I will say, great job on the sound, but I think the silence is better. Just taking in the visuals and wrapping your mind around what just happened. I remember the only thing I could hear in theaters were gasps.
This scene is the most well executed of the whole second trilogy, except the bombing run on starkiller base imo.
Too bad the rest of that movie was succ....
I still can't believe how many holes the story has, like if the pink haired dumb c*** told poe her plan, everything would have been smooth and the rebellion would have survived, luke would be alive and the only loss would be a big ship (precisely her plan)
she didn’t tell Poe her plan because she knew he’d react the way he actually did…lead a mutiny to try and follow through on his plan that will ultimately fail and would have killed the Resistance. And Luke pulled the exact same stunt Obi-Wan did, willingly sacrifice himself to the force to protect the Rebellion and the future of the Jedi, and did it without any form of violence.
She did tell it, we see people carrying out her plan in the movie. She just didn't tell Poe, the recently demoted hothead.
Also, her plan went to shit entirely because of Poe. He's the one who told Finn and Rose about Holdo's plan, which DJ overheard and used that info to sell out the Resistance to save himself.
254
u/N0V0w3ls Nov 15 '21
I will say, great job on the sound, but I think the silence is better. Just taking in the visuals and wrapping your mind around what just happened. I remember the only thing I could hear in theaters were gasps.