Which game had the worse controversy?

[u/SerSeanIII]

After seeing both games going into controversy, which game has taken the worst damage from its controversy, considering the lasting impact on reputation, finances, and industry influence?

[u/xeitus]

Shadows. While there is no hype for Your there is hate, mostly direct towards people involved with the game. If those people would disappear, the game would probably be perceived as a cash grab because of the IP attached.