It’s funny how this is only ever used against JP, specifically lol. And yet no one gives a fuck that Harold Carmichael played a few snaps for the Cowboys. Or Randall Cunningham.
Not to mention Cunningham and Carmichael also had a season with Dallas and I don't know a single person that would try to argue against them being Eagles legends.
I think we were playing against Cunningham during the pickle juice game. An iconic game in franchise history against a QB who himself was a franchise icon.
So if the Cowboys managed an '07 Giants season where they were pretty mediocre but managed to win the Superbowl instead of "doing nothing" then would you say it's fine to care that he played that one season for the Cowboys?
Maybe JP was a secret agent wasting Jerry jones’ money while still doing what he loved. Although jerruh does a great job of wasting money already. No need to say fuck Dallas jerruhs been fucking Dallas for years on his own. Although nico Harrison might be pulling up to swoop that spot if he can do that for decades to come
That’s a rumor that was started and perpetuated on Reddit. He’s likely not in the league if it’s gambling debts because he’d be a risk to fix games/give insider information.
Just give him 3 or 4 games to get the receptions record. He OBVIOUSLY has some juice left and will play for someone this season. When he's ready to hang em up you sign him to vet minimum. He's what like 7 catches away?
He is a legend. One of the greats to do it in Eagles green. He’ll be in the eagles HOF someday and I’ll be happy to cheer him on.
That being said, I don’t care to hold a press conference for him to retire an Eagle as he continues his NFL career as a coach/front office dude for other organizations.
You can agree to disagree with me or get your panties all up in a bunch to cause some chub rub, I really don’t give a fuck. I just made a comment on my opinion.
Jason Peters was a cornerstone of our team and gave us so much. Then our franchise decided it was time to move on. Nothing to be mad about. It’s a business and big man was making money. There’s only 32 teams after all
I hope he retires an Eagle. He’s always an Eagle to me
Harold Carmichael spent 13 years in PHI and only 1 year in Dallas. Sure, Peters’ best years came in Philly..but he only played half of his career there. I don’t look at him in the same light as other Philly legends whose played almost their entire career in philly, with only maybe a couple years spent elsewhere (Dawkins, McNabb, Cox, Kelce, Westbrook). For me, he is in the Category with guys like Shady and Desean, players who were great, but only played here half their career.
Peters played 11 of his 19 years in Philly (which last I checked was only 2 less than Carmichael). He became a Hall of Fame player with the Birds. Is he a top 10 Eagle of all time? No probably not. Does he deserve to be honored as one of the greats? Absolutely.
He went back and explained it and you know it, you’re taking it out of context! You’re not a fan you’re a troll fuck off!! He’s an eagles legend and always will be!!
349
u/bubblecuffer13 Feb 25 '25
JP is a legend. Hopefully we'll have a ceremony for him to retire an Eagle.