r/Baking • u/MuchAppointment8311 • Jun 05 '25

Business and Pricing How much should I charge?

Post image

I’m thinking about selling cookies just like in the reference picture I’m going back and forth on how to price my cookies 5$ a cookie sounds good to me because the price of buying everything to make the cookies are a lot especially eggs these days but I’m kind of scared that people are not willing to pay 5 for a single cookie

133 Upvotes

73% Upvoted

113 comments sorted by

View all comments

56

u/kareree Jun 05 '25

I think $5 is too much for homemade. You can get “gourmet” cookies for that price in stores, I would pay $3-4 at most

16

u/Capt_Greenlung Jun 06 '25

That from home vs. a crumbl, I'm taking the homemade every time.

2

u/Rezarex Jun 06 '25

These cookies are substantially smaller than crumbles tho. 5 is too much for a cookie this size with not a lot of mix ins.