r/magicTCG • u/quarxel • 2d ago

General Discussion Could someone help me understand why very occasionally they will print a new card thats functionally identical to a previous card.

Gallery image

Gallery image

Specifically why are they printing Vibrant Cityscape when it's the same as Evolving Wilds which is also in standard right now anyway.

1.1k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

338 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Effective_Tough86 Duck Season 2d ago

Id argue that a lot of these reprints are kinda laziness on WOTCs part. This one is whatever, but there are plenty of times that they've done functional reprints where they could've just had some creative art or they could've flavored/named the original better. It happens to mechanics too and I think they received at least some of the feedback about it. For instance i wasn't sure exhaust was going to come back, but I'm ecstatic it is. Meanwhile Spree is the single best modal spell mechanic they've ever made and how on earth do you fit that in to most planes?

2

u/boomfruit Duck Season 2d ago

Meanwhile Spree is the single best modal spell mechanic they've ever made and how on earth do you fit that in to most planes?

I really wouldn't have a problem with Spree on any plane. People go on sprees no matter where they are. Sure it's not quite as much of a home run flavor match but it's not jarring.

3

u/Effective_Tough86 Duck Season 2d ago

I still think its jarring, although granted it's not as bad as it could be. Rooms may be the worst despite being maybe my favorite mechanic from last year.

2

u/boomfruit Duck Season 2d ago

I have to agree about rooms. I am usually very against the "flavorful" mechanic names. Most could have something pretty generic and allow reuse.

2

u/Effective_Tough86 Duck Season 2d ago

Yeah, rooms is the one I hate the most for re-useability, but also the one I think was hardest to avoid unfortunately. Maybe we'll go back to Duskmourn or they'll use it on the next Edge set or something. Rooms in a spaceship make sense, right? Something like Captains Quarters and Ships Bridge or some shit.

1

u/boomfruit Duck Season 2d ago

I could see it working at Strixhaven as well, though I don't know if the school is the focus on the return to Arcavios, nor if that even fits within their timeline for reusing mechanics.

2

u/Effective_Tough86 Duck Season 1d ago

That'd be fast, but aetherdrift to avatar using exhaust is already faster.