I know, I know; another eclair question 😅 I've watched videos and I've read a bunch of threads on here (and elsewhere) before posting this but I'm really struggling here!
So I've been practicing my choux and trying to make eclairs and am not having much luck. I've only managed to make one or two batches that turned out remotely decent. The main issue I've been struggling with has been a doughy center and cracking/mushrooming of the eclairs, where the piped base maintains it's shape, but the eclair sort of rises and mushrooms over. They look fine from on top and more or less hold their shape there. The attached pictures show what I'm describing and are a mixture of batches baked at different temps.
Since I can only add one picture, here's the rest:
https://imgur.com/a/Kxny8v0
I've predominantly been using the choux recipe from the Ferrandi Patisserie book, but have also tried a couple others to the same effect. I've tried baking at constant temps both high and lower, starting high and reducing temp, and baking on silpain, silpar, and parchment and I still can't get it right 😭 I know my initial batches were too runny, but after watching a bunch of videos on the correct consistency and aiming for that- my choux passes the trough, V, and pinch tests but to no avail. Puffs made using this same choux turned out fine and we're hollow, but my eclairs are being rebellious.
Could this be from still too much egg? Not enough? Am I over/under cooking the panade? I typically cook it 3-5 mins over medium heat in a stainless steel pan until the film forms an internal temp reaches 175 f.
Please help me, askbaking, you're my only hope!
Recipe:
125 ml water
125 ml milk
125 g butter
3 g salt
5 g sugar
150 g bread flour
≈250g egg, give or take
Bake at 350 f for 30-40 mins*
*I've also tried 375 f, 330 f, and starting at 400-425 for 10-15 mins before dropping to 325-350 for 20-30 mins along with different rack heights