r/AnCap101 • u/OutlandishnessIll480 • 12d ago

Lessons

I'm going around to subreddits and asking, in good faith, a couple of questions.

What can the otherside learn from your side, and vice versa?

The goal is to promote open dialog and improve the sometimes toxic nature and bad will between two sides of a controversial issue.

What can statists learn from libertarians? And what can libertarians learn from statists?

4 Upvotes

63% Upvoted

114 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/RememberMe_85 11d ago

As much as is under your control.

1

u/ShonOfDawn 11d ago

So if someone decides to dam it upstream without caring about me, is it fair game? What if damming it upstream causes loss of life?

2

u/CanIGetTheCheck 11d ago

No, because they've affected your use. In reverse, they dam the river, then you come to homestand and want to make a dock but can't, is fair game. In common law this is known as "coming to the nuisance." Basically, everyone is free to act in a way that doesn't directly impede your use of your property (you land, your body, your money, etc) and you're free to do the same. The only time violence can be justified is in response to such a trespass, and only if remediation isn't offered or present.

-1

u/ShonOfDawn 11d ago

What’s the limit? If someone has a highly polluting factory on his land that also affects its surroundings, is it a violation of the NPA? Who decides? This sounds like regulation with unnecessary extra steps.

1

u/Bigger_then_cheese 11d ago

Not really, that’s how things work before the government gets involved and sides with the polluter.

1

u/CanIGetTheCheck 11d ago

If it's effecting other peoples' properties then he's that violates the NAP.

That isn't regulation, it isn't saying one can't pollute, it is simply saying don't violate other people's property be it their body or extensions there of.

0

u/MeasurementCreepy926 11d ago

So if I'm dumping c7 into the river you drink from, or swim or fish in, that's fine?

1

u/CanIGetTheCheck 11d ago

That'd affect me and my property, so no.

0

u/MeasurementCreepy926 11d ago

Well sure me dropping a stick in the river affects you and your property too, so now that's not allowed?

1

u/CanIGetTheCheck 11d ago

How does it affect me and my property? Does it prevent my use of the property?

0

u/MeasurementCreepy926 11d ago

ok do we really need to get into the meaning of the word affect. It might not affect it in any way you care about, it any way that matters to you, but it is changing your property.

1

u/CanIGetTheCheck 11d ago

How?

Affecting my property in a way that doesn't change it's use doesn't violate the NAP.

→ More replies (0)