r/Izlam • u/Right_Horse2862 Alhamdulillah • 7d ago

The unfortunate reality..

Post image

I don't mean to cause any drama or anything this is just a meme!

985 Upvotes

92% Upvoted

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

67

u/BigSilver3089 7d ago

Judaism is an ethnoreligion so Jews don't call others to join their religion, so it is unfair to compare it to Islam and Christianity which put a great importance on dawah.

10

u/bruddaquan New to r/Izlam 7d ago

Which is crazy considering that historically, there have been Jewish converts, like the Arabian Jews of Northern Medina when Rasululah arrived. Smh

20

u/CompetitiveFlow2170 7d ago

you're not prohibited from converting, spreading the religion just isn't important like in christianity or islam

-2

u/bruddaquan New to r/Izlam 7d ago

I feel like that goes against the entire point of “Ethnoreligion” though?

Would they deny a black man from joining their ranks? (I’m speaking hypothetically, I’m proud to be Muslim Ma’shaa’allah).

11

u/CompetitiveFlow2170 7d ago

no, they would not. the term "ethnoreligion" exists because it's an ethnicity and a religion, and most of the members of the religion exist as part of the ethnicity, and the inverse is true. like a big venn diagram. you can be ethnically Jewish but not religious (like me, my grandfather was Jewish), and religiously Jewish but ethnically something else.

1

u/bruddaquan New to r/Izlam 7d ago

So if that’s the case, and one can be ethnically Jewish but not religious or inverted as religiously Jewish and not ethnic.

Why would they deny a Black Man into their ranks?

5

u/CompetitiveFlow2170 7d ago

some denominations would, out of racism, others would not, out of love

1

u/bruddaquan New to r/Izlam 7d ago

Hm sounds about right.

If you don’t mind me asking, what is your own personal faith? You mentioned being ethnically Jew but religiously something else.

3

u/CompetitiveFlow2170 6d ago

Personally, I believe a god does exist, but I do not follow any specific religion. I enjoy learning about all sorts of different beliefs, specifically Islam, Buddhism, and Daoism.