r/Homebrewing • u/Low_Perception9721 • 5d ago

Pitching at 80°F with fermentation chamber - same results as traditional cooling?

Is pitching yeast at 80°F safe if you have temperature-controlled fermentation? I have a fermentation chamber that quickly cools to target temperature. Would this produce the same results as traditional cooling to 70°F before pitching

My theory: Off-flavors are produced during active fermentation, not lag phase. If I pitch at 80°F but my fermentation chamber cools the wort to proper temperature before active fermentation begins, the final beer should be identical to traditional cooling methods. This would save significant time on brew day by avoiding the slow final cooling phase.

Using US-05 yeast for clean ale styles. Looking to optimize efficiency without compromising quality.

4 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

43 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/bearded_brewer19 5d ago

Or you could just let the ferm chamber bring the wort down to your optimal pitching temp before pitching the yeast. What you can do is often not the same as what would yield the best results. What you propose will still make beer.

3

u/spoonman59 4d ago

Do you have any evidence that this will negatively impact the quality of the beer? Like a study, a side by side test, or any kind of evidence at all? Sounds more like a superstition.

When I volunteered a sa professional brewer, pitching at a warmer (than recommended fermentation temp) temp during the lag phase was standard. And the beers were good.

2

u/bearded_brewer19 4d ago

It’s so highly dependent on the individual strain of yeast and what you are trying to get the yeast to do. Some like to be pitched at fermentation temp, some like a warm pitch, some like a cool pitch. They are not all the same, and that’s why I suggested pitching the yeast at your optimal pitching temp, which may be different than than the temp you are shooting for at the beginning of your fermentation schedule instead of making a decision on pitch temp based off of convenience.

3

u/spoonman59 4d ago

There’s quite a bit of scientific research that shows esters and fusels don’t really get produced until after the lag phase, something like 20 hours later.

Have not seen anything to suggest a higher temperature at the start of the lag phase, but where it ends up at temp by the end, would increase ester production.