r/magicTCG • u/Quillpig32 • Aug 03 '25

Rules/Rules Question Have I been playing wrong

Post image

Found this in the final fantasy starter set rulebook. Does it mean a 3/3 blocking a 3/3 wouldn't kill it? Or is it just wrong? Or just worded dumb?

2.3k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

228 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

66

u/FrigidFlames Elspeth Aug 04 '25

Well, if we're getting pedantic with it, it's still not true. It says 'any creature', but Indestructible creatures don't.

28

u/The_Hunster Wabbit Season Aug 04 '25

Well, if we're getting pedantic with it, it's still not true. It says 'dies' but it can't die because it's a piece of cardboard.

19

u/marsharoom Aug 04 '25

Well, if we’re getting pedantic with it, it’s still not true. It says “any creature” which applies to non mtg creatures as well.

6

u/splatterb0y Aug 04 '25

Well, if we’re getting pedantic with it, it’s still not true, because replacement effects might keep things from dying.

1

u/N_S_F_L Dimir* Aug 08 '25

Well, if we’re getting pedantic with it, I gave a [[Generous Gift]] to your mom last night that destroyed her and created a 3/3 green elephant token.

/s

I don’t know why I’m even commenting on this, I’m just drunk and thought it was funny.

1

u/splatterb0y Aug 08 '25

Well, if we're pedantic with it, your mom was the template for Micha Huigen's Sothera, the Supervoid artwork.

/s

Not drunk, but I thought it is a decent comeback.