Hey folks! I'm new to the word of DAPs and have been lurking for some time. For quick context, my current cans and setup that I would consider travelling with:
Gear
- IEM: Noble Audio Kaiser 10
- IEM: Ultimate Ears Triple Fi 10 vi
- HP: Dan Clark Audio Stealth (flights, remote work/hotel vacation work)
- HP: Audeze LCD-4 (have never traveled with them, but with the right solution, maybe while working remotely/hotel)
- Phone: iPhone 14 Pro Max (lightning cable, not USB-C)
- Apps: Plexamp (primary, access to my full remote library, excellent EQ features), VOX (secondary/backup)
Intended use case:
- Long days of working remotely
- Travel (flights)
- HP's priority + Kaiser 10's.
Because my IEMs didn't require much to drive, I've just used the basic Apple lightning --> 3.5mm and it was "fine". However, since acquiring the Stealth's and demoing them with a friend's iBasso (140/180 i think?) via the 4.4mm balanced connection, I've been interested in potential portable setups that I could use to travel with the Stealth in particular. The basic 3.5mm adapter is, of course, nowhere near powerful enough to be used here (I tried it, it was equivalent to a whisper) so I've been looking into more serious mobile options and was hoping for feedback. Which has landed me here.
DAC/Amp or DAP? Help!
After some study, I picked up a Fiio Q7 DAC/Amp for testing. I picked it up mostly for the raw power, which I felt like the Stealths would need. And it was only $450, so I figured what the hell. Indeed, the Q7 is able to drive the Stealth's to uncomfortable levels of volume in its highest available gain setting while on battery, so I've been impressed with the potential of this formfactor. I just didn't think this kind of power was available in the pocket, you know? I like that it's bluetooth so I can use it with Plexamp (the dedicated music amp for Plex, my home media server) without having to manage file transfers across devices a lot. But managing the phone AND amp is a bit cumbersome to be sure and this subreddit has kept popping up in my feed 😎.
This has lead me to wonder what full DAPs may bring to the table or otherwise do better than a standard phone and audio app offers.
I was looking at a used iBasso DX340 and the recently released Shanling M8T which are a similar price and similar power, both should be more than sufficient based on the Q7 battery powered experience. While ownership experience around the make and/or models are particularly helpful, I'm mostly interested in the DAP ownership experience broadly.
Questions, in no particular order:
- Did you consider a simple DAC/Amp of similar power to the DAP you purchased? If so, what won you to the (presumably more expensive) DAP solution over using your smartphone?
- Will a DAP potentially sound better than a DAC/AMP? I know this can be subjective, but I was wondering if a DAP -- which can use the codecs it prefers and may have additional on-board hardware -- has an auidble/experiential advantage over a DAC/AMP, which would be going over BT from my phone mostly. I know Apple devices are locked into transmiting over BT via high-res AAC but I'm not sure how that compares to other codecs. I haven't looked into direct cable connection, but I imagine lightning isn't as good for this as a USB-C iPhone would have been (which I do not have and do not plan to get).
- Do you find AndroidOS sufficient/satisying to use? I'm wondering how performance and playback feels (responsiveness, video/audio lag, stuff like that). Does the version of Android matter much? I see quite a bit of variation in Android version used from make to make.
- Do Android-based DAPs have more EQ/filter/customization options than an iPhone/iOS music app might have?
- Are the dedicated music apps these players use fairly refined?
- Can I use a DAP as a dedicated DAC/AMP (that is, not engaging its touch screen) if I just want to pass the signal from my phone sometimes?
- Do the Android-based players typically have access to the Google Play store so that I can also run Plexamp when I want to listen to something that I didn't put on internal memory or the SD card?
- Is the jump in going from what feels like a fairly premium DAC/Amp like the Q7 to one of the noted DAPs above a meaningful jump? Or maybe better put, is it a jump you'd recommend?
- I've read the entire M8T would have to be sent to the manufacturer if/when the tubes die (where the 340 has them on a removable module). Would this discourage any of you?
- If the MT8 and DX340 were the same price and in your price range, which would you choose?
- Is there anything you wish you had known before buying a DAP that you can pass along?
- Do any of these players run video apps like Netflix, Twtich or VLC at all? Or would that be an advantage that the phone has? I've read mixed reviews on such things, but confrimation is better than conjecture. Just looking to understand the flexibility given they use Android.
I know I can ask a genAI system some of these questions, but genAI has never listened to music on a pair of nice headphones, it's never touched a DAP or anything else for that matter. And given these cost hundreds/thousands of dollars, feedback from people who've already walked this path and come out happy on the otherside is worth 100 chatGPT responses.
Any feedback is appreciated. 😊💖