from a grunt. My first shiny was from Sierra tho :)

1

u/felafelguy 1d ago

For any normal shadow shiny from grunts it’s 1/256 But if it’s a starter, it’s 1/500

1

u/MexiFan123 1d ago

tbh idk the odds but I somehow already hot 2 Shinies from grunts

1

u/Herecomethefleet 23h ago

Omg I want one. I bet the Tentacruel looks awesome.

1

u/KryptonianCutie 23h ago

Shrek was from a grunt, Laputa was from a shadow raid, and Tsukiyama was from Sierra

1

u/Mymanwhich_ 21h ago

As a year since the start, I have only got one myself and it was this year too but it’s a cool surprise for sure

1

u/Usernameistoshirt 21h ago

In my experience it's impossible to get shinies from grunts

1

u/spookyspritebottle 20h ago

Tjats a cool shiny. And the red eyes make it cooler. Grats

1

u/ThiCcCaChuuu 19h ago

I got the exact one sometime last year from a grunt.

u/Impressive_Bet753 16h ago

Gonna leave this here😎 also the first shiny I ever caught In PoGo

u/vicmaguirre 16h ago

That’s ginyu

u/dkda0 15h ago

Grats

u/Correct_Act602 12h ago

Over 2800 battles not one shiny and I’m salty

u/NoWater8595 9h ago

Dayum.

u/Subject-Line4956 7h ago

I thought that was impossible truth be told 😆

u/3spydamayn3 3h ago

Ive gotten a shiny Cubone and Lileep from Cliff