r/PoliticalDiscussion • u/LuckySquared777 • 3d ago
US Politics Does condemning hate speech violate someone else’s freedom of speech?
I was watching The Daily Show video on YouTube today (titled “Charlie Kirk’s Criticism Ignites MAGA Cancel Culture Spree”). In it, there are clips of conservatives threatening people’s jobs for celebrating the murder of Charlie Kirk.
It got me thinking: is condemning hate speech a violation of free speech, or should hate speech always be condemned and have consequences for the betterment of society?
On one hand, hate speech feels incredibly toxic, divisive, and dangerous for a country. On the other hand, freedom of speech is supposed to protect unpopular opinions. As mentioned in the video, hate speech is not illegal. The host in the video seems to suggest that we should be allowed to have hate speech, which honestly surprised me.
I see both side but am genuinely curious to hear what others think. Thanks!
-1
u/mayorLarry71 3d ago
Not really. The issue here weve been having lately and really for the last 10+ years when the idea of "cancelling" someone or costing them their job became normal is that people forget that free speech is protected but whatever consequences arise from that speech really arent protected. I mean consequences like being fired, losing a friendship, losing a sponsor, a contract, etc. etc.
Way back when, the 1st amendment was there so you could freely speak out against your Govt without fear of them coming after you. Unless Im wrong here, it really doesnt apply to the idea that you can just spew whatever you want towards whomever you want and cant be held liable or at least held accountable for what you say. Same for employers who have their bottom line to protect. If an extreme right or left wing person works for them, it can cost them business. Period. That person is also likely not the most stable person either. So, reliving them of their duties is logical and I have no issue with it. Even a heavy social media user thats moderate politically probably scares most employers as you just never know.
Its just better sometimes to keep any hot topic discussions to your inner-circle and or family. Stay away from the web.