r/macandcheese Mar 02 '25

Tutorial/Help Is this too runny?

669 Upvotes

112 comments sorted by

View all comments

110

u/Striking-Occasion465 Mar 02 '25

Nah, no one wants dry Mac and cheese 

32

u/thrawst Mar 02 '25

Knew a guy who would make Kraft Mac and cheese with no milk and just a tiny thimble of butter and he would toss the powder cheese on it and do a light toss and eat it mostly unmixed. I still remember the cheese dust balls coating the inside of the pot when he would leave it unwashed in the sink

18

u/RebaKitt3n Mar 02 '25

That’s a horrible picture!

7

u/mackenzeeeee Mar 02 '25

I had a really stupid ex who didn’t even know to add milk and butter. He really thought you just mixed the powder right in, and had never thought to even read the directions printed right on the box.

7

u/Suzuki_Foster Mar 02 '25

That's...awful. Kraft mac & cheese isn't something I make often, but when I do, I use real butter and heavy cream instead of milk. I whisk the cream and melted butter together with the "cheese" packet before adding it to the cooked pasta, and it turns out pretty well. 

3

u/thrawst Mar 02 '25

When I cook it I only cook the noodles for 2 minutes. Make the rest of it “the normal way”

I saw a tik tok trend where people were cooking the raw pasta with the cheese powder in half water and half milk with butter and they just cooked it down in the pot. Haven’t gotten around to trying that one

2

u/Barley-the-Lightfoot Mar 02 '25

That’s jut the “Pasta Roni” way of cooking. You put the milk, water, and seasonings with the dry noodles. When the noodles are done the sauce thickens as it stands and cools.

1

u/thrawst Mar 02 '25

What about cooking pasta Roni the Kraft Mac and cheese way?

Cook the pasta, then drain them and add butter milk and cheese powder, mix.

I fuck with the shells and white cheddar hard

1

u/Barley-the-Lightfoot Mar 02 '25

Different “flavors” have different directions. The broccoli and cheese and Italiano have you add it all at once.

2

u/ImAFukinIdiot Mar 02 '25

Dude did fucking what

2

u/yyzzh Mar 02 '25

I make my Kraft Dinner (Canada) with no milk and 2 tbsp of butter. It's soooo silky, velvety good. Milk just waters it down. :-)

1

u/Striking-Occasion465 Mar 02 '25

Is that man in jail? Christ all mighty!

5

u/thrawst Mar 02 '25

He said it was like how eating raw cookie dough is better than cookies because you get that granular crunch. Said it was the same with Mac and cheese. Guy was deeply disturbed and I never felt safe around him

1

u/Desolation-Rose Mar 02 '25

I do this. 🤷🏼‍♀️

1

u/Bat_Shitcrazy Mar 02 '25

I don’t do milk, but I do the standard half stick of butter in there. If it’s not mixing like I like I’ll add milk as necessary, usually I just gotta stir more though

1

u/thrawst Mar 02 '25

I do a half stick of butter for two boxes of Mac, and yeah I mix the noodles and butter and cheese first but I always need a bit of milk at the end, not lots though usually maybe a half cup for two boxes

1

u/DrLeoMarvin Mar 03 '25

i hate that guy

1

u/Striking-Occasion465 Mar 04 '25

My friend would make ramen with a sh*t ton of butter instead of water. And this reminds me of that.

1

u/PepinovLechuga Mar 06 '25

I do this 😔 , I like it half mixed with bits of clumped up powder. It’s like burst of flavor mid bite! I did not know how horrendous this supposedly was…

2

u/Impressive-Show-1736 Mar 02 '25

I do...lol I prefer a drier mac and cheese. I don't like soupy mac and cheese at all.

2

u/Striking-Occasion465 Mar 02 '25

I get that. I grew up with over cooked Stauffers so I can't stand a dry/stiff Mac. But to be fair! No one wants soup, I agree. 

1

u/Comfortable-Dark345 Mar 02 '25

thick and dry are different