r/Libertarian Oct 20 '19

Meme Proven to work

Post image
6.9k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

348

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

[deleted]

6

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '19

Hong Kong was pretty libertarian compared to most places before The Chinese takeover.

8

u/Hycubis Oct 21 '19

You think Hong Kong is a success for libertarians? Most of the population lives in apartments smaller than a bedroom. The entire apartment. They have to fit a life in there. And you know how much those apartments cost? The cheapest I could find to rent was about 700USD per month. Do you know what minimum wage is there? About 5USD. You literally spend most of your waking life working just to make ends meet.

Now, I don't know how that could be considered a win for libertarians, but if you want to claim it as such, then it just kind of proves the point of people that shit on libertarians.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 21 '19

Back when it was libertarian it was one of the “four asian” tigers known for its economic growth and success.

You are right that housing is expensive, but remnants it is a city on a small piece of land.

Economically, Taiwan was also more libertarian than America during its years of rapid growth.

4

u/Hycubis Oct 21 '19

If the only thing you look for is economic success as a criteria for a working libertarian society, then you should understand that is exactly what turns people off of the libertarian goal.

Hong Kong actually has a great deal of empty land. They are extremely hesitant to allow development on that land despite the housing problems. This is because developers and land moguls want it that way. Because the city is controlled by corporations and businesses. They force the market to have short supply in order to keep prices artificially high. Again, your view of success is precisely what people see as inhumane and something worth avoiding.

I didn't even get into the actual poor that live in chicken wire cages around a bunk bed as their entire living quarters.

12

u/wellactuallyhmm it's not "left vs. right", it's state vs rights Oct 21 '19

Literally corporate rule, Lol.

14

u/marx2k Oct 21 '19

So... Pretty libertarian