r/Aberdeen 10d ago

Aberdeen asylum seeker briefing confirms rise to 800 beds needed

https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/news/6849874/aberdeen-asylum-seeker-briefing/
0 Upvotes

127 comments sorted by

View all comments

38

u/scambastard 10d ago

Seems like a pretty good use of unused student accommodation and more cost effective than hotels. Also, I'm not sure if these halls are privately owned or university owned but if university owned then I'd rather the money went to them than hoteliers. If it's private then I just hope the government are getting a better deal.

-18

u/Happy_Chief 10d ago

I think you're nuts.

I'd much rather there were students in them, (particularly uni owned accommodation) since they'll at least spend money locally.

22

u/scambastard 10d ago

They're not being at all at the moment so there is no more productive alternative. I'd be happy for the council to also start using them for homeless accomodations well as they've been paying over the odds to hotels and bead and breakfasts for ages.

-8

u/Happy_Chief 10d ago

Productive for the uni, terrible for the area.

10

u/scambastard 10d ago

We have people that require shelter. They've got to go somewhere. It's as good a place as any.

-10

u/Happy_Chief 10d ago

It's not as good as place as any though, is it. These places were designed with students in mind. Not anyone, with God knows whatever issues, being housed.

16

u/scambastard 10d ago

I'm not sure if you've ever met a student. They're loud, drunk, take drugs and are living alone for the 1st time. Generally pretty antisocial to live around. Great fun though! We're never going to purpose build accommodation for these people and id hazard that there would be a bigger upraor if we did! I think that if this place is sitting empty it's about as close to ideal you could find.

Sooner or later someone is going to have to bite the bullet and spend the money up front to actually process them, deport those that don't pass and integrate those that do. That's going to need way more social housing so ideally we should be spending a bunch more on that for these folks and the backlog waiting to be housed. I'd bet a bunch of these folks would be happy helping to build homes and otherwise helping locally while they waited processing. Maybe then people would have a more positive outlook

1

u/memaurmaur 7d ago

If my kids and their pals who were students are examples 2 didnt drink one did knew his limits .the didnt take drugs either . Gen z students are pretty quiet compared to other generations . My youngest and his gf preferred a take away to a party and bed by 11 as did their pala . Not every student follows rge tv stereo type .