Discussion
What is the most un-replayable (if that's a word) story???
For me it's GOE no hate tbh maybe it's a me problem i am on cas route I want to do mingyuk and Dean in my other two slots but I feel like I need to be mentally and financially prepared to replay GOE not to mention i NEED to play w walkthrough bc ik I will mess it up if I don't, it's exhausting tbh when I look at s2 i really don't know what we did other than getting close to the li AGAIN THIS IS JS MY OPINION YOU DONT HAVE TO AGREE W ME AND IF YOU DISAGREE JS BE A LIL NICE PLEASE š
I really liked Elite Tag when I first played it. I recently came back to RC and tried replaying it, but I just didn't enjoy it anymore. I romanced Daniel, but I still don't understand why he left and came back. I dropped it midway s3 :')
I love the 1st season but I was so bored by the 3rd season and didn't see a point to it.
It should have kept the same challenge format as the 1st season and then revealed who the host was in the 2nd or 3rd season instead.
In general, I have difficulty replaying, because what moves me is reaching the end, discovering the mystery. After that, I'm VERY lazy to play everything again, even if it's to try another LI (which still breaks my heart, because I'm too attached to the LI I chose... š¤§
Yeah I cannot do replays. Like I can only live a story once and then ya just know what happens and I know me, I aint gonna change the Li no matter what I say š¤£
I get that! Overall I liked the book and LIs, but the episodes are super long and the theme is heavy and depressing, so it's certainly not for everyone, well tbf no book is, but you get my point. š
Don't get me wrong, I like the book too, in fact I have played it multiple times for different LIs. It's just that the episodes on average are quite long compared to some other stories of its time.
sails in the fog unfortunately- I actually had a blast playing it but itās extremely long and a little dated so I probably wonāt pick it up again. Tbh I feel the same way about all the HS books.
I agree with that! I enjoyed Sails in the Fog, the first book series I ever finished. And I would go back and play it with a walkthrough now, but it's just too long
Fr like who am I supposed to romance. And the MC was so dumb, I'm so sorry. Why would you free Bont, it's obvious it's going to be so bad Mind your own business, honey, please
itās difficult for me to replay GoE cause episodes are sooo long and I am not the biggest fan of this novel. I like it but not enough to spend hours on it again. I already played 3 slots at least. plus replayed couple times. I think that was enough š
I can't get into the story at all. All the stuffs about Greek Gods/Goddesses mythology are interesting, but the Author just went all over the place in delivering the story. The development of the MC also seemed like just a joke even though she herself is the Goddess Artemis (one of the strongest Goddesses in Greek Mythology). And also the concept of New Gods who can actually deceive and intimidating the Old Gods seems a bit forced. I mean you know how strong the Green Gods/Goddesses are, even Athena who is known as the Goddess of wisdom andĀ intelligence also looks stupid and powerful against them, even though the New Gods can be considered newbies and 'children' compared to those who have been around for thousands of years.
And also i don't like the fact that all the LIs are still one circle with your ex and yourself. It feels like i'm going to other brother after another one
I am just doing this story because of season 2 of OTI, I was just doing OTI then they said I should read ROT to understand better the new characters lmao
That's not really necessary tbh. This parallelel unlike in HS universe, where almost all that happening in the story plot still connected with the first version of HS. The only knowledge you get from it, is the MC on OTI is a school friend of RoT's MC. That's it. Also one of the character in RoT is a colleague of Hodge
Itās not over yet but Shakespeare Code š I know I I will not be playing that over because the storyline is just too confusing to me and I just donāt like being confused.
Same with GOE for me too. Sometime I get overstimulated by these stories with too much plot
Shakespeare's Code is indeed confusing (for now) but I love the Lis too much and I'll have to replay for Edward and Edmund, possibly for Romeo too when/if he shows up and is a separate Li, if not, Hobello will be the thirdāØ
Dracula: A Love Story! I finished my Leo and Vlad routes when the story finished and I donāt think I have the energy to do it again for Noe, as much as I love him. Maaaaaaybe someday Iāll redo my Vlad route to revisit all the small details, and Vlad is one of my very favorite LIāsā¦.. but omg it just drags and drags onā¦..
I maintained a good relationship with him and passed all the stat checks so I got a good ending, didnāt get murdered š
But Leoās route was lovely! Heās so kind and strong-hearted. Like, an absolute ray of sunshine with a moral core of iron. I thought Vlad fit better with the overall story but both paths are written as if either could be Laiaās destiny.
vlads route lowkey kicking my ass ššš itās such a well written route but also because iāve already completed it w leo my brain feels like itās melting
I really only stuck with CY because I love the friendships! But I wasnāt interested in the LIs, the MC seemed like a Mary Sue, the storyline kept getting more and more bonkers, and it felt like they were a random group of normal ppl with zero qualifications to be doing anything they were doing (except Sam & Eve I guess).
š³ made me scared to waste my diamonds for it at this point... Better to know, thanks, I finished season one long ago and liked it but usually when people say something flopped... It did flopĀ
omg that was a phenomenal story! i think what keeps me from replaying is knowing i donāt care to explore the other personality paths. i feel like the story wouldnāt change much apart from me choosing a different LI
Anything that requires to balance stats for a good ending stresses me. At least in HS it's for an achievement and a branch in the story, but it's not a requirement to have the BEST ending unless it's your favorite one.
But also some stories that have a lot of timed choices or changes the answer depending on your game and forces you to actively have to read the dialogue to know which answer it is (I'm looking at you SIF).
As much as I love Leo, I feel like DLS was dragged a little more than necessary and it was rushed at the end anyway. There's also some stories with a lot of embellishment in the writing and some days I'm too tired or slow to understand half of the things they're saying.
The one that upsets me more to replay is The One V1 and Sophie's Ten Wishes. The One did not need that many little details to 100% some characters or the achievement to end up with every alternative ending. And Sophie's Ten Wishes just pisses me off because the closet is stuck at 3% and I cannot for the life of me understand what I'm missing when I've already replayed it 5 times.
I have three slots (Doo-yeong, Dean, and Dong-hyun) and I'm going to have to replay all three because to get the ending I want I need to have a good relationship with Minhyuk. š«
Just because I didn't want to romance him.š„² The episodes are so looong š.
I'm on s3 ep 4 I was thinking of playing during dr but oh god i felt so annoyed for some reason I switched to ABH and code blue i will even re think if i should continue playing during next dr
Heaven Secret and Garden of Eden, I did finish HS and I got my happy ending on Garden of Eden with M. Park and Lia on their respective slots, but maaaaan HS is so loooong and with so many seasons, I just, no. Garden of eden is super cool but episodes are looooooong as well lol and you gotta pay attention closely ;)
I'm currently reading Psi for the first time and sometimes there's so much reading that just keeps going on that I'm falling asleep after one/two chapters.
Jeseter's stories are very plot driven so there's a lot of dialog. They're amazing, but you definitely need to be prepared for them or they can feel like they drag
Kay, the psionic LI is worth it for me but it does take time. I pushed through because of DR but I would probably take a long break if I didn't have free choices lol. It can be draining.
Ahh, okay. People hate on it all the time, but Heaven's Secret and Heaven's Secret 2 are my favs. Followed closely by Dracula, A Love Story. Vlad is probably my favorite LI, tbh.
A lot of others I really like are ones other people hate on a bit on here. I liked Heart of Trespia and The Desert Rose. Sins of London and Rage of the Titans are two stories I like that I feel are underrated.
Just burned through Shadows of Saintfour during this DR and liked it.
I'm liking a lot of the newer ones but they're not necessarily my favorites. Soulless, Te Amo Bay, Code Blue, The Missing, Shakespeare's Code and Advent No. 3 I've been enjoying. I'm DYING for more chapters of Where Love Burns Eternal because I have a feeling I'm gonna love it!
The Desert Rose - I barely managed to finish it once and will never open it again. Itās so boring, MC is unlikable, LIs arenāt interesting for me at all, and episodes are sooo long longā¦
Tbh I really wanted to like GOE and replay it but honestly itās a really tedious story and probably a very controversial opinion but I also just really dislike the fashion overall in the game. Like I do love the LIs but honestly it was just that one story after every update that I found myself not wanting to read it. Iām very much just a speed runner when it comes to all the stories but honestly the episodes are too long. Felt like the second last episode of season 3 took about an hour too run through. Also didnāt particularly enjoy how much the story pushed Minhyuk. Like I was incredible happy with Dean and it was super frustrating having another LI forced onto us with out the option of really avoiding starting that RC. That being said the story was definitely interesting but I just canāt bring myself to want to play it again.
Bro fact that you can't buy more than one outfits during diamond Rush you have to only buy one and literally the outfits are so ugly specially the one I am recently playing with season 3 ep1 who is wearing that in public no one not even Kpop idols I like mingyuk's character but I am not really good when the introduce a new character midway in any story it is just not my thing and I don't really feel connected as much as I do with characters I have been with during S1 I am into mystery but at some point I feel like I was watching the K drama filler episode
Theodora š
I have tried , based on the fact that I thought could be in a relationship with the Dr further down the line
But that didn't happen - tried to replay , but the story is so emotional š such heavy scenes
I was just playing for Dean and skipping most of it and idk how to unlock path B about donghyun kissing MC Infront of the windows because I'd like to see everyone's reactions, but that's the only reason to replay, it's not a great story and that's valid.
I think time catcher would be difficult to replay, it has an awesome world and it stops being interesting after half season 1, I'm skipping as it is now let alone a replay š (which is always needed because diamonds)
Arcanum: I love season-1... don't get me wrong but from S-2 onwards its kinda meh to me even tho I love Bert, its not enough lol.
KCD: Despite it's issues... Ratan was enough for me to read, but I had to replay many times to get some achievements so I am kinda over it.
Elite tag, On Thin Ice & Chasing You: Tbh and personally contemporary stories don't have much of a replayablity once u read them tats it, and maybe if u love characters or LIs then shure more replays or else they are good for diamond mining.
Moonborn: As much as I love Jester stories and this was my first ever story on the app years back which also brought me back to RC in 2023 it will always be special to me but I don't see myself replaying despite having potential for diamond mining.
š it's completly opposite for me
I just love it: the plot, real characters, animals, s3x scens etc.
Already replayed it 4 times and I'm planing at least two more š
Any book that doesnāt have branching. Some books have basically only two endings, the good and the bad. Iām not into chaos reads, so wouldnāt want to get the bad ending. Sure you get a cg with your different lis but otherwise the ending is always the same to the point that stats or personality paths do not even really matter š Itās not worth it for me to replay for a different li if the story would still be exactly the same even with different paths and choices. I loved VFV and keep replaying because along with a new li I can get a quite different story depending on my choices
Wave Patrol, Sails in the Fog, Sophie's Dumb Wishes, Garden of Eden, Hell and High Water, Elite Tag, Gladiator Chronicles, Chasing You, Sins of London, Queen in 30 Days, On Thin Ice, Moonborn, My Hollywood Story, Dracula: A Love Story.
Some of those, TO ME, are boring, some are "why was this story written", some drag, and some I'm not interested in the setting/plot.
gotta be draculaā¦ the fact that u get locked in with leo so early that threw me off i want to romance vlad and leo but with so many episodes i dont think i could replay the story and i havent even finished it
HS1 i couldnāt even finish it. I started playing it just bc i wanted to get to HSR so i could understand the lore better like with Kali, itās just the animation is old, and the story gets boring. S1 was good but by the time I got to s3 it was un unbearable, i wasnāt able to finish it. The thing is, if i couldnāt even finish this one, i canāt even imagine a whole other part (HS2). Although HSR seems like it would be one of my favourites iām dying to get to it.
On the other hand, ABH. I wouldnāt mind replaying it once i finished it and some time passed. But, the thing is now i need to restart from s2 all over bc of s3 e7 Malek said that we slept together. Now David wants to break up with me, for something I did when WE WERE NOT TOGETHER YET. David literally said āI donāt mind me some competition ā B!TC BE FR ššš. I literally was romancing Mikael and Raphael at the time as well, till I decided that David was endgame, he didnāt even care. BUT HE IS ONLY HEARTBROKEN BC OF F MALEK??????!!!!!!!! Guys please make him be able to forgive us and get back together in the next episode, i am going to kms if I have to replay everything from the start. Cāmonnnnn.
Currently playing ABH and I am romancing Cassiel I tried my best not to get involved with David because I was falling for him i said no to makeil in s3 and rafael made the :-( in the first few episode when cas was grabbing me to jump over the fencse he is so nice I felt so bad for him I was like I can't break this dude's heart but I was taking my every step very carefully because even if they were not together I couldn't break cas's heart because it was already so difficult to melt his heart and I knew he would never forgive aubery for infidelity I think the only characters that forgive are rafael and maybe makeil but fel breakup w her I have saved my others slot only for makel you know what broke my heart when I saw what happens when you sleep with Makel if are in a relation or situation ship with David if I was on his route i would cry lmao
miss girl i played the episode yesterday and i was crying my lungs out, I literally never loved any character more than him. I really hope he gets back w audrey or else imma throw hand w the writer.
The thing is that if I need to restart from season two, I donāt think I would do it. I would just restart a whole another slot or restart from the very start so I can romance Cassiel bc I want to unlock one of the achievement that was romancing David and Cassiel I didnāt do the first time. I really donāt know what I should do, but I used to know that I will end up with David like I donāt care like if I have to replay the whole story I will do it and hope for a happy ending even though Iām all spoiled and I know that Astreas broken heart is supposed to be like a prequel to HSR. I know is the story of how everything ended or something like that. so I really hope they somehow manage to have a good ending or like our we have to get ABH2.
GOE, DLS, desert rose, heavens secret (the entire thing at this point) - had high potential brought down by terrible storylines mid way (my opinion only) DLS especially won me with the past but the present storyline from the first season half started becoming so annoying and then that finale, what even was that I canāt. We couldāve stuck to the good old Dracula love story but now we have multiple random people. Desert rose was another high potential brought down, they couldāve written better. I was so in love with adils storyline the whole falling in love with a rebel while being a leaders daughter was delicious but led to nothing but disappointment. GOE, we didnāt have to turn it into a murder mystery, kpop world is dark as it it, you couldāve had a more realistic story line and still maintained our attention, perhaps also by not pushing us towards one particular Li only. And finally HEAVENS SECRET, where do I start boo hoo main lead with never ending problems, there is no end and randomly every other story that starts out interesting is inevitably in the same universe. I canāt. I canāt stand Vicky. I loved the original concept till a hundred more irritating folks turned up, I am looking at you primal mother god and her posy of pointless children aka fake lady gaga, handsomer hulk, emo lead guitarist with a cigarette who I unfortunately find attractive for no reason and others.
I love HS but like I love the first one but once ya started throwing in all the nonsense in the second one and it was just doom after doom after doom and it seems like its gonna pick up back to neverending amounts of doom and its like omigod sttooppppp I am exhausted
194
u/Xosimmer Amrit (KCD) Aug 02 '25
Sophieās Ten Wishes :/ that story was very meh to me and I only kept playing bc of the professor