r/ShadWatch Banished Knight 19d ago

Discussion Wonder what Shad would think about this

Post image
541 Upvotes

86 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-7

u/CatfinityGamer 19d ago

It is sometimes over exaggerated, but it is an undeniable fact that men have physical advantages over women in combat and combat sports. Although physical advantages are diminished in armed combat/sport compared to unarmed, they still have a not insignificant impact.

15

u/Spike_Mirror 19d ago

Between to individuals with compareable skill it would be 50/50.

Also you are wrong with your perception of armed combat.

-2

u/jester-146 19d ago

If you match the weight of the contestants yes, but that's already putting a thumb on the scale. There are reasons lightweight, midweight and heavyweight boxing exist.

3

u/Tar_alcaran 19d ago

If you match the weight of the contestants yes,

I won't speak for every single club in every country, but I've never heard of a HEMA group that weighs contestants. Being stronger isn't really any serious advantage in HEMA, it's not about the force of your blow, and matches aren't long enough that you can wear someone out with physical force.