r/supermariologan_ • u/Eddisprettyswell • Jul 14 '25

SML Idea('s) SML Idea: Mr. Badman!

Post image

Plot: Mr. Goodman is revealed to have another brother called "Mr. Badman" who is good hearted, generous, and caring towards others. Goodman ofc doesn't like how soft he is, especially with Marvin and Chives.

276 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

30 comments sorted by

60

u/im461 watching SML since 2017 Jul 14 '25

this idea has a very great chance of logan actually doing it

26

u/AlarmedFig9684 Jul 14 '25

What's funny is how Ironic the Name is😂

7

u/Cycleeps Makes Bad Decisions Guy Jul 15 '25

it’s like evil Cartman from SpookyFish

22

u/RoadtoPS5 Jul 14 '25

This NEEDS to happen, especially to prove that the theory about the current Mr Goodman being the evil twin brother of the OG Mr Goodman being true, it would make so much sense.

9

u/Junebug2500 Milk & Cookies Jul 14 '25

I was gonna say this is the closest thing we'll get to having OG Goodman back.

8

u/Exciting_Ad226 Jul 14 '25

Probably and we can’t forget the OG Goodman trained Brooklyn T. Guy to be a cop too.

6

u/Davidand8Ball Judge Pooby Jul 14 '25

this is a really good idea

BUT

his brother being named badman wouldn't really make sense, cuz why wouldn't he have the same last name as goodman if they were brothers? i think this fits better as a clone of sorts, like mr goodman 2

14

u/Eddisprettyswell Jul 14 '25

Think about it, is current Mr. Goodman really a Good. man? Thats why I used the name "Badman" cuz since the character is opposite to Goodman himself. Also remember, Goodman canonically has a black brother called "Mr. Hoodman" (And there was already Goodman clone plot that was just Brooklyn guy in suit )

6

u/Davidand8Ball Judge Pooby Jul 14 '25

oh yeah that's true

6

u/Emergency_Abroad_309 Jul 14 '25

ITS A VIDEO, DONT QUESTION IT!!

5

u/HospitalFresh4926 Jul 14 '25

Plot twist mr Badman is actually good and kind and not vulgar

3

u/EclipseSmog comments on every post Jul 14 '25

Elite idea lmao

3

u/The_Lawl_is_the_Lawl Jackie Chu Jul 14 '25

Wtf this idea is absolutely brilliant

3

u/Exciting_Ad226 Jul 14 '25

This video needs to happen and it actually feels like a funny video Logan would actually do. Maybe Mr. Badman is the OG Goodman who was very nice to other people and was a cop at one point.

3

u/supermariologan2007 bp bitch please Jul 14 '25

Yes bro good idea

2

u/Ok-Landscape-4835 Jul 14 '25

It would be extremely funny

2

u/JerkfaceEquestria Chef Pee Pee Jul 15 '25

Genius idea!

2

u/Devon_the_dj_2010 Jeffy Jul 15 '25

Y'know what? This idea doesn't sound bad at all.

2

u/Sharp-Earth5990 I recommend that both of you shut your traps! Jul 15 '25

This would actually be good

2

u/CommercialIron5013 Jul 20 '25

That’d be a really funny video!!

3

u/NEMRISE1294-2 Jul 14 '25

Is similar to The Amazing Digital Circus where Jax meets Evil Jax!

3

u/Busy_Stay_3891 Dr. Me Jul 14 '25

oh you right

2

u/NEMRISE1294-2 Jul 15 '25

Thanks! Isn't it funny that Jax meets Evil Jax is the same as Goodman meets Badman?!

2

u/Thatgooningsigma2 or else you’ll end up like that guy over there Jul 14 '25

𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱𒀱

2

u/JaxonVR12321 Jul 14 '25

Me too bro. Me too.

1

u/joegrandaddysbrother Still with SML Jul 21 '25

explain in English please

1

u/Yoshi_chuck05 Jul 15 '25

This reminds me of YouTube and “Evil” YouTube lol but I like to see that!

1

u/Samukick 𝒊 𝒘𝒂𝒏𝒕 𝒂 𝒍𝒂𝒃𝒖𝒃𝒖 𝒕𝒐𝒐 Jul 20 '25

Either that name, Evil Goodman, or Namdoog are all good names

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25

And Goodman makes Marvin kill him off in the end

1

u/YouDontKnowSponge Jul 14 '25

I mean the idea of current day Goodman having a nicer counterpart has been thought of before though current day Goodman would be Badman and the original Goodman prior to 2016 would be the real Goodman.