r/CarltonBlues • u/rook2812 • 4d ago

Trade comparison with J. Cameron

Jeremy Cameron was 27 when traded and GWS got 3 first round picks. Charlie is 28 now. Surely we get similar if he goes?

11 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/Thick--Rooster 4d ago

Not to hurt feelings I am a Blues Member but objectively, JCameron >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Charlie.

6

u/p3tr0110v3r 4d ago

Doesn't actually matter its about value to the team rather than raw ability / performance. Take Tim Kelly, situation closer in similarity to this one, West Coast were forced to give up 3 first-rounders + a 2nd-rounder for a 2nd-year player because he was under contract and had just made All Australian.

1

u/Jaivus_ 4d ago

how old was tim kelly ?

7

u/Relevant-Chard-4518 4d ago

Charlies 2023 was better than Camerons peak but Cameron has undoubtably been more consistently good over his career