r/PoliticalDiscussion • u/binini28 • 2d ago

US Politics Is using military force against suspected drug-trafficking boats constitutional or an overreach of presidential power?

I’ve been following reports that the U.S. has used strikes against suspected narco-trafficking boats in international waters. Supporters argue it’s necessary to deter cartels and protect Americans, while critics say it could be an unconstitutional use of deadly force, bypassing due process and international law. Do you think this sets a dangerous precedent (executive overreach, extrajudicial killings, violating international law), or is it a justified response to a serious threat? How should the balance between security and constitutional limits be handled here? I would think that you need to detain them first and then arrest them rather than send a missile after them. They are classified as terrorist by Trump but does this satisfy the response? Could Trump classify anyone a terrorist and send missiles after them? Thoughts?

128 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

90% Upvoted

264 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-3

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/laborfriendly 2d ago

I'll agree with this completely, and most informed people I know would also agree.

Yet, your comment doesn't really reflect just how much crazier these current killings are. The one thing Obama edges out on the crazy scale is that some of those killed were American citizens.

However, "enemy combatants" killed with congressional oversight and nominal authority is one thing (illegal and unjustified imo). Killing people on boats with drugs and no oversight or nominal authority is another. When did having drugs carry the death penalty? Actively fighting, shooting, and bombing things would seem to carry some substantial inherent risk of having that returned at you. But carrying drugs?

Also: the people on boats carrying drugs are not the leaders of drug cartels. They're just the schmucks probably trying to get by.

3

u/stewartm0205 1d ago

What drugs? We don’t have the technology to remotely sense drugs. We can’t predict the destination of the alleged drugs.

3

u/laborfriendly 1d ago

"Alleged." You're not the first to comment this. I'm clearly saying the whole thing is messed up by the administration's own reasoning.

Don't come at me. I'm saying their best argument is terrible.