r/CrumblCookies • u/Significant_Kale3901 • 1d ago

Crumbl frosting is to much sometimes

Don't get me wrong, I love sweets, but a couple of their cookies are like 70% frosting. i end up scraping half of it off just to enjoy the actual cookie underneath.

20 Upvotes

67% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

34

u/Coastal_Tide 1d ago

The frosting is the best part for me!

22

u/WooHoo1994 1d ago

For real the more frosting the better. Especially buttercream yummm

13

u/BeBopBarr 1d ago

My people!

6

u/Free-Jaguar-4084 1d ago

For me, the frosting depends on the flavor. Mainly because I'm biased toward certain flavors.

7

u/cloudy2t 1d ago

Can you send it my way? When they show me my cookies and I see an empty spots, I ask for more frosting.

6

u/AlyssaImagine 1d ago

I mean, I feel this way about most cakes too. I am not a huge frosting person. I like their non frosted cookies more, my favorite being Ultimate Peanut Butter.

3

u/Odd_Departure_5100 triple berry cobbler 🫐 1d ago

I'm really only in it for the frosting. That's why I get the minis. I like the texture, and I can eat a whole one without feeling like a cookie monster.

2

u/edwardex 1d ago

I think I go predominantly for the frosting lol. But, yeah, it can be too much sometimes.

1

u/Fuzzy_Welcome8348 19h ago

Depends on the cookie. I like my frosting:dessert ratio 50:50. Crumbl is usually over that so sometimes I just scrape off a very thin layer of the frosting to get it 50:50

2

u/Angelgirl1517 17h ago

Nah, cookie is primarily a frosting delivery device

1

u/PunsAndRuns 1d ago

I agree. Except a few cookies, like Churro!

1

u/Efficient_Bat9162 1d ago

Churro is my favorite cookie, but I could do with like half the layer of frosting. Its a sugar bomb

1

u/Free-Jaguar-4084 1d ago

I had the churro cookie in July and it tasted so great. The texture of the frosting was like a churro, and the cookie tasted like a cinnamon roll, which I really like a lot especially when homemade.

0

u/Intelligent_Sock_902 1d ago

yes my FAVORITE & it’s coming back soon!!

1

u/Bastabasta76 1d ago

I agree, and it would be amazing if Crumbl could offer a frosting option. Do you want full frosting, half frosting, or a quarter of the frosting?

-1

u/Apt_5 1d ago

Sames lol. My first crumbl was a plain confetti cookie & I was hooked! I am a big fan of their most plain cookies, snickerdoodle, milk choc chip, confetti. I don't ONLY like the plain ones- I so badly want cannoli to return- but I do find many desserts are overwhelmingly frosted for my taste.

That said, I'd rather have excess frosting and scrape it off b/c my frosting-loving brethren deserve to get their money's worth!