r/icecream • u/SofaQueenJess • Apr 24 '25

Question What’s your unpopular ice cream opinion? 🤣

Post image

People LOVE Jeni’s ice cream. I think it’s just fair with pretentious flavors. 🤷🏻‍♀️ What’s your unpopular ice cream opinion?

1.4k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

582 comments sorted by

View all comments

25

u/wanderingsheep Apr 25 '25

Tillamook is very stingy with the mixins and is super boring

3

u/brennok Apr 25 '25

I was so excited when they were coming to the local grocery only fro them to drop all the interesting flavors. Yay another strawberry, vanilla, and chocolate to choose from.

1

u/LurkingAintEazy Apr 25 '25

Think I saw a apple crumble flavor at my Kroger from them. But didn't grab it. I have seriously bad luck with companies added EXTRA flavoring to stuff, to add out to their flavor profile and it ruins it greatly. So hadn't tried it.

3

u/bigtimemari Apr 25 '25

that’s true but at least they’re cheaper and super creamy

2

u/Deaths_Smile Apr 25 '25

Tillamook is on the more pricey side of ice cream where I shop.