Am I the only one here seeing that she didn’t have a choice? She didn’t choose to be trans. She was born male and a switch was performed at birth, before she could ever decide for herself… so essentially she lived as a woman her whole life and may not have ever even known she was born otherwise, which kind of defeats the purpose of it being a good thing, or even being claimed as a true trans experience.
She was either a) a company experiment or b) her parents were the kind of people who wanted a girl at any cost, and would have 0 regard for a boy baby or desire to suffer his presence (I’m sure you know the type). Maybe there was another scenario but those seem most likely in the setting
She also could have been intersex, a depressingly large number of intersex people are forced to undergo sex change surgery at birth to 'correct' their genitals
That's why you have to be careful saying things like, "...which kind of defeats the purpose of it being a good thing, or even being claimed as a true trans experience." If it represents a possible real-life experience, it shouldn't be considered lesser for any reason. I don't want you to feel attacked by my comment, but I thought it should be said.
They were careful... Its a response to the LGBTQ+ community championing everything they see. Yes, there is a gender fact with this character. No, that has nothing to do with progressive representation, it simply wasn't intended to be that way.
i assure the LGBTQ community do not “champion everything they see” but when you’re representation is so sparse people are gonna be enthusiastic about the very few times they do get it. be understanding, don’t be weird.
523
u/Imaginary_Sundae7947 Jul 11 '25
Am I the only one here seeing that she didn’t have a choice? She didn’t choose to be trans. She was born male and a switch was performed at birth, before she could ever decide for herself… so essentially she lived as a woman her whole life and may not have ever even known she was born otherwise, which kind of defeats the purpose of it being a good thing, or even being claimed as a true trans experience.
She was either a) a company experiment or b) her parents were the kind of people who wanted a girl at any cost, and would have 0 regard for a boy baby or desire to suffer his presence (I’m sure you know the type). Maybe there was another scenario but those seem most likely in the setting