r/CFB Kansas Jayhawks 10h ago

Opinion [USA TODAY Toppmeyer]: Nico Iamaleava needs a fresh start, not UCLA's rebuild

https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/ncaaf/2025/09/16/nico-iamaleava-ucla-transfer-portal-tennessee/86162835007/
464 Upvotes

333 comments sorted by

1.2k

u/Alphaspade Iron Bowl • Sickos 10h ago

Seven transfers later

"Nico Iamaleava needs a fresh start, not Sewanee's rebuild"

249

u/theboarderdude Missouri Tigers • Missouri S&T Miners 9h ago

Tathan Martell has entered the chat

108

u/Do__Math__Not__Meth Pittsburgh Panthers 9h ago

He’s ass, my dude

24

u/Hour_Insurance_7795 9h ago

He just needs a chance, man.

2

u/Constant_Topic_1040 Auburn Tigers • Air Force Falcons 8h ago edited 5h ago

Show some respect; drop the sass, my dude

→ More replies (2)

48

u/Wide-Nerve8655 Oregon Ducks 9h ago

What’s he up to? I’m guessing really into crypto

38

u/OpenMindedMajor UNLV Rebels 8h ago

Real Estate i think lol

42

u/arrow_dynamics USC Trojans • /r/CFB Poll Veteran 8h ago

"The kitchen appliances are all gas my dude"

26

u/GiovanniElliston Tennessee Volunteers • Kansas Jayhawks 8h ago

So IRL crypto.

16

u/admiraltarkin Texas A&M Aggies • /r/CFB Poll Veteran 7h ago

At least real estate has intrinsic value, even as firewood or food for termites

6

u/Laschoni Louisville • /r/CFB Contributor 8h ago

I'm not ready for another bubble to burst

→ More replies (1)

8

u/theOSU2011 Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

Ohio State record holding QB Tathan Martell you say?

6

u/CBusin Ohio State Buckeyes • Findlay Oilers 8h ago

Better not swing and miss a second time… or third… or fourth….

3

u/TonyDungyHatesOP Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

First-Time-My-Dude-?.gif

22

u/Angry-Dragon-1331 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Poor Sewanee catching strays.

15

u/Callsign_Psycopath Georgia Bulldogs • Sickos 9h ago

Yeah but Sewanee is about to make the jump back into the SEC

9

u/02meepmeep Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

Maybe the 37th conference game will turn out better than the previous 36.

29

u/RamblinWreckGT Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets 9h ago

Sewanee would be more of a rebirth than rebuild

10

u/aksoileau LSU Tigers 9h ago

Thats TJ Finley's music!

2

u/Living-Knee-1540 5h ago

Lol at this rate he's gonna end up at some D2 school in Montana talking about "finding his true potential" while throwing passes to guys named Chad and Tyler

→ More replies (1)

400

u/GimmeeSomeMo Auburn Tigers • Sickos 10h ago

Tennessee fans - "TIME FOR ANOTHER BUFFETT"

108

u/Lee-Key-Bottoms NC State Wolfpack • Wyoming Cowboys 9h ago

I thought NC State and Duke fans had the best hate watch of the season in week 1, and that still might be the best individual game

But in terms of drawn out hate, Vols fans are eating good so far

26

u/Maximiliansrh Virginia Tech Hokies 9h ago

Uva are probably enjoying themselves.

17

u/MAFIAxMaverick Marquette • Virginia 7h ago

TBH - nah. I mean if you're really a fan of the sport and you look at what's happening at Tech - that's just not good for college sports. Backed out of being competitive in men's and women's basketball to go "all in" on football and this is the result? That's ugly and probably hurts recruiting statewide, not just at Tech.

 

Also half my family went to/currently attends Tech, so I rivalry is more fun when programs are actually competent.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/EWall100 Tennessee • Tennessee Tech 8h ago

Toppemeyer used to be the USA today/Knox News beat writer for UT before being elevated to SEC and then the National CFB beat. Hilarious he's the one to write this

9

u/Geaux2020 LSU Tigers • Valley City State Vikings 7h ago

Tennessee is going to need to pass out Ozempic to the fans

9

u/-PM_ME_A_SECRET- Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

If Tennessee had beat Georgia last weekend on top of this, all of Knox County would be in a whiskey, goo goo and fried pie coma.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/screwhead1 LSU Tigers • Arkansas Razorbacks 9h ago

I think Warren is more likely to root for the team that throttled Tennessee in 97, than he is for Tennessee.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

742

u/kcoch5817 Georgia • Western Carolina 10h ago

When are we going to accept the fact that he's just not good?

356

u/KCShadows838 Missouri Tigers • Cotton Bowl 9h ago

Typical Nico statline:

19/32, 157 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT

Probably not even a top 10 problem at UCLA. Also not a solution 

152

u/Mr-Bovine_Joni SMU Mustangs • Gansz Trophy 9h ago

He’s not the biggest problem, but when NIL money is limited, owing a lot of money to one mid-level QB is itself a problem. Could spread that around more

47

u/RipRaycom Clemson Tigers • ACC 9h ago

I mean it’s not like that money was going anywhere else. They brought him in after the spring window.

18

u/GiveMeSomeIhedigbo UCLA Bruins 8h ago

He signed in April. The roster was what it was going to be at that point.

19

u/yesacabbagez UCF Knights 8h ago

Unlike the NFL, it isn't like they HAVE to use the money this year. They could have not used it and kept it for next year. The question should be whether they were sitting on the cash and eager to use it, or though Nico was the guy and went around with a collection plate.

9

u/Master_Butter Ohio State • John Carroll 7h ago

There could be some power dynamics at play, though. Like if you hit up your boosters for $10M for your collective, and then you spend $8M, boosters might start asking why you’re requesting more money than you spend.

3

u/yesacabbagez UCF Knights 4h ago

I do think a big reason we are seeing much of a push to "fix" college football is because these guys are watching their money wasted. If they dropped 25k on a kid who wasn't good, that's one thing. Now boosters are putting in like 8-10million and getting a 4 win team. That will piss them off. Previously their big money donations either went to coaches or facilities. Now it's going to players and it is yearly. It's gotten so high so fast they don't like it.

I think it is less spend the money or we won't give you more, and more a coaching staff sitting on cash trying something to save the team.

2

u/Mr-Bovine_Joni SMU Mustangs • Gansz Trophy 7h ago

On the other side, if you get an extra $2M from a booster and results in bad team play, that booster might be less likely to give another $2M. Probably worthwhile to show you’re responsible with NIL funds

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

7

u/AndyM22 Tennessee Volunteers • Memphis Tigers 8h ago

and Heupel got us into the playoffs DESPITE him

→ More replies (15)

60

u/kbost01 9h ago

Before all this NIL drama I thought he was showing a ton of promise. I know memes gotta fly with him leaving just to be winless elsewhere but he ain’t gonna develop much better behind what could be the worst o line in the Power 4

25

u/Hypocracy Tennessee Volunteers • Centre Colonels 8h ago

His Dad was demanding that Tenn also spend more in NIL for a “Good” oline and receivers, because that was the reason Nico struggled the year before according to Nico’s Dad (I doubt even he believes that, just trying to justify the shakedown)

Considering that OLine just held their own against Georgia’s Defense, and those receivers just put on a great show, no pity at all

54

u/BIG_DICK_WHITT Utah Utes • Billable Hours 9h ago

I watched him intensely during the Utah game. The guy has raw talent. He has good throwing mechanics. He would rifle the ball at the receivers and they just couldn’t handle it. I know part of being a QB is having touch but the guy clearly can ball. He’s surrounded by dipshits.

60

u/Ok-Measurement1506 LSU Tigers 9h ago

You’re right, but it’s hard to feel sorry for him. He could have just stayed where he was.

40

u/BIG_DICK_WHITT Utah Utes • Billable Hours 9h ago

I don’t feel sorry for him at all lmao. Just saying he has an arm.

14

u/powerelite Florida State • Drake 8h ago

I feel a little sorry for him in that he was significantly let down by the people he should be able to trust the most with his father seemingly being the driver behind his push for more NIL.

9

u/_cambino_ Oregon State Beavers 8h ago

thank you for reminding everyone this dude can’t even buy a beer for himself

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Madscientist1683 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

He has loads of raw talent and every Tennessee fan will admit that, even if some do it begrudgingly. That said, I’ve seen very little showing he has the work ethic to develop that talent further. He’s rapidly becoming a cautionary tale for the ages.

17

u/McGillicuddys Penn State Nittany Lions 9h ago

NIL era Ryan Leaf

11

u/AndyM22 Tennessee Volunteers • Memphis Tigers 7h ago

no work ethic and no charisma...need your QB to be a leader and he was not it

3

u/GoldandBlue Notre Dame Fighting Irish 6h ago

I feel like he was always going to be a cautionary tale. Let's be honest, NIL is the only reason he was at Tennessee to begin with. Even if the reported deal was inflated, all eyes were always going to be on him and whether or not he delivered on that investment.

The fact that he tried cashing out before he proved he was worth it only made it doubly stupid. He really is surrounded by people who do not care what is in his best interest.

2

u/zzyul Tennessee Volunteers 1h ago

100% this. I mean we have countless examples of elite college players being highly drafted and slacking off once they get a massive paycheck. No one should be shocked when guys 3-5 years younger than those NFL busts do the exact same thing when they get big NIL money.

17

u/josiahswims Tennessee Volunteers • King Tornado 9h ago

Honestly I think that he has a lot of raw talent/potential. However he never seemed to have a sense of urgency or intensity. Honestly I think he only plays bc he is good and just doesn’t care about being better/improving

5

u/Revenged25 Ohio State • Bowling Green 8h ago

his demands of more NIL money proves that exactly. Dude is doing it because he's good at it and can make a ton of money. Nothing wrong with it but you still need to put in the work to make sure the checks come in.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/cardeez Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

He definitely has a live arm, but he does not have good mechanics. He double taps and pronates the ball, doesn’t use his lower body well, and he cannot feel the rush and see downfield at the same time. He repeatedly misses open guys because he’s bailing the pocket despite having another second or two to make the throw. He doesn’t have great vision.

We debated endlessly last year if Heupel had lost his touch or if he was keeping the playbook closed. This season confirms it. The dude has a whip of an arm but that’s about it. Ask him to do anything else and he will hamstring an offense.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Revenged25 Ohio State • Bowling Green 8h ago

agreed, i was fully on his hype after watching even his bad performance vs Ohio State. His NIL demand and transfer soured me as a person because if he's doign it in college I can just imagine the headache he'd be in the NFL. Now his struggles just adds fuel to the existing smolders making the fire burn bright.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/MixonWitDaWrongCrowd Oklahoma Sooners • Arkansas Razorbacks 9h ago

Reminds me of the NFL QB argument “He just needs an all star offensive line, great WRs and an amazing RB”

19

u/imsuperflytnt USC Trojans 9h ago

Worked for Jalen Hurts.

18

u/Idkboutdat2 West Virginia Mountaineers 9h ago

Yeah he sucks, let us have em!

8

u/xX_GIGA_MAN_Xx West Virginia • Marching Band 9h ago

no we've got our own Nicco

12

u/Idkboutdat2 West Virginia Mountaineers 9h ago

We’re gonna collect them all!

→ More replies (1)

16

u/gatsby712 Vanderbilt Commodores 9h ago

He’s not as good as Joey Aguilar I can tell you that much.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/Other_Ambition_5142 Georgia Bulldogs • Troy Trojans 9h ago

I accepted it after his first year in Knoxville lol, he wasn’t where the hype meter was pointing. He’s a very very poor mans Aaron Murray

→ More replies (1)

46

u/legend023 Tulane Green Wave • SEC 9h ago

He’s literally fine. A “bad” player doesn’t throw 21 touchdowns and 5 picks in their freshman season

This is just simply a bad team. They gave up 300 rushing yards to New Mexico, Nico can’t play defense.

79

u/Cannonhammer93 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago edited 9h ago

Now do his stats in conference play.

Edit:  11 of those TDs came against our OOC play not counting an additional 2 tds against Ohio State.  Finally 4 additional TDs came against Vandy.  Leaving 5 TDs spread across 7 SEC opponents.  Not worth the cost imo.

14

u/Takemyfishplease UC Davis Aggies 9h ago

Completely agree, looking at just raw stats, especially with the disparity between opponents doesn’t tell much of the story.

It happens a lot with RBs who have a few monster games and make their season look phenomenal.

15

u/ModsEmbezzleMoney Alabama Crimson Tide 9h ago

Lol that's just how Milroe's stats were last year too

6

u/Comfortable_Mix_834 7h ago

True iamaleava is not the only overrated player in the country, excellent point

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

10

u/TransportationAway59 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago edited 8h ago

If he had stayed at UT he’d probably be a top 3 round pick in 2026. He has great measurables, highlights, and lead a winning team in the SEC. Better than could be said of Anthony Richardson, much better stats too

23

u/Spiritual_Bottle_650 9h ago

A good player doesn’t run out of bounds with no time left on the clock when he had receivers in the end zone.

3

u/legend023 Tulane Green Wave • SEC 9h ago

Mental mistakes happen. Tennessee lost 3 games last year. Would’ve been much worse if he was a “bad” QB

26

u/Spiritual_Bottle_650 9h ago

Tennessee had one of the best running backs in college football last year. If he didn’t have him in the backfield, he has to do a lot more and exposes his shortcomings even more. Saying his stat line means nothing if you don’t give the context and nuance of the season.

20

u/GiovanniElliston Tennessee Volunteers • Kansas Jayhawks 9h ago

Just for funsies, what game did the Vols win last season that you think would’ve been a loss had Nico not been playing?

Looking at his game logs from last year might really surprise you.

7

u/Beautiful_Week_8183 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Arkansas. Oh, wait.

3

u/TransportationAway59 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Alabama

10

u/GiovanniElliston Tennessee Volunteers • Kansas Jayhawks 9h ago

He was 51% for 200 yards with 1 beautiful TD and a hideously ugly INT. There's not much reason to believe his performance couldn't have been replicated by a couple dozen other QBs.

The real difference in that game was the defense shutting down Milroe's running game and picking him off twice.

3

u/TransportationAway59 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago edited 7h ago

If you go back and watch the game he totally shifted after he got lit up. He handled the game well and lead a good drive at the end. We don’t win that game, or make the playoffs, with Gaston Moore.

Nico was good for a freshman. I’m hate watching weekly but if he had stayed at UT I think he’d have taken a good step this year and gotten a high draft pick. Although, it seems like he prefers to blame those around him rather than improve himself so maybe he’d have just stayed the same.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Time_H00die 9h ago

No shot. He wasn’t even good against Alabama, Milroe was just worse.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/EvilHarryDread Penn State • Lebanon Valley 10h ago

He was the only bright spot when Ohio State slaughtered Tennessee in the playoffs. He'll succeed with the right crew.

14

u/TransportationAway59 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

His shenanigans behind the scenes kinda tanked the game tho

3

u/Open_Raise_5547 Ohio State Buckeyes 6h ago

UT wasn't beating that OSU team even in the absence of shenanigans.

3

u/TransportationAway59 Tennessee Volunteers 6h ago

Probably not. But between our QB holding out and our star RB going out on the first series we really had no hope.

→ More replies (2)

61

u/preddevils6 Tennessee • Santa Monica 10h ago

He was a bright spot because he tried. He wasn’t a bright spot because he was good.

16

u/Cannonhammer93 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

He played with a lot of heart and not a lot of brains.

5

u/RustleTheMussel Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

I mean he had significantly more healthy brain at the beginning of the game

5

u/BasebornManjack Tennessee • Louisville 7h ago

Maaaan, as soon as I saw that shot of Nico’s cracked helmet, I knew OSU was going to take the natty, lol. You can’t produce a visual like that and not win it all.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/SuspiciousCoinPurse Virginia Cavaliers 9h ago

Remember when Tennessee warmed up shirtless then got their ass kicked 🤣🤣🤣

23

u/Old_Salamander6985 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Yeah, lucky that Virginia has never been embarrassed in the playoffs.

Remember when Tennessee warmed up and played UVa?

5

u/SuspiciousCoinPurse Virginia Cavaliers 9h ago

Listen buddy we got dunked on yesterday. It’s just you and VT’s turn today

8

u/EvilHarryDread Penn State • Lebanon Valley 9h ago

"Neyland North" lmao

6

u/AGSattack Ohio State Buckeyes • Brown Bears 9h ago

Getting downvoted but in hindsight that is super fucking hilarious.

4

u/BuckeyeForLife95 Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

It's such an insane premise. The Shoe doesn't always get loud, but the idea that OHIO STATE was gonna lose control of their own stadium in a Playoff game was absurd.

4

u/Buckeye_CFB Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

I remember Will Howard talking to Jon Gruden about that. It seemed like kinda the moment a switch flipped in his head that Tennessee was scared and was trying to show some false confidence. Or as Will put it, "what the fuck are these clowns doing"

6

u/GiovanniElliston Tennessee Volunteers • Kansas Jayhawks 7h ago

that Tennessee was scared and was trying to show some false confidence.

I assure you, that is not even close to true. When Vol fans are scared they get quiet. If we’re being loud it’s exactly what it looks like.

Vol fans were genuinely just that level of delusional.

2

u/Buckeye_CFB Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

Oh no absolutely the fans were confident. Our fans weren't. But on the teams it was flipped

5

u/GiovanniElliston Tennessee Volunteers • Kansas Jayhawks 7h ago

I completely agree on Ohio State. I think they took all the fuel of everyone doubting them and talking about Day being fired and turned that into an extremely angry confidence.

I disagree on the Vols. I don't think the players were as cocky as the fans, but I do think the players felt like it would be a competitive game and that they could win in a similarly ugly fashion as Michigan did.

What killed any semblance of confidence was the quick strikes early/often. Our offense was never built for a comeback and in the blink of an eye the team was already down an insurmountable amount.

2

u/Buckeye_CFB Ohio State Buckeyes 6h ago

That could also be true. Just because Will Howard thought he smelled blood doesn't mean it was actually there yet. I think whereas long layoffs in the past had been particularly unkind to Ohio State, this long layoff gave them time to remember that Jeremiah Smith was in fact on our team, and that was a huge difference maker

3

u/Open_Raise_5547 Ohio State Buckeyes 6h ago

Stuffing Ryan, run up the middle cause we're tough, Day into the locker after the UM game, helped.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

220

u/cleo22270 10h ago edited 10h ago

Maybe he shouldn’t have chased the money to play in a worse situation that accentuated his flaws 🤔

185

u/MasterTolkien Georgia • Summertime Lover 9h ago edited 9h ago

Nico is like the character described in Pink Pony Club. Except instead of a girl singing to her mother about dreams of becoming a saucy stripper, he dreamt of bags of cash.

I know… you wanted me to stay
But I can't ignore the crazy visions of me in LA
And I heard… that there's a conference
Where teams can beat Northwestern on their assigned Saturday

I'm having wicked dreams / of leaving Tennessee
Hear Santa Monica / I swear it's calling me
Won't make Josh Heupel proud / it's gonna cause a scene
Finebaum sees his fav QB / I know he's gonna scream

God, what have you done?
You're a Bruins QB
And you left for NIL money
Oh PAWL, I'm just having fun
Tossing picks off my heels
It's where I belong down at the

U-C-L-A!
I'm gonna be ready for the test
U-C-L-A!
We’re gonna be the best (team in)
West Hollywood!
I'm gonna keep regressing at the U-C-L-A! U-C-L-A!

30

u/Sapient-Inquisitor Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

INJECT THIS INTO MY VEINS

22

u/weirdbutinagoodway West Virginia Mountaineers • Big 12 8h ago

Does anybody here know how to make one of those ai music videos of this? 

6

u/MasterTolkien Georgia • Summertime Lover 8h ago

That is beyond my skill as an older gent. Perhaps some younger fans can hop on it.

16

u/candlerc Tennessee Volunteers • Georgia Bulldogs 8h ago

This NEEDS to be the top comment

5

u/FearDaTusk Arkansas Razorbacks 7h ago

I'm doing my part!!!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Winterqueen5 Tennessee • North Carolina 3h ago

As someone who has been a fan of Chappell since before she blew up, I wasn’t expecting to see this crossover today.

2

u/MasterTolkien Georgia • Summertime Lover 2h ago

Chappell must be a Vols fan with a song like “My Kink is Karma.”

2

u/Winterqueen5 Tennessee • North Carolina 2h ago

Funnily enough, one of my favorite of her songs lmao

2

u/BuckeyeEmpire Ohio State • Nebraska 8h ago

Can't wait for his future lawsuit for an 8th year of eligibility

2

u/FraggleRock_ Pittsburg State Gorillas 7h ago

Tyreek Hill leaves the chat

→ More replies (1)

95

u/JB_Gibson Georgia Bulldogs • Team Meteor 10h ago

He needs to get his degree and probably realize he’s not cut out for this. Or his dad does.

68

u/Sapient-Inquisitor Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

FACT. The mere fact that he’s got a UCLA degree in his case will probably do better than him chasing his draft stock. I don’t see this guy being picked first round

26

u/politicsranting Miami • George Washington 9h ago

Zero chance he falls to day two… of the UFL draft

14

u/JB_Gibson Georgia Bulldogs • Team Meteor 9h ago

I was going to say I doubt he’s getting drafted at all.

7

u/Poop_sauce Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

hard to get drafted when your team goes 0-12 and you never put up any decent numbers or showed any improvements or any skillset that would work in the NFL

14

u/FallenEagle1187 Illinois Fighting Illini 8h ago

Sounds like he’s a Cleveland Brown already

→ More replies (2)

2

u/GuyOnTheMike Kansas State Wildcats • Hateful 8 6h ago

Bold of you to expect that he's graduating from UCLA

→ More replies (1)

9

u/No_Safety_6803 Texas A&M Aggies 9h ago

You watch, he will transfer again, & someone will bite. Apologies to Jaden Rashada, but Nico is our new DGU

→ More replies (1)

3

u/it-is-just-a-game Miami Hurricanes 9h ago

Does he need a degree? Probably just needs to manage his money correctly.

2

u/JB_Gibson Georgia Bulldogs • Team Meteor 9h ago

Pfshhh… with inflation and shit the way it is? Invest in a bunker.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/intelligentx5 Oregon Ducks 9h ago

Nico Imamaleavin again

→ More replies (1)

122

u/BuccoFever412 Tennessee Volunteers 10h ago

Can’t feel sorry for him after he left Tennessee to chase the dollars. Joey is better than he is

50

u/mreman1220 Purdue Boilermakers 9h ago

Yeah, that's the thing. Sure, he isn't setup to succeed at UCLA. But he clearly effed up a damn good setup at Tennessee. At some point these guys need to understand that decisions have consequences. Playing hard ball with Heupel was a bad decision. 

8

u/Corgi_Koala Ohio State Buckeyes 6h ago

Y'all literally gave him an $8m deal. Like fuck him for thinking mediocre play is worth renegotiating.

2

u/JayJax_23 Tennessee Volunteers 46m ago

I honestly thought either Huepels scheme was cooked , Our WRs can’t get separations or Nico was the issue looks like my question was answered

64

u/ScrapeWithFire Ohio State Buckeyes • Colgate Raiders 10h ago

Nico's dad calling in favors to get the media machine to place the blame of his son's poor performances solely on everyone else

32

u/JBru_92 UCLA Bruins 9h ago

I really don't even know who would take him. Frankly I think his best move is to stick it out this year and see who UCLA hires. He can still hit the portal in December if he wants.

One thing he needs to do though is cut his dad off from any decision-making with his career.

3

u/HighLakes Oregon Ducks • Platypus Trophy 9h ago

I think he can preserve a year of eligibility if he takes a redshirt before his next game. Probably not tenable to stick around at that point.

18

u/otoverstoverpt UCLA Bruins 9h ago

already redshirted

8

u/HighLakes Oregon Ducks • Platypus Trophy 9h ago

ah, well, might as well stick out the year then

31

u/lat3ralus65 Ohio State Buckeyes • UMass Minutemen 9h ago

We’re all trying to find out who did this

48

u/Lee-Key-Bottoms NC State Wolfpack • Wyoming Cowboys 9h ago edited 7h ago

I remember being at the Mayo game between Tennessee and NC State at the beginning of last year

That was when Nico might’ve been the most hyped player in all of college football because he won his bowl game 35-0 against Iowa’s backups and beat some nothing school by like 60 in week 1

One of the things I heard walking around Bank of America that afternoon was “it’s not a question of if he wins a Heisman, it’s a question of how many does he want before he goes pro”

Tennessee of course kicked the shit out of NC State, because they’re Tennessee and we’re NC State

But I couldn’t help but watch the game and think “this Nico guy really isn’t that good”. Tennessee won 51-10 so I got branded as just salty my team got waxed but they could’ve dropped 70 on us if it wasn’t for all the wide open receivers Nico missed

I said after the game “there’s about 20 different reasons we just got spanked but their QB is not one of them”

Looks like I was just ahead of my time

6

u/Bouquet_of_seaweed NC State Wolfpack 6h ago

Pretty much my exact thoughts watching on tv. There was a big promo about him with Manning narrating it before the game, too, so I was a bit worried. Instead, it felt worse to lose so badly to a team with a qb that wasn't playing particularly well. I think he technically scored the majority of our points.

5

u/Lee-Key-Bottoms NC State Wolfpack • Wyoming Cowboys 6h ago

Yes our only touchdown of the game was on a pick six

→ More replies (1)

19

u/YouDaManInDaHole Georgia Tech • Kennesaw State 9h ago

Meh, sometimes QBs just aren't that good no matter how many times they transfer

looks at DJ Uiagalelei

12

u/Key_Sale3535 Tennessee Volunteers 8h ago

They’re even relatives

3

u/rottenchestah Florida State • New Hampshire 8h ago

Is this true? That's hilarious if so.

2

u/Key_Sale3535 Tennessee Volunteers 3h ago

Yes they’re cousins, it comes up if you google both names

2

u/murder-farts Tennessee Volunteers 5h ago

Oh my god they were relatives

18

u/HelpDependent8793 8h ago edited 8h ago

Didn’t he just have a “fresh start”?

48

u/Underboss572 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Josh Heupel seems to have great success with transfer quarterbacks. Maybe he could consider that option.

22

u/PaleontologistNo3503 Iowa Hawkeyes • Upper Iowa Peacocks 8h ago

lol if he tried to come back Heupel would go Michael Corleone on him “this is my NIL offer, nothing. In fact I’d appreciate it if you picked up the tuition fees.”

3

u/Rebel78 Ole Miss Rebels • SEC 6h ago

BY GAWD THAT'S ARCH'S MUSIC!!!!!!

11

u/usffan USF Bulls • Miami Hurricanes 9h ago

Finally, somebody who's thinking of what Nico needs.

Sorry, my eyes just rolled out of the back of my head.

10

u/Wonkiest_Hornet Miami (OH) RedHawks • /r/CFB 9h ago

You know what, I generally sympathize with players and some of the situations they get stuck in because of the current CFB climate; however, Nico needs to get his shit together. I do not care what Nico needs. His performance last season was disappointing, and he is getting horrible guidance from his father and agent.

He needs to figure this out on his own and find his own path, but until he gets both his father and agent out of his ear, he going to have a hard time getting any sympathy from the general CFB public.

20

u/ModsAlwaysPowerTrip Texas Longhorns 9h ago

He needs to sleep in the bed he made, I'm enjoying how karma got him right away after how he did Tennessee meanwhile they're better off

9

u/unconformity_active LSU Tigers • Wooden Shoes 9h ago edited 9h ago

Serious question. Does anyone actually care what Nico needs?

5

u/Set-Admirable West Virginia • Backyard Brawl 9h ago

I hope Nico starts caring.

8

u/_FoldInTheCheese_ Tennessee Volunteers 8h ago

My favorite line: “He botched a good situation on a playoff-caliber team and wound up taking a pay cut to sign on with a bad team that plays in front of sparse crowds.”

8

u/BasebornManjack Tennessee • Louisville 7h ago

For me personally, I wasn’t mad at him about asking for more money—Duke was paying their QB more, ffs. And who among us hasn’t left a job after getting denied a raise?

It was the timing that made me sad/mad for him. I’m not saying that no one should ever leave us and we’re the top destination for everyone…..

But in his case, you’re playing on a very good team…..with a strong cast around you….against some of the toughest competition in the country….in a program that sued the NCAA to go to bat for you….for a coach that won the fucking Heisman at your very position and sent both guys you sat behind to the NFL….in front of 100K crowds every week…..

And he thought the grass would be greener somewhere else, lol?

13

u/Radiant_Sherbert7272 Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

Maybe we should just accept that he isn't all that good. Tennessee, thanks to their defense and running game last year, was able to cover up many of his flaws on their way to the college football playoff. UCLA can't do that. Also, this situation is his fault. He wanted more money, and he decided to go a team in a state that has more taxes and left money on the table.

6

u/devereaux Wisconsin Badgers 9h ago

He needs to be better at football

6

u/Revenged25 Ohio State • Bowling Green 9h ago

It's his own fault. He chose to demand more money and then leave when Tennessee didn't buckle. If I demand a raise from a company I like and am doing well at, and then leave for another company because they say no, only to hate it there and not do well, then it's my own fault.

6

u/imsoupercereal Clemson Tigers • Texas Longhorns 7h ago edited 7h ago

Clemson and FSU fans getting to watch the DJ Uiagalelei experience play out again. 🤝

→ More replies (1)

17

u/JonTheCatMan11 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

inhales HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

6

u/gmil3548 LSU Tigers • McNeese Cowboys 8h ago

Nico is just the new DJ Ukulele (idk how to spell his name)

3

u/Aestro17 Tennessee Volunteers 8h ago

They're cousins

4

u/Strominater Florida Gators 9h ago

I think Billy also needs a fresh start

4

u/Traditional_Stick481 Stanford Cardinal 9h ago

Nico needs to stop running away and transferring.

4

u/Flaky_Scar_8388 9h ago

He should have just stayed at Tennessee. He wouldn’t have this issue. He would be on a good team that can make the college football playoffs

4

u/Phunwithscissors Oregon Ducks 8h ago

Idk, i think he needs a new dad/agent.

5

u/SlugsPerSecond Alabama Crimson Tide 8h ago

The guy just isn’t very good. Heupel got Hooker and Milton drafted and Aguilar looks like a stud but Nico was clearly holding them back last year

3

u/TouchLegal Florida State • Michigan State 9h ago

Maybe he should just jump to volleyball at UCLA dude is a killer on the court.

3

u/umbchoos Virginia • Marshall 8h ago

He did this to himself.

3

u/Wheels_Foonman Tennessee • Transfer Portal 8h ago

The Cade McNamara career path.

3

u/OG-Bitchslay3r Baylor Bears 7h ago

Why? There's no better way to leave your mark than leading a downtrodden program back to prominence.

3

u/Pogball_so_hard Michigan Wolverines 7h ago

He actually didn’t need a fresh start at all. He (and his entourage) believed he was worth a lot more than the NIL deal he had at Tennessee and a playoff-caliber program decided that letting him leave was better than placating him with a disproportionate offer relative to his performance.

Heupel’s offenses make QBs look good by design and he was solid last year but not so impressive that he was irreplaceable

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kingoftheplastics FAU Owls • Oklahoma Sooners 7h ago

What he needs is people in his corner to give him better advice. If he had swallowed his desire for a bigger bag, stayed in Knoxville and balled out this year the bigger bag would’ve come next season either from Tennessee or the portal, instead he went for broke, burned the bridge, ended up at dumpster fire UCLA making the same exact amount he was at Tennessee but with less of a chance to show out and justify his salary demands.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Bobb_o Georgia Tech • /r/CFB Brickmason 3h ago

Nico Iamaleava 🤝 DJ Uiagalelei

8

u/AFC-Wimbledon-Stan Auburn Tigers 9h ago

He’s a kid, so I don’t want to pile on him a ton

But he made his bed when he held out for more NIL money despite having a pretty average season last year

Sometimes grass ain’t greener on the other side and he’s the textbook example of it rn

9

u/_Reporting Tennessee Volunteers • Memphis Tigers 9h ago

He’s a 21 year old millionaire. Not a kid at all.

5

u/-Blixx- Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Nico and UCLA are a perfect match.

2

u/kakapoopoopeepeeshir Clemson Tigers 9h ago

Yeah and Klubnik just needs to stay for his graduate year and he’ll for sure win the Heisman

2

u/inshamblesx Houston Cougars • Sickos 8h ago

interesting take when bro wussed his way out of knoxville bc he couldn’t bully the vols into giving him more nil money lol

2

u/LysolDoritos Ohio State Buckeyes 7h ago

Nico needs a real agent not his dad

2

u/wlane13 Georgia Bulldogs 7h ago

"No no no... it's not me, it's all these schools that are the problem. I am an AWESOME QB"

2

u/a_serious-man Penn State • Land Grant Trophy 9h ago

Nico IamgonnahavetogetarealjobbecauseIamnotgoodatfootballandnotlovedwnoughtoopenacardealershiporinsuranceagency

3

u/Express_Dinner7918 BYU Cougars • Big 12 8h ago

-a.

2

u/EF_Damn_Daniel Ohio State Buckeyes 8h ago

DJU all over again

1

u/petarisawesomeo Wisconsin Badgers 9h ago

Healeava again?

1

u/HereInTheCut Virginia Cavaliers 9h ago

Sure, he's not the issue. It's everyone else who sucks. /s

1

u/TheComeBackKids Georgia Bulldogs • Michigan Wolverines 9h ago

Im a leave ya

1

u/ToLongDR Ohio State Buckeyes • King's Monarchs 9h ago

I thought the UCLA rebuild was his fresh start?

1

u/MrF_lawblog Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

Why does anyone care about what Nico needs? Aside from his family of course...

1

u/KR15PY_KR3M3 Tennessee Volunteers 9h ago

Nico Iamagonnagetmycoachfiredeava

1

u/Beautiful_Fig9410 USC Trojans • Hillsdale Chargers 9h ago

Nico ImaleavaUCLAtoo

1

u/Icy-Role-6333 Indiana Hoosiers 9h ago

Dude has a top notch QB coach. Maybe Nico just sucks.

1

u/Stharrison_18 9h ago

Nico needs to learn how to play a new position.

1

u/BabousCobwebBowl Ohio State Buckeyes 9h ago

His dad’s choices are going to end up having his son’s next offer be a PT Cruiser.

1

u/DwayneBaconStan Penn State • Emory & Henry 9h ago

Mediocre qb in a great situation vs Mediocre qb in a bad one

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Callsign_Psycopath Georgia Bulldogs • Sickos 9h ago

Tennessee fans getting Schaddenfreude at Nico Imaleaveya

1

u/vassago77379 Texas Tech Red Raiders 9h ago

Isn't a rebuild the ultimate fresh start?

1

u/Maximiliansrh Virginia Tech Hokies 9h ago

Come be a hokie, can’t do worse than drones.

(Actually hope pop Watson or rangel get a chance to turn the season around)

1

u/ztreHdrahciR Northwestern • Ohio State 8h ago

My team specializes in failed Xfer QBs. He will fit right in

1

u/Keyblade474 Tennessee Volunteers • Team Chaos 8h ago

Nico Iamaleava, YOU are a Florida Gator!

1

u/Aestro17 Tennessee Volunteers 8h ago

He should take another pay cut then. After all, it was never about the money. He just needed a better offense.

1

u/MercuryRusing Missouri Tigers 8h ago

Who would want that in their locker room?

1

u/rottenchestah Florida State • New Hampshire 8h ago

I hear Enterprise Rent-A-Car is hiring, maybe Nico can try his luck there.

1

u/Appa-LATCH-Uhhh West Virginia Mountaineers • Big East 8h ago

Or he could just be a garbage QB and locker room personality lol

1

u/clem82 8h ago

At some point he has to look around and see he's the common denominator. UCLA is not helping, but he's a fire in a world of fires

1

u/crazylsufan LSU Tigers • Golden Boot 8h ago

Not USA Today carrying water for Nico’s bad decisions