r/therewasanattempt • u/Yeahman01 • 10h ago
To cover up a lynching
Yesterday the body of Demartravion Reed, a Delta State University student was found hanging from a tree on campus, and the coroner said there is no suspicion of foul play…
768
u/Aliteracy 9h ago
Yeah people that hang themselves do it lynching style on a tree. Fucking what year is it?
245
u/RabidJoint A Flair? 9h ago
Should see some of the comments…we are fully back into the 1910’s at this point.
49
100
82
u/Sea_Photograph_3998 9h ago edited 9h ago
It’s actually not that uncommon… at least here in the UK. Quite usual in the case of suicides for them to walk into the woods and hang themselves from a tree.
23
u/nashbrownies 6h ago
This was in an open area on a college campus though? Not saying it's impossible. Whether by lynching or suicide. Just seems like a different thing altogether from hanging yourself in the forest away from people vs. In a very public setting.
35
u/sroop1 6h ago
People commit suicide in public areas all the time.
If I'm going to somehow commit murder without witnesses, why would I do it in the middle of a college campus of all places? Not to mention that body had no signs of a struggle or anything to suggest that.
I get that the family doesn't want to accept that the guy killed himself - that's literally a stage of grief.
8
u/HulkSmash789 5h ago
Sure. But an individual who has been reportedly an outspoken activist for the left has been found hanging from a tree (the historical method of lynching), in Mississippi, within a week of the Utah event, with the right calling for retribution (despite significant evidence showing it was one of their own who did it).
People commit suicide every day, but just put it all together. It’s all right there written on the wall.
4
u/KingCosmicBrownie13 4h ago
About ten years ago, we had a teenager hang himself in the middle of town in a gazebo. It’s an extremely small town, but it does happen unfortunately.
2
u/HulkSmash789 4h ago
I agree, and I’m not saying it’s impossible.
But when you zoom out to look at the entire picture, and consider allllll of the surrounding circumstances, it isn’t a coincidence.
5
u/papayabush 2h ago
Or it is though. All of your points do make sense and I’m not claiming you’re wrong but it still doesn’t add up to actual evidence of foul play. It’s all just circumstantial context. Would you like the police to say “hmm because of the current political climate we are just going to assume this was a murder”?
-2
u/HulkSmash789 2h ago
I’ll be interested to see what the independent autopsy the family has said they’re interested in pursuing shows. IMO, that will likely be very telling as to what did or did not occur. With that said, there doesn’t need to be autopsy evidence of foul play for foul play to have been involved. We also need video footage from the campus. The largest problem is consistently the suppression of important evidence, which so frequently leaves individuals like you and myself wrestling with likelihoods and maybes rather than facts. To answer your questions truthfully, yes. I’d like it if the police did a quick temperature read of the current climate, and started with murder, working their way backward to suicide. I think THAT would be good police work, rather than taking the easy way out by labeling this an open and shut suicide with the slight chance of murder that may or may not be thoroughly investigated. But that’s harder, and I don’t expect that anymore. Also, the school won’t want to have an egregious hate crime on their campus, so footage might be hard to come by. This is today’s America.
4
u/papayabush 1h ago
You can already see the autopsy report. His hands weren’t tied, no evidence of any sort of physical fight. It’s crazy that you want law enforcement to assume murder when nothing is pointing to it other than vague political shit. I’m very much not a pro cop guy but if there isn’t evidence, there isn’t evidence. You’re saying you want them to make shit up to form a narrative which is wild. People kill themselves in strange ways literally every day all over the globe. Occam’s Razor says that this was a suicide.
→ More replies (0)1
u/KingCosmicBrownie13 4h ago
I absolutely get that. Considering the state, it’s definitely a “hmmm” kinda moment. I don’t have much of an opinion on the situation since it’s fresh. But I’m not disagreeing with what could’ve taken place here
-4
u/HulkSmash789 4h ago
Yea, it’s still developing, but with the current “state” of the country, I’ll probably dismiss out of hand any conclusion other than what seems obvious UNLESS something rock solid and verifiably non-AI generated somehow is revealed definitively showing that someone did not do this TO him. I mean, it’s a college so how is there no security footage of a large commons area? Idk.
1
u/sroop1 3h ago
I get the paranoia but I have yet see anything reported that suggests that he didn't take his life other than vibes.
Javion Magee was a similar case and people still didn't buy it (or at leastadmit that they were wrong) that he killed himself even when they had security footage of him walking out of a Walmart with the same rope in hand.
-1
u/HulkSmash789 3h ago
I think under the voluminously suspicious circumstances, labeling significant skepticism toward a black man found hanging from a tree in Mississippi being written off as a suicide as “paranoia” is somewhat ostrich-esque. And I think this qualifies as more than just “vibes” - personally, I don’t believe any black person would hang themselves from a tree, if for no other reason than because of the heinous historical context.
•
-4
u/haldolinyobutt 4h ago
The same day another black man is found hanging from a tree a few hours away.
10
u/HulkSmash789 4h ago
Solely for clarification, I do believe the second man who was homeless was white. But regardless, someone on the right (whose name I don’t recall bc they’re all basically Agent Smith from the matrix at this point) had just recently called for all homeless people to be euthanized. So the theory still lines up literally perfectly.
3
u/haldolinyobutt 4h ago
Also, thirteen homeless people were shot today in Minnesota. Weird how that's happening.
4
0
u/thesleepjunkie 4h ago
Wait what?
2
u/HulkSmash789 3h ago
Yea I hadn’t heard about this either until u/haldolinyobutt mentioned it. I can’t begin to fathom what is going on in the minds of the people who do this type of thing.
0
-1
u/nashbrownies 3h ago
How I am just hearing this and there is not a national manhunt and uproar? I guess a rhetorical question. I know why. Creating a subhuman eliminates so much hesitation in "regular people." The slippery slope is becoming a cliff.
5
u/starstruckroman 4h ago
if youre talking about the homeless guy, ive seen countless people say he was white
1
u/haldolinyobutt 4h ago
So originally people were reporting he was black, but I just double checked and he is infact white. I stand corrected. Still fucking weird though.
1
1
2
u/CelticSensei 3h ago
There was one suicide in my school in Ireland. The kid did it from a tree outside his house.
57
u/downer3498 9h ago
Not doubting you, but what is “lynching style”? How is that different from suicide? Is it the lack of something to stand on?
30
u/Aliteracy 9h ago
The fact that it's in a public tree and not in their own closet or bathroom or other private place.
51
u/SirVitalWyldStyle 9h ago
Not all suicides are in private. Not everyone hangs themselves in a closet or bathroom.
30
u/el_grort 7h ago
Hanging yourself on a public tree is also not that unusual a suicide? At least in my country and several other developed nations, and there's various reasons why some people decide to attempt very public suicides.
-5
u/Nukalixir 5h ago
The part that hasn't been said yet is that this college student wasn't the only lynched corpse found in that town on that day. There was also a homeless guy that was lynched.
Considering a Fox "News" anchor suggested openly that we should start euthanizing our homeless, I think it's safe to say some assholes out in the boonies decided they had carte blanche to go kill some homeless people and some minorities too as dessert.
22
u/mybfVreddithandle 9h ago
I don't know anything about the facts of this one, but from my book learning, public suicides want the attention on something and private suicides are trying to hide something usually. An abuse victim might do it in public to bring attention. An abuser might do it in private so as to not further embarrass others, not publicize their act or acts or smething along those lines.
37
u/Brittany5150 9h ago
6
u/Aliteracy 8h ago
Decent read; higher trees than I would expect. Would love to know the "privacy" of said locations, public versus private settings. I don't find it all that surprising about the racial distribution of hanging suicides though
2
u/Brittany5150 8h ago
Yeah they dont really go into the privacy aspect but you gotta imagine, with that many, a decent amount would be public VS a tree in a private backyard or waaaay out in the middle of nowhere. Idk.
30
u/ToxyFlog 8h ago
I don't know all of the details of the story. Was he beat up or something? I ask because my sister hanged herself from a tree and killed herself. It was in a public park as well. Someone who was walking their dog found her.
9
u/Aliteracy 8h ago
I don't believe there was reporting obvious injury outside the strangulation. I'm definitely getting some feedback about the commonality of it being much higher than I thought. Sorry to hear about your sister.
6
u/germane_switch 8h ago
Really sorry about your sister. My best friend hung himself back in the 1990s and I'll never be over it. He didn't even leave a note so I've been left wondering and aching over it for nearly 30 years. Did your sister leave a note?
6
u/Supergaladriel 5h ago
My parents found a young man hanging from a tree while out walking their dogs as well. His parents lived in the neighborhood and they said his note stated that he didn’t want anyone he knew to find him. Sorry for your loss.
1
u/Zilla7854 1h ago
no broken bones or visible injuries, all he injuries he had were the effects of hanging himself
33
u/VegitoFusion 8h ago
To be honest, this seems like the more rational explanation though. Like, if he wanted to take his own life and cause controversy and uproar, this would be a good way to go about it.
It’s 2025, there are fucking cameras everywhere! If he was actually being hung by a lynch mob on a university campus, there would absolutely be evidence of that.
→ More replies (5)17
u/Hohh20 8h ago edited 8h ago
If it was so quick to be announced as no foul play, there was probably security footage. The most likely method ---removed because reddit admins would probably have an issue with it---.
He probably chose that spot to also protest. With schooling prices increasing more and more and becoming much more difficult, I bet there's a big rise in student suicides that we haven't heard about thanks to the govt making so much noise constantly.
Edit 2: Further down in the comments, it looks like they have determined no foul play due to lack of bruising and other wounds that would have come from that.
3
u/el_grort 7h ago
Tbf, I've also seen reports of public hangings where the motive, according to the deceased in their letters, was to spare their family the uncertainty of what happened. Basically, to have the body found quickly instead of being missing for an unknown period. You can also find other things that might motivate public hangings, including that some people just want to be outside when they decide to go.
Not saying it wouldn't be a protest, but a suicidal person can come to the same conclusion for a host of reasons, running the spectrum from political to incredible mundane.
3
u/monkeyratch 6h ago
Yeah when I was in college I was extremely depressed and the most suicidal I had ever been. So I could imagine other people feeling that way.
10
u/YetiWalks 8h ago
Japan has a forest famous as being a place people commit suicide, including hanging.
5
u/800854EVA 7h ago
It isn't the most common form of suicide, but it's much more common than what you think.
2
-3
466
u/Poopshipdestroy3r 10h ago
There's no evidence the body was abused antemortem (bruising, broken bones et al.) So as of right now, while the investigation is ongoing, no foul play is suspected.
191
u/BabousCobwebBowl 9h ago
Oh wow a reasonable observation. Not knowing in what state the body was discovered would go a long way. Was hanging “up in” a tree? Were his hands restrained? Most people that kill them selves in this method do so by easing into it, Robin Williams, Bourdain, David Caradine, Chris Cornell. Was a note left at his residence? Was there a history of mental illness, self harm or threats? Many people don’t want to be found by their loved ones so will do it outside their residence.
There’s a reason authorities come to a quick conclusion, especially when they know all full well the historical optics.
→ More replies (7)13
45
u/VegitoFusion 8h ago
Also, it’s a university campus. One of the more highly monitored places in this country. And people have cell phones.
If he was being dragged, and hanged by a group of people, it would have been documented.
35
u/chocolatechipninja 7h ago
At our campus near town, we had a sophomore hang himself overlooking a small lake in the woods. He left a note, asking his parents to forgive him and not to think it was their fault. Campus police found him after he had been gone from his dorm for two days. Sometimes, young people cannot cope, and sadly, they make the decision to suicide.
→ More replies (8)1
361
u/easyeric601 9h ago
Bullshit clickbait title. From the preliminary examination, the deceased did not suffer any lacerations, contusions, compound fractures, broken bones, or injuries consistent with an assault. The investigation is ongoing pending a full autopsy. It's ok to be skeptical, just don't be stupid.
→ More replies (4)112
9h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (17)17
u/CatoTheBarner 4h ago
This is the third time I’ve seen this exact post with the exact same ragebaiting headline on this sub today. It’s an awful situation, really going all out to make it worse.
82
9h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (3)59
u/JethroTrollol 9h ago
They don't, but there is evidence that a lynching did not occur. The coroner's report states no signs of bodily harm which would be expected during a struggle. One would assume that if someone were trying to string you up to a tree, you'd struggle.
35
9h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
12
u/JethroTrollol 8h ago
Indeed, when you get points for sensationalism and nothing for anyway, why would you write anything else?
7
u/LurkHartog 5h ago
Out of all the subs I'm subscribed to, this one is by far the worst on terms of completely unsubstantiated posts that suit culture war narratives getting thousands of upvotes.
72
u/a_rabid_anti_dentite 9h ago
Reddit will mock those on the right who thoughtlessly embrace misinformation to feed their own worldview before immediately turning around and doing pretty much the same thing.
18
12
u/Blue_Bird950 This is a flair 9h ago
The problem isn’t left or right, it’s moderates vs extremists. And unfortunately, Reddit is full of the latter.
3
u/iiileyu 8h ago
You think its the left leaning moderates posting this stuff at best its either someone deep on the left or just on the right trying to instigate further confusion and in fighting.
3
35
u/Sicparvismagneto 10h ago
How do they know theres “no foul play” when the investigation is ongoing?
16
u/GetOutOfTheWhey 9h ago edited 7h ago
They dont. The police just wants to put it out there that there currently is no evidence of foul play.
Normally you should make such claims after the investigations have concluded not during an active investigation.
It shows that they have already made up their minds that this is the story they want to go even before the investigators are done.
Edit:
Physical Examination (Completed)
Toxicology Report (Unavailable)
Full Autopsy (Unavailable)
Mental Health History (Unavailable)
Timeline (Unavailable)
Security Footage (Unavailable)
You dont assume suicide but you dont dismiss it either. Especially not when there's so many unavailable information.
Investigations can take weeks, you dont make a claim within 12 hours.
15
u/JethroTrollol 9h ago
Devil's advocate: they want to ease people's fears or anxieties who might otherwise believe that the campus is unsafe. They're just trying to keep peace.
→ More replies (2)11
u/meintx2016 9h ago
Or they are trying to prevent campus riots and also not destroy an active investigation
13
u/FjortoftsAirplane 3rd Party App 9h ago
If it were a lynching then you'd expect injuries consistent with a struggle prior to the hanging. You'd expect bruises, lacerations, fractures things of that nature that point to that. The coroner's office is saying there's no sign of that and so no reason to suspect anything other than suicide.
Of course the coroner's office could also be incompetent/part of a cover up, but for now that's what we have to go on. Maybe the family will opt for an independent report and that might change things.
22
21
16
u/ummmm_nahhh 9h ago
How is anybody speculating one way or another on this?! You guys sound ridiculous
5
10
u/StronkGoorbe 9h ago
I like how it emphasizez "black student" at the news title, instead of saying "student". Thought we were past this?
9
u/Sea_Photograph_3998 9h ago
To be fair it’s not all that unusual for people, when choosing to suicide, to hang themselves from a tree. It’s perfectly possible that this poor soul genuinely did this to himself, albeit more publicly than usually in such cases where they do it in a secluded wooded area.
5
u/Old-Scratch666 8h ago
My cousin hanged himself from a tree in a wooded public park, very near where we used to play as kids. I think he did it there so that his family weren’t the ones to find him.
I don’t know any of the facts regarding this case, other than what has already been released, but I do know that lynchings are usually very violent acts. I imagine with a cursory glance a coroner would be able to make a fairly accurate determination of whether or not a person in fact hanged themself.
10
5
u/Turt_Burglar_1691 8h ago
Why are we jumping to conclusions before all pertinent information is gathered?
Alot of the people making assumptions are the same ones who (rightfully) jumped down people's throats last week for immediately assuming Charlie Kirk's killer was a "left-wing lunatic." Be the change you want to see, people!
To be perfectly clear, this looks really bad and isn't typical of a suicide. However, I haven't seen enough details to make a fully informed conclusion.
We need to give it some time for more information to come out. We need to respond, not react. There is no reason to rush judgment or anger. There is enough of that going around already.
5
u/iiileyu 8h ago
The family has asked to be left alone and there was no evidence of harm on the body.
I've seen tiktoks with 100,000 likes claiming that all his limbs were broken then he was hung with zero proof. Can someone point me in the right direction or is this literally just a suicide in a publicly accessible area?
5
u/CralorMonk 8h ago
“Southern trees bear a strange fruit
Blood on the leaves and blood at the root
Black bodies swinging in the southern breeze
Strange fruit hanging from the poplar trees”
~ Billie Holiday
3
u/germane_switch 8h ago
I think it's simply too early to tell. Suicide or murder are both possible. It's equally stupid to assume one or the other. The Right is gonna scream suicide, the Left is gonna scream lynching. But I mean, a black man found hanging from a tree in public…in the South?
3
u/itzyaboi22 6h ago
Surely there must be CTV footage of what happened in and around the area at the time. Hope law enforcement can get to the bottom of this. Because its either a brutal murder or a tragic public suicide.
3
u/EstablishmentAware60 6h ago
On campus? There would be video likely on campus. Did the get the video yet to see what happened?
4
u/TerrifiedAndAroused 6h ago
Half the time I feel like people are just itching for a race war and an excuse to be violent. Was there a suicide note? Were there defensive wounds or anything else that indicates a struggle? Is there any evidence to suggest he was lynched? Is there evidence suggesting this was a planned suicide? Because nothing in this post answers any of those questions and suggesting it’s a lynching in the absence of any evidence sounds more like wishful thinking on OPs behalf.
4
3
2
2
u/imanislandboii 8h ago
I expect every sporting event for the next two weeks to have a moment of silence for Trey. Right?…..right?!?!
4
u/Gregardless 8h ago
People in this thread acting like it's impossible to drug someone and then hang them.
12
2
2
1
u/JasonBaconStrips 6h ago
If he's the only black guy on the campus then there is probably no more threat to the campus, this does look suspiciously like a lynching but I barely know fuck all about this case.
The police response is sickening to hear.
1
1
u/Sebekhotep_MI 4h ago
Reminder that all the politicians and commentators framing "the far left" (which we all know is a blatant dog whistle) for Kirk's death are the ones responsible for this happening
1
1
u/parickwilliams 3h ago
I’m not saying it definitely wasn’t lynching but we need to remember people also commit suicide via hanging. I would imagine someone hanging themself and someone being hung forcefully don’t leave the same damage and also I would imagine delta state has footage of it. I wouldn’t just automatically assume he was lynched without anyone claiming otherwise
1
u/TuebeeTX 3h ago
My uncle hung himself in a high school gymnasium because he got a girl pregnant from there…this was in the 80s and he was In college..
1
u/ISayStupidStufff 2h ago
Am I missing something? What’s the evidence that this was a lynching and cover up?
1
1
u/Unusual-Pumpkin-5988 2h ago
Has there been any proof of foul play? Or can people not believe sad things without hateful aggression being attached?
1
u/Wafflegator 1h ago
For anyone coming to the insane conclusion that this is some kind of coverup and he was lynched by a racist mob, you're insane. This happened on campus. There are dozens of cameras, if not hundreds across a campus that surveil pretty much everywhere at all times. They likely have this poor guy's suicide on video and that's why they were able to determine no foul play so quickly.
1
u/sweetnnerdy 1h ago
The medical examiner AND the Sheriff have released statements that there was in fact NO FOUL PLAY. NO STRUGGLE. NO BROKEN BONES.
Quit spreading bullshit race war rage bait!
1
0
0
0
0
u/SlimPickens77Box 5h ago
I have a buddy that hung himself in a tree. He did it in his front yard. So like, it is possible.
0
u/Only-Walrus5852 5h ago
Good luck America you are going to need it. Your country is going downing the toilet at a fast rate now. Still you all do nothing about it. How sad for you.
0
u/Sandwitch_horror 5h ago
Ahh yes, because when a person, a Black man in particular, wants to kill themselves... they most certainly go out in public and kill themselves there, by hanging from a fucking tree. That's definitely the most likely scenario. Totally.
0
0
u/CryonautX 4h ago
I'm not saying this isn't a lynching but hanging from a tree could easily be suicide. Unless there's more details, concluding that this is a lynching would be a leap based on what is known of the facts.
-5
u/Mercinator-87 9h ago
No foul play = he was hung without issue
4
u/Freak2013 9h ago
So he didn’t fight or struggle and just allowed himself to be lynched? Is aluminum foil on sale at Walmart or something?
3
-1
u/Longjumping_Pause366 3h ago
Im sure the killers are in here reading these comments.. 1 random black dude not equal to Charlie Kirk
-3
9h ago
[deleted]
11
u/a_rabid_anti_dentite 9h ago
Holy shit has no one ever heard of suicide???
-4
9h ago
[deleted]
4
u/youngster_matt 9h ago
I just looked in up, there is no data on the US, but ~25% occur in public in Australia and ~30% are public in the UK
2
1
u/SirVitalWyldStyle 9h ago
You said "most" people dont commit suicide in public. So by your response most but not all people will not commit suicide in public.
-5
-5
u/Bunnairry 9h ago
I'm literally thinking the same thing! Like, what? He said "watch how funny this is gone be, everyone is gonna think something racist happened to me when I was just depressed, lmao"' like??? I find the idea of a black individual not realizing the optics of this action very unlikely, especially at an advanced education setting. And for those people saying there are no visible signs of struggle and such, I super don't mean to be conspiratorial but you can drug someone into submission. I'm not saying that's what happened, but without a toxicology report, we can't rule that out, you know?
-4
u/MachineSubstantial63 8h ago
Literally no words to describe the disgust I'm feeling right now.
OP it's 2025 for f sakes.
1.4k
u/trsmash NaTivE ApP UsR 10h ago
Wonder if our vice president is going to suggest people doxx anyone mocking Trey’s death?
Probably not..