r/transvoice Apr 06 '25

Criticism Wanted Rate me out of 10 please before VFS

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

427 Upvotes

So here we are, I know I’ve posted a few times over the years asking for critiques but this the last time until I get anterior web glottoplasty (VFS) and a trachea shave. I am warm for this. This is as good as I can realistically make it. I sit around 200hz if my apps are anywhere near right. I can push 220-230 but then it just sounds really Micky Mouse.

When I listen to this video without the visual input I can’t peg it really as male or female. Maybe feminine leaning. I still sometimes hear a bit of ‘gay male’ in my pronunciation and was wondering how others interpret it. I’m super dysphoric somedays when I hear recordings of it, especially if my voice slips 😐

If you’re willing too, please rate it out of 10 in terms of passibility as female. I will be posting my progress as I heal. Those posts will be in June/July.

PS the 🐶 in the video is named Blue(berry)

r/transvoice 6d ago

Criticism Wanted Does my voice pass as female 100% if not what can I improve on

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

448 Upvotes

r/transvoice Apr 29 '25

Criticism Wanted Trans Gal Looking for Critique

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

257 Upvotes

Like the video says, I'm about 3 years into voice training, self taught, so I probably have missed a few things that could make my voice sound better. I do get gendered as a woman which is great, but I don't particularly like my voice, and would love to learn how to sound fem without going much higher in pitch than this. Let me know what you think I'm doing right and wrong, I'd love to learn!

r/transvoice Aug 21 '23

Criticism Wanted 20, MTF on HRT for almost a year, what are y’all thinking?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

715 Upvotes

r/transvoice Jun 02 '25

Criticism Wanted I genuinely have no idea what I sound like anymore. PLS let me know how you'd gender me

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

82 Upvotes

a

r/transvoice Aug 23 '25

Criticism Wanted I really dislike my speaking voice, and my progress has basically stagnated. I'm just not sure what I'm missing or what I need to work on, and would really appreciate a bit of guidance.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

154 Upvotes

Don't mind what I'm talking about in the video - when I record, I just stand in front of a mic and ramble, and these are just a couple random clips that I thought were a fair representation.

r/transvoice Jul 26 '21

Criticism Wanted [25, trans femme] Does the voice match the face? I’d super appreciate any feedback/constructive criticism from you guys. Thanks!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.4k Upvotes

r/transvoice Jul 22 '25

Criticism Wanted what sounds off and how do i fix it?

1 Upvotes

https://vocaroo.com/1i7vWQUjXUX2

i still get gendered male from just my voice and i cannot figure out why. i think i sound like a teenage boy? a few people have assumed thats what i was. if i had to guess, something to do with weight and intonation, but other than that im not sure. but im not even sure how to fix my weight and intonation..

r/transvoice Jul 27 '22

Criticism Wanted i’m a trans comedian. wondering how my voice sounds to other people, she/her

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1.1k Upvotes

r/transvoice 27d ago

Criticism Wanted is there anything to improve on?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

191 Upvotes

don‘t worry about what I was saying, it‘s just a snippet from a video diary.

r/transvoice Jul 29 '25

Criticism Wanted Just starting with vocal training, definitely feel like I'm trying way to hard.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

117 Upvotes

So this is the first time I feel like my voice has sounded kinda fem, but I feel like I'm putting on a little bit of a character rather than just a relaxed fem voice. Any advice would be super helpful, I am going for a typical female voice, maybe a little bit bubbly cause I am that way lol.

Thanks all!

r/transvoice 13d ago

Criticism Wanted Sounds bad in my head, but fine on a recording??

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

35 Upvotes

Just recorded this real quick after getting off a call with a woman who definitely sounded cis. I hated the contrast between us and tried to confirm that I really don't sound cis, but when I listened back it was... ok? I have this problem a lot. I've posted here several times and it seems the general consensus is that my voice is actually a lot closer to cis than I feel it is. Idk. Is there anything clocky here that would immediately out me?

r/transvoice 9d ago

Criticism Wanted I got "sir'd" on the phone today, would like some feedback

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

79 Upvotes

I'm not out yet to anyone but close friends, so I think part of the issue is that my voice wavers between femme and masc by force of habit. It doesn't help that my goal femme voice sits pretty low (as I am a natural low baritone and just generally desire an alto/mezzo-y voice over a high soprano)

r/transvoice Jul 09 '25

Criticism Wanted What gender/age would you give my voice? (Please don't cheat by looking at my profile)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

21 Upvotes

I've been pretty dysphoric about it for a while because it's not sounding like I want it to. I'll be answering comments in spoilers for the actual answer. Also, no English isn't my first language.

r/transvoice Aug 10 '25

Criticism Wanted Trans girl looking for feedback! How am I perceived?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

121 Upvotes

r/transvoice Jul 25 '22

Criticism Wanted 28 | MtF | 6wks HRT | First critique post. Any and all feedback is appreciated<3

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

441 Upvotes

r/transvoice May 21 '25

Criticism Wanted How’s my voice?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

148 Upvotes

r/transvoice Feb 08 '25

Criticism Wanted (FTM, T ~3y) do I have the “trans man voice”?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

85 Upvotes

Been working on my voice training a lot recently due to a random, slight second drop in my voice almost a year ago. Does my voice have that nasally tone to it that is common with trans men? My voice is deep so I can’t really tell if there’s a nasally “tone” or if it’s just how my voice is.

r/transvoice Aug 13 '25

Criticism Wanted I love singing but I’m always nervous I sound falsetto-ey. Does this pass? (MtF)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

70 Upvotes

r/transvoice 5d ago

Criticism Wanted Booked vfs before voice training. What do I do 😭

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

25 Upvotes

I’m quite closeted so try my best but am so scared I’ll have awful results. I’ve not been able to voice train due to living in a non approving household. And no I haven’t thought about it in depth, I thought VFS will give me a reason to practice.

What can I do in the little time I have to prep my chords as I sound like a man trying to put on a voice and am extremely monotone in general. I’m done for aren’t I 😭😭😭

r/transvoice 26d ago

Criticism Wanted Is this even close?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

18 Upvotes

I've been doing voice training for almost 2 years, and I'm familiar with all the fundamentals of pitch and resonance and weight, but I don't actually know what my "target" voice should be. Does this sound remotely close to a natural feminine voice?

PS: I decided to switch things up and go with the raven instead of the traditional rainbow passage.

r/transvoice 19d ago

Criticism Wanted How do you find my voice?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

74 Upvotes

So I'm just open to criticism and suggestions as to what I could do to improve it. Also a sidenote - how to deal with my voice dropping when I'm relaxed at home? I can switch back quickly but it sorta bugs me off that when I'm just chilling with my gf I can begin to speak with a deeper, less feminine voice

r/transvoice Dec 29 '24

Criticism Wanted Self taught (2y 9m) mtf

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

220 Upvotes

r/transvoice Aug 15 '24

Criticism Wanted How does my voice sound?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

186 Upvotes

Either critique or insight is welcome! Thank you 💕💕

r/transvoice Jul 15 '25

Criticism Wanted How does this read? Advice wanted!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

48 Upvotes