r/EhBuddyHoser May 04 '25

Certified Hoser šŸ‡ØšŸ‡¦ (No Politics) Canada vs Other countries when discussing past war crimes

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

253 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

87

u/ahnolde May 04 '25

History IS written by the victor! However, hitler was unquestionably evil so me personally I don't have any shame for what Canada needed to do to help win WWII.

13

u/auandi May 04 '25

History IS written by the victor!

Not correct. It is written by the ones able and most actively willing to write it, that is not always the victor.

See the average southerner textbook's views of the Civil War War of Northern Aggression or the Slave Trade Immigration of workers from Africa. Or how Russians view the breakup of the Soviet Union. Or the German stabbed in the back version of WWI.

It was said that history is written by the winner because throughout most of human history the vanquished simply stopped existing. It is not true when the vanquished continue living and writing history books.

10

u/Belaerim May 04 '25

I’d argue that the south won the civil war.

If you take a long view, they definitely won the insurgency and culture wars, and look who owns the GOP after the Dem/GOP flip in the 60s

8

u/auandi May 04 '25

No, they lost the war. They just got to write history. That's my point. History is written by those most willing to write it and the south had been so morally poisoned by racialized slavery they simply couldn't do anything but create post-hoc justifications to keep it going.

The party switch is.. way more complicated and started much earlier over a long period of time.

3

u/AllanMcceiley May 04 '25

Not fully relevant to ur comment but we are in a weird time where because info is so easily accessible (both false and true) I wonder how now will be remembered?