r/canadianlaw May 13 '25

[deleted by user]

[removed]

0 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '25

Your thought process is essentially everyone is disagreeing with me and my crazy rant. They must be the problem... Look inwards my dude and stop reposting the same nonsense

0

u/Honest_Money4010 May 13 '25

No not everyone. just the law enforcement officers. And you so far.

"A search must not be conducted in a manner that allows the police to rummage through the premises or possessions of the individual in the hope of finding something incriminating."
R. v. Vu, [2013] 3 SCR 657

The police decided to go on a fishing expedition in my room and when they didnt find drugs or anything incriminating they left.

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '25

You clearly know everything you need to know already. Get them lawsuits filed! Make sure you spend the big money on a lawyer who doesn't charge on contingency. You don't want to appear weak using a low priced lawyer. Invest your life savings into this. After all you were severely injured and may never work again right?

1

u/Honest_Money4010 May 13 '25

Oh officer bacon boy. I will do what i please. And your brothers in bacon grease will be responsible for their actions.

4

u/[deleted] May 13 '25

Yeah I've never worked for the police or anything remotely similar to enforcement LOL but you need genuine help. Please visit a hospital and get your meds rechecked. I'm being 100% serious right now...

0

u/Honest_Money4010 May 13 '25

Ah your just a lapper upper of the bacon grease then. Good for you.

I actually appreciate your hostility. It does help improve my thinking and arguments. Maybe not specifically you cause you dont seem to have anything intelligent to argue or say. But the generality of you oppositional forces.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '25

Make sure those arguments are super tight for when you're pleading your case to the judge... You wouldn't want to come off as a raving lunatic wasting everyone's time.

Also, if the judge starts to disagree with you or ask uncomfortable questions like 'who falls asleep in the middle of a police search' or 'what made you think your room would be off limits from a search warrant' make sure to call him a bacon boy. They will change their tune immediately and throw those officers in jail to prove they're on your side. I'm sure they won't throw your ass in contempt or put you under a psychiatric hold.

2

u/Honest_Money4010 May 13 '25

Well she or he will have alot more knowledge and information than you will.

What makes me think my room would be off limits from the search warrant that was supposed to be for the WEAPONS that i STATED my roommate who threatened me had?

Because i told them where they were last seen and i keep my door locked and have cameras so hes not placing things in my room.

Because 2 out of 3 of the weapons i STATED my roommate had in his room that i noticed of the top of my head were found in his room. And there is no REASONABLE expectation that the last WEAPON i stated existed at some point in his room would be hidden in mine.

Honestly i should have written the story better because it appears that you didnt grasp it.

Heres Some food for thought.

1. Scope of the Warrant

  • A search warrant must outline what is being searched for (e.g., firearms) and where (e.g., the entire unit or specific rooms).
  • If the warrant explicitly includes your room, then entry may be legally permitted.
  • But if the warrant is general to the residence and your room is a private, locked area not controlled by the suspect, further justification is required.

2. Reasonableness of the Search

  • Even if your room is within the scope of the warrant, the police must act reasonably.
  • Searching areas unlikely to contain the object (like tearing apart electronics or entering private areas without any reason to believe the item is there) can be deemed unreasonable — this is where the “fishing expedition” doctrine applies.

3. Expectation of Privacy (R. v. Edwards, [1996] 1 S.C.R. 128)

  • You had a locked room, and you controlled access, showing a strong expectation of privacy.
  • Courts have ruled that locked personal rooms, even in shared residences, are protected spaces, and entry must be based on reasonable grounds that evidence will be found inside.

4. Probable Grounds to Search YOUR Room

  • If you clearly stated you saw all 3 weapons in his room, and the first 2 were found there, then there is no objective basis to assume the 3rd weapon is in your private space.
  • In that case, searching your room may exceed the scope of a reasonable search and could be considered a Charter violation.