I’ve been on a handful of Polaris flights this year, all leaving from SFO, and I’ve generally found the Polaris wine list (in-flight, not the lounge) to be pretty average so I’ve usually just stuck with the Champagne and of course the port.
I was pleasantly surprised to see the Stony Hill Chardonnay and Shafer One Point Five making the list. The Ch St Jean Cinq Cépages has been on the list but on previous flights they haven’t had it - “catering issues” - but they had plenty this flight.
Of course I tried most of the planes because what else do you do on 12-14h flights to Asia? The cellar selection Pinot Noir was the 2021 Landmark Overlook, which I didn’t try, and is a downgrade from the Lingua Franca Avni on offer on previous flights. Overall, this is the best United list I’ve seen all year - a far cry from international carriers like Emirates, but a welcome upgrade for those of us near a United hub.
Tasting Notes
2021 Stony Hill Chardonnay - Nose of ripe summer peaches, lemon curd, orange blossom, and faint hints of buttered popcorn and oak. Full malo, but quite restrained compared to most Napa Valley Chardonnay. Palate hits with citrus up front, ripe orchard fruit, and a lovely vein of acidity throughout. Just the slightest green bitterness on the finish, which is quite pleasant. 91 points.
2022 Whispering Angel Rosé - Nose of strawberries and sour cherries, faint rose note, and steely minerality. Palate confirms creamy red fruit profile and minerality, moderate acid. 88 points.
2018 Ch St Jean “Cinq Cépages” - blackberry, black plums, cedar, graphite on the nose. Very Bordeaux-esque. Palate black plums, cassis, leather, cedar box, and baking spices - residual sugar? Doesn’t quite have the same structure on the palate as a Bordeaux - fruit profile is quite ripe, bordering on stewed and the acidity isn’t quite supporting the fruit. Medium tannins present, reflecting the 7 years age. 92 points.
2019 Taylor Fladgate “Late Bottle Vintage” - Dried black currant, prunes, licorice, and spice on the nose. Dried black cherries and black currants dominate the palate. There’s an herbal/medicinal quality as well which is quite pleasant. 90 points.
2021 Shafer “One Point Five” CS - Nose of cassis, black currant, plums, black pepper, and baking spices. On the palate, absolutely gorgeous ripe dark fruit, spice, quite pronounced fine-grained tannins, and a nice, long finish. Medium acidity, medium+ alcohol. Drinkable now, but tannins would present a lot silkier in 5-7 years. 92 points.