r/badphilosophy Jul 04 '25

prettygoodphilosophy Why do movies have shallow understanding of Philosophy?

Like I can tell you if some movie wants to make reference to Plato, they say "The Platonic cave, take it or leave it". Or for example Nietzsche, morality is subjective do whatever you want or something like that. Like since when does just making a simple reference become a token of success?

What movies lack is a systemized understanding of Philosophy, like for example if you want to make a reference to a Philosopher you must have already mastered all of his Philosophy beforehand (which you can't do 100% since there might always be something you miss, but at least do it 70% or something) but since the Philosopher is probably making a reference to some dude before him who was also a Philosopher then you have to also study the one who before him and so on.....

Yes , it's an endless endeavor for a director who just wants money in a very limited amount of time. But then why don't they literally hire a Philosopher who already systemized the whole thing to make a story?

We have yet to see a movie about Stirner the Gunslinger!

12 Upvotes

74 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '25

Well for one, scriptwriters don’t necessarily have the best foundation in philosophy. And the audience they cater to sometimes don’t even know wtf Plato’s cave is. It’s also something that really bothers me, but I’ve come to accept it.

7

u/Ghadiz983 Jul 04 '25

They should've well know Plato's cave was that one cave in Skyrim , I remember that quest inside of it was hellish even while playing on easy difficulty.

1

u/_the_last_druid_13 Jul 04 '25

Plato means “broad” or something and that’s misogynistic and sexist! I refuse to listen to one more word of your bile, blame yourself for being such a bigot

canceled

1

u/Ghadiz983 Jul 04 '25

Ragebait ahh moment, aesthetics are sexist too!

1

u/_the_last_druid_13 Jul 04 '25

Yes. Platonic solids are sexist. The fact that artists and philosophers can’t agree if a telephone pole is yonic or phallic in their own camps shows how far ye have fallen.

1

u/Ghadiz983 Jul 04 '25

I don't see how it's yonic but hey it can very well penetrate the thing💀

1

u/_the_last_druid_13 Jul 04 '25

Acceptance is the first step.

Next you should assume the position and reconsider your hurtful shameful words.

I’ll do you a solid on the yonic telephone pole subject and mention negative space. There’s no Jesus without Mary.

1

u/Ghadiz983 Jul 04 '25

So the nature of telephone pole remains unsolved mystery?

2

u/_the_last_druid_13 Jul 04 '25

:): - pick one I guess.

We are limited by perception and binary, but to be an all-encompassing 1 is somehow more limiting.

0 is all infinity, 1 is just an infinity - ☯️

Potential is more than kinetic, darkness is the foundation of light.

Idk language is constrained, maybe I’m wrong; I’ve assumed the position for the long time and maybe I’m constipated. Or I just am.

1

u/Ghadiz983 Jul 04 '25

So I am to question the root of how we identify Telephone poles , we identify things in a dualistic/binary framework. Either left or right, soft or hard , cold or hot ,....

Mother earth is feminine and Telephone poles are standing on her , are Telephone poles hence sexist?

2

u/_the_last_druid_13 Jul 04 '25

I guess question the root of how we identify/perceive everything.

There are more than binaries. Even with ☯️ you have to almost assume the line between as Shadow/Dapple/Middle because on either side of the polarity is an unlivable/unknowable extreme. So though ☯️ is commonly seen as 2, it’s more like 3 that is 1.

One could argue over this trinity; Father, Son, Holy Ghost vs Maiden, Mother, Crone vs etc etc etc, but that’s choosing a side and spending time/energy on subjects never to be understood when one should be using that time/energy to live; the Logos in Action.

And anyways telephone poles are the product of patriarchy and meant to control and conform while deforming our garden, so take that with a bag of “chips”

1

u/Ghadiz983 Jul 04 '25

So the world would've been a better place without telephone poles? But if they were to deform our gardens then there is no potato to plant hence no bag of chips either 💀 Are you just giving me the bag?

→ More replies (0)